It's also worth noting in many areas arrest quotas are outright illegal.
What departments do typically do is look at distributions. Say on a Friday evening shift, over the past 12 month period, a typical officer typically has 16-18 speeding stops.
However, during the same Friday evening shift, an offer typically writes 1-2 for the past months. Why? Maybe it's something explainable. Maybe it's the officer isn't doing a good job.
But that's the intent of looking at distribution. It's not to say the officer has to write 16-18, but if it turned out they were slacking off, they may easily see it that way.
Arrest quotas are obviously and undeniably real, they've been documented numerous times in various contexts. The most recent major case of many such examples in NYC was the Adrian Schoolcraft case: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adrian_Schoolcraft
““It’s an easy way to make an arrest. And they’re under pressure to make arrests.” A poster on Officer.com, a verified online message board for law enforcement officers, put it bluntly in 2013 when he advised a rookie to be on the lookout for “GKs”: “make sure they have a prior conviction so you can bump it up to that felony!!!”
So, there may not be quotas, but it’s pretty clear that there is pressure to deliver arrest numbers, especially felony arrests. A different mechanism that drives the same behavior.
Speeding tickets are a perfect example. The sergeant has a life outside work - he gets days off, he runs errands, he drives to and from work. And all the while he sees people doing stupid stuff just like the rest of us. So it's hard for him to imagine his officers can drive around for an entire shift and never see someone speeding, running a red light, or making an illegal u-turn.
What do you think your boss would do if you sat at your desk and did nothing all day?
Then they should stop and cite those violations. No one said that the police should not write tickets for minor misdemeanors. The complaint is the practice of using those misdemeanors as a way to pad their productivity, and by extension their department's budget.
Police departments should be a sunk cost. There shouldn't be pressure to make arrests, as an arrest can only be made when someone breaks the law and is caught. Look at the whole Arpaio mess. Sure, Illegal Immigrants are here illegally, but it's a national problem, not a local problem. We've sat complaining (at least we were as of last year before shit got fucked) that the feds are going after medical marijuana dispensaries in CA despite the fact that locally, those dispensaries are by-and-large complying with local laws. An illegal immigrant in Arizona isn't all that different. They may be breaking a federal law, but they're a productive member of their community. They aren't breaking any local laws, and it's been ruled countless times that local police departments should not be enforcing those laws much like a local patrolman can't really arrest and cite someone for treason. It's above their pay grade. When you do have departments focusing on one kind of violation, like treason or illegal immigration, as Arpaio ended up doing, the department pulls resources from other violations, like rape and statutory rape, that are mostly violent crime with victims that want justice for the pain and suffering they endured by their neighbors. Those are the people that should be arrested, and the fortunate (or unfortunate) reality is that a lawful community will have officers that are not "productive".
The evidence for that is spotty at best, and you're missing the point, which is cops won't write tickets (or make arrests) at all unless they're pushed to do so.
Let me add another example. Where I live there's a massage parlor every other block or so. Everybody knows these places are giving happy endings. If there are a hundred brothels (let's call them what they are) in the city, it's not unreasonable for the police chief to say to the vice squad "You have the manpower to shut down at least three of these places every month, so if that doesn't happen I'll want to know why." That's perfectly legitimate management.
This is incorrect. Almost every law enforcement organization in the United States tracks the number of arrests made by each officer, and there is ample evidence that this information is used when making personnel and staffing decisions.
Also, many municipalities track arrests by organizational unit (in NYC it is per precinct), and when management (police chief) requires that mid-level management (commanding officer) "get their numbers up", you have exactly the same incentive to commit fraud that you see in places like Wells Fargo.
Also, rather than taking my word for it, you should look at the many, many, many, many news articles that have been done on the subject. There's the first google hit (http://www.nbcnewyork.com/investigations/NYPD-Lieutenant-Say...), feel free to look at the first 200 search results for corroborating reports.
No it isn't! In New York City, of course there are arrest quotas.
