News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by rightos on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @10:11AM (#15400557)
Very interesting, any information about a target price range?
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by opencl on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @10:45AM (#15400794)
This is an IP core rather than an actual SoC so the pricing will obviously depend on what else gets packaged with it, but based on the core+caches area of 0.538mm^2 on 28nm it should be competitive with the Cortex A7/A53/A35. As seen in Allwinner A64, Raspberry Pi, etc. It does say 2MB of L2 cache whereas most quad A53 SoCs I've seen have 512KB so the cost is probably going to be a bit higher from that. But full SoCs are likely going to be in the $5-$10 range.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by mtgx on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @11:39AM (#15401253)
1.7 DMIPS/MHz seems to put it in the range of Cortex A5, maybe Cortex A7. But it also targets significantly higher clock speeds of 1.5GHz, so it may be faster than Cortex A7 in the real world. Probably not faster than A53/A35, but it should be close enough. Plus it has some additional features.

https://www.cnx-software.com/2015/04/09/relative-performance...

What may hurt it more in the market is the name. Most companies seem to underestimate its importance. U54-MC Coreplex doesn't exactly roll off the tongue...That means it's that much easier to ignore and forget about it. Hopefully whatever SoC will use it will have a better name.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by userbinator on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @09:32PM (#15406184)
To compare with x86, 1.7 DMIPS/MHz is slightly less than the original Pentium (P5) at 1.88 DMIPS/MHz, and well behind the Pentium Pro (P6) at 2.7 DMIPS/MHz. Later x86 microarchitectures are vastly more efficient, with modern i7s achieving closer to 10 DMIPs/MHz.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Million_instructions_per_secon...

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by jabl on Thursday October 05, 2017 @05:47AM (#15407853)
Isn't this pretty good then? P5-level performance/MHz from a pretty simple in-order scalar processor. And it clocks at 1.5GHz whereas the P5 topped out at around 200MHz. Though I suppose if you'd manufacture a (slightly tweaked) P5 on a modern process you'd reach similar clock speeds too...
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by makapuf on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @01:11PM (#15402045)
Well the esp8266 80386, x86-64 or 741 chips didn't perform too bad either. ( I know x86 64 was an arch and not a chip)
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by ant6n on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @06:20PM (#15405227)
u54 rolls off the tongue. Sounds like a u-boot, too. With a night club.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by petra on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @10:53AM (#15400861)
The raw cost of the coreplex's silicon is probably ~7 cents. of course there's extra stuff that goes into a soc, but why do you assume it will go from 7 cents to $5-$10 ? is it because the cost of the A53 etc is insignificant ?
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by pdq on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @11:30AM (#15401169)
You have to take into account the end product, not just raw silicon cost.

There are costs in SoC packaging, wire bonding, testing, yield loss, warehousing, distribution, R&D, and profit.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by imtringued on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @03:07PM (#15403438)
Because it will cost you 10 million dollars+ to produce your first chip. Every chip after that costs you 7 cents.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by simonh on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @12:27PM (#15401659)
I suppose the money for the wages of all the people working at the billion dollar silicon chip fab plant has to come from somewhere.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by pjc50 on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @12:05PM (#15401486)
Since when have the silicon costs been the slightest bit relevant to IC pricing? It's all about volume and recouping R&D costs and other NRE.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by topspin on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @01:28PM (#15402215)
This discussion brings to mind something Gordon Moore explained[1] about the economics of chip fabrication. According to this Intel co-founder it's all about selling silicon real-estate:

    What we end up doing is really selling real estate. We've sold area on
    the silicon wafer for about a billion dollars an acre, that order of
    magnitude, as long as I've been in the industry. Individual transistors
    used to sell for a few billion dollars an acre. The microprocessors
    today, too.  Maybe DRAMs are something under a billion.
So the cost of fabricating a wafer full of devices doesn't change much over time, but shrinking features means you get more devices for that cost. Notice the difference he points out between microprocessors and DRAM: all the costs involved with highly complex devices like CPUs ultimately still fall within the same order of magnitude as the cost of simple DRAM devices. The cost is some small number of "billions per acre" whether you're making the latest cutting edge circuit or just more arrays of bits.

[1] https://www.intel.com/pressroom/archive/speeches/gem93097.ht...

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by marcosdumay on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @02:41PM (#15403129)
That's because there was some sweet spot under that figure. Bigger, lower tech transistors lead to a more expensive chip because it was too big, and smaller higher tech transistors lead to bigger costs because few companies could make them.

Unfortunately, that is all history. Current top of line fabrication processes cost more per area than their ancestors.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by monocasa on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @12:13PM (#15401551)
Yeah, but this core is open source, which significantly reduces the NRE costs for most integrators.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by pjc50 on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @12:25PM (#15401642)
It looks like (although not 100% clear) it's available as hard IP, which means they've done the layout, but the very expensive mask NRE remains.