As a matter of fact, NYPD officers will arrest innocent people, on entirely trumped-up charges, just to make quota.
Pro tip, avoid German train stations if you're not white.
Avoid using the major traffic hubs. No joke. Cops here will even fleece you on the spot sometimes if you're black. They seem to believe that all black or rasta wearing persons are dope dealers.
But somehow enforcement of the law is "oppression"
It's like saying "most programs crash on a daily basis because computers are soooo fast and there are soooo many crashing opportunities". You going about your daily business will probably not be breaking laws.
If you're running a grocery store, however.....
The list of laws and regulations that are in effect in the US is enormous. Luckily most of them aren't enforced consistently.
It seems to me that the motivation for such a law to apply to such a common tool is for prosecutors to have a tool to leverage during prosecution.
The general wisdom in the knife community is to not make a scene or rock the boat if you've got any pocket knife on you and UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES use a pocket knife to defend yourself(even under thread of life or limb). There's a metric ton of laws about using knives and weapons(even in self defense, largely tied to gang enforcement) and prosecutors tend to aggressively pursue them. In a lot of cases you'd be under less legal jeopardy drawing a pistol with a CCW than a small pocket knife.
Knife laws are also enforced on a per-city basis(aside from the assisted knives which are generally state-level). So one town might have a length limit of 3" where the next town over might be 3.5". It's almost impossible to not run afoul of some local ordinance.
Long time ago, acquaintance was assaulted/mugged on a platform and defended self with a boxcutter. Subsequently had to go to trial and defend actions. IIRC, took a while to get things cleared even tough it was self-defense. But maybe it wasn't as onerous as it could have been with a real knife.
Clearly that person has never read the GPL, all of the legalese is clearly explained in the license. The GPL has always been my go to as an example of an easy to read and understand legal document.
It's not about "reading the GPL". It's about power.
If the only people allowed to decide morality / ethics / legality are lawyers, then they have power, and you don't. This is fantastic for the people in power. Less so for you.
Outlawing certain types of guns & knives also exposes the population to selective enforcement, civil asset forfeiture, & other means to tyranny.
Of course, there are practical limits, like it probably wouldn't behoove us to ensure that everybody has a right to carry a briefcase nuclear bomb.
It's about creating a cogent system of checks & balances that acknowledges that people oppress each other. A system that acknowledges that politics can be a vehicle of liberation/oppression, that the voting public can be educated/deceived, & that people unite or devolve into tribes.
That really isn't the first order way one protects themselves from criminal elements. Even if you are Jason Bourne, living in a mad max wasteland you will not live long. Whereas millions of people with zero self defense skills can go through their whole lives never having to defend themselves at all in civilized societies.
It isn't even clear if keeping powerful weapons around in a civilized place is a net win on safety. Yes there is some chance you may successfully defend yourself from criminals, but that is very low, maybe lower than the chance of having an accident or some other negative results of owning the weapon.
This is a false dichotomy. Banning legal gun ownership does not mean a civilized society (i.e. Bordertowns in Mexico) & protecting legal gun ownership does not mean a Mad Max Society.
> It isn't even clear if keeping powerful weapons around in a civilized place is a net win on safety.
The maxim is one of preventing asymmetric power. Legal Gun Ownership is an effective strategy to check the lethal power of the state, cartels, gangs, etc.
Hitler, Stalin, & Mao used gun control to give the state a monopoly on violence. Many societies that have gun control are relatively safe, but many with gun control also devolve into a case where the criminal elements gain power & rule due to a monopoly on violence.
Mexico does not allow legal gun ownership yet Sinaloa, Los Zetas, MS-13, & corrupt Federales own guns. The law abiding population suffers (in horrific ways) as a result.
Chicago has some of the strongest gun control laws in the USA; yet, gang members don't seem to want to follow the law...and the violent crime rates hold testament to the consequences.
Legal gun ownership is one of many strategies to implement. It's a particularly effective safeguard when you have political/demographic/cultural/societal dynamics that are less than ideal to ensure that law abiding citizens have a shooting chance.
"Chicago has some of the strongest gun control laws in the USA; yet, gang members don't seem to want to follow the law...and the violent crime rates hold testament to the consequences."
The cat is out of the bag in the USA. Guns are everywhere, and the Constitution permits it. You cannot change a society like that overnight, even with the best will in the world. You can put effort in tightening the grips, apparently like in Chicago, but that doesn't mean its going to be followed. Especially not by criminals. The other part of strict gun laws, is actively enforcing them. One big advantage when you do see a gun in such case is: either its an undercover cop (unlikely) or a criminal (that means: freeze or flight, since you don't have a gun). In the USA you got far too much fight instead of flight, the source underlines that.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/14/upshot/compare-these-gun-...
I don’t think you know what a lawyer is. You’re respectively describing legislators, prosecutorial administrators, and various forms of politicians. These people may or may not be lawyers.
Here in germany we have a law, that rules that if somebody dies without a last will- all his belongings are shared in percentage among his decendants - creating the "Erbengemeinschaft". In theory this is a good law.
In reality, this generates even among the best familys,as it allows for a group of decendants to manage the common fortune- especially if a company is at stake, a huge chance for a infinite conflict that lasts until the last of the fortune is used up by lawyers. Its insane and nobody gains from this. Jobs are lost, lives are shattered for nothing, brothers and sisters never talk again to one another- if there ever was a law to ensure enployment of a disgusting profession - this is it. If you wanted peace- the law would be salomonic, slice the fortune instantly, conflict solved.
Most legislators aren't also actively practicing lawyers and are not writing laws with the aim of giving themselves more business.
It also ties in with the fact that, like it or not, we need lobbyists. Sure, the system is broken, but legislatures can't be experts on everything. So, they need people to explain and even be able to get into the details. They need someone who is a domain expert.
That is, theoretically at least, why we have to have lobbyists. Legislatures should also have a good baseline knowledge of the legal system, with all the details that includes. They need to be very familiar with the legal system which makes lawyers potentially good legislatures.
Potentially... Like lobbyists, there's good and bad with the system. There is potential for good, as much as there is potential for bad. We seem to like to think we are in dire straits and that doom faces us constantly, but we are actually doing quite well. We're not perfect, but we aren't as bad off as the nightly news would have us believe.
Also, people really hate lawyers, until they need one. I'm not a lawyer but I have great respect for some of them.
https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R44762.pdf (page 2 shows 218 lawyers in congress)
http://library.clerk.house.gov/documents/Lawyers.pdf
>or write them
Congress doesn't really write laws. K-street (lawyers) tend to write them in conjuction with congress (lawyers) staff helping.
>vote on them.
See above two links.
Please now clarify how I give techies a bad name?
http://www.abajournal.com/news/article/lawyers_no_longer_dom...
Did you know 70% of programmers have a degree in computer science?
To me, this is largely a result of lawyers fucking ruining everything they touch, and then not giving a shit about the lives they ruin by extension (for example, congress and k-street). It's the lawyers that are out of control here. They are the ones who got the bad law passed, they are the ones who keep allowing prosecutions to happen, they are the ones who keep the law from being challenged, etc. It's like lawyers want to be the gatekeepers to the world, but only if you pay them hefty fees. Hell, I even had someone try to tell me I shouldn't talk about GPL licensing because only lawyers understand licensing! I know lawyers are a needed entity, but they seem to have far too much power of the daily lives of people in this sense. You know what really grinds my gears though, is that these lawyers who are often at the heart of almost every injustice (even if by silent acquiescence) always pretend to be such awesome pillars of the community. I think we should start throwing lawyers in jail for such bullshit laws until you hit one powerful enough and watch the bullshit law suddenly disappear.
For anyone who wants to see video of what a real gravity knife is:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RZjXuiC8t1E
or a modern version
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5IhZWyV0QI