(They have a plan for an actual SOC but aren't shipping yet: https://www.sifive.com/documentation/freedom-soc/freedom-u50... )

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by opencl on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @01:44PM (#15402403)
The RISC-V ISA is free (i.e. you can design your own core without paying royalties to a company like ARM, which is what SiFive has done here) but this is a normal paid-for IP core. They do have some SoCs with a "free and open platform specification" but there's no public repo to download their Verilog code from.

If you want an actual open source RISC-V core, see: https://github.com/lowRISC/lowrisc-chip

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by asb on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @03:01PM (#15403375)
Hi, I'm one of the co-founders of the lowRISC project. You're right that SiFive's licensing arrangements can be somewhat confusing. Although they sell licenses (like https://static.dev.sifive.com/business/sifive-license-and-su...) which look like a typical proprietary IP agreement, the SiFive Coreplex IP is a derivative of the open-source Rocket chip generator. SiFive was founded by a team from Berkeley who produced Rocket, and are almost certainly now the biggest contributor to ongoing Rocket development.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by monocasa on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @03:14PM (#15403528)
Off topic question: has there been any work yet on a TileLink IOMMU? I was playing around with writing one, but didn't want to put in the effort if you guys or SiFive were just around the corner from releasing your own.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by asb on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @03:31PM (#15403727)
It's not something we've worked on so far at lowRISC. If SiFive have been working on something in that area I haven't seen them talk about it publicly.

Sounds like a great project, if you do start working on it I'd love to discuss more.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by phkahler on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @04:40PM (#15404418)
>> the SiFive Coreplex IP is a derivative of the open-source Rocket chip generator.

Any idea why they didn't drop in the BOOM core then? The EE Times article puts it at 30mm^2 with the L2 cache, so even a larger BOOM core wouldn't increase the die size much. Or are they aiming for really low power first? I could see a whole family of these coming over time. I hope this all goes really well.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by _chris_ on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @05:45PM (#15404988)
While they could easily drop in a BOOM core, there would be some very non-trivial costs for SiFive to verify the IP and tune up the performance and feature set to match their costumers' needs. A lot of work has been put into Rocket once it made the transition from academic to professional and they would have to do that again for BOOM.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by jabl on Thursday October 05, 2017 @05:39AM (#15407815)
Also, there was quite recently a BOOMv2 paper describing some improvements, and hints of low-hanging fruits for further work. So I wouldn't be surprised if we'd have at least BOOMv3 before anybody commits to taping it out on ASIC.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by phkahler on Thursday October 05, 2017 @01:32PM (#15410906)
You just wrote that in response to a comment by one of the BOOM and BOOMv2 creators. And yes, there was more than just hints at low hanging fruit, so I'm hoping a v3 is in the works. But all those guys seem to be incredibly busy just giving birth to this (risc-v) thing.

BTW, just to put it in writing I'm estimating the BOOMv2 clock at 2.5GHz on 28nm. Depending how much IPC they clawed back it might match the A15 on coremark.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by jabl on Thursday October 05, 2017 @02:33PM (#15411470)
> You just wrote that in response to a comment by one of the BOOM and BOOMv2 creators.

Oh. Oops.. :)

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by monocasa on Thursday October 05, 2017 @11:23AM (#15409907)
The BOOMv2 authors apparently had taped it out in TSMC 28 nm HPM.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by opencl on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @03:13PM (#15403519)
Thanks for the clarification, it's not at all obvious from the website. The actual target audience buying $600k core licences is probably aware of all of this anyway.
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by monocasa on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @02:12PM (#15402757)
The source here isn't their core?

https://github.com/sifive/freedom

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by opencl on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @02:36PM (#15403080)
That code seems to be for an FPGA devkit for their SoC but using an entirely different CPU core, the Berkeley Rocket Chip.

They're selling coreplex licenses for several hundred thousand dollars (not the one in the linked product page, it isn't for sale yet): https://dev.sifive.com/coreplex-risc-v-ip/buy/rtl/e51_corepl...

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by _chris_ on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @03:09PM (#15403455)
> using an entirely different CPU core, the Berkeley Rocket Chip

Nope, the U54 and E31 are both Rocket, just with different parameters/configurations.

SiFive has continued to improve Rocket and contribute their improvements back to the available source code.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by monocasa on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @02:57PM (#15403331)
SiFive is a bunch of Berkeley people. Are you totally sure that their cores aren't rebranded Rocket cores?
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by petra on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @03:27PM (#15403690)
If that's the case, why there's such strong r&d effort on die minimization ?
Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by Nokinside on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @05:21PM (#15404815)
To increase number of transistors without compromising speed and reduce energy consumption.

Nobody voluntarily transfers cost decreases to customers unless they have to.

Re:RISC-V based 64-bit quad-core application processor by zitterbewegung on Wednesday October 04, 2017 @10:14AM (#15400564)
Doesn't look like it but I would sign up on the bottom to get more info. (aside it should be on the top of the page)