News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by zekevermillion on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:21PM (#15368789)
First, I do not agree that pre-selling a purely functional token is necessarily an offering of securities under Howey or otherwise. If the protocol is already specified, and the token has clear utility. I don't know if that's the case here, but just taking the article at face value.

Second, even if a particular token represents a security, offering it to the public is not "securities fraud" in and of itself. Fraud is a material misstatement or omission. What the author is talking about would be an unregistered securities offering, which if no exemption is available, would be illegal. Illegal but not necessarily fraudulent per se.

This is not to say that Colony should have an ICO. I don't know anything about their specific case. But this article is not useful to anyone else trying to make a similar decision.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by collinvine on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:32PM (#15368890)
> I do not agree that pre-selling a purely functional token is necessarily an offering of securities under Howey or otherwise

Are you a lawyer? Because it wasn't the opinion of the author; it was the opinion of their lawyers.

> offering it to the public is not "securities fraud" in and of itself.

Right. In the US, you can abide by the new-ish JOBS act for crowdfunding from non-accredited investors. You'd be selling a security. The problem with token sales is that they are trying _not_ to be securities. This may not be "fraud", but it is likely in violation of securities laws.

> this article is not useful to anyone else trying to make a similar decision.

The takeaway is that no project going forward should do a pre-functional token sale.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by zekevermillion on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:55PM (#15369127)
Yes, I'm a lawyer. I'm not your lawyer though. And it doesn't matter -- even non-lawyers are capable of reasoning about legal topics. You do not appear to be a lawyer, yet you have an opinion.

The takeaway from this article is just wrong, b/c it implies that the SEC thinks token presales are all inherently fraudulent. That is not correct.

Many ICO's are illegal securities offerings, probably. And many are also fraudulent. These two things often overlap. They are not equivalent though.

Howey is a FACT DEPENDENT TEST. That means, if you are planning any kind of token offering, you have to get advice about your specific circumstances.

As a heuristic, "stay away from ICOs" is pretty solid. No one will be harmed by this. Many people will be harmed by participating in crappy ICOs, either as promoters or buyers.

However, HN is a forum for technical discussion, and I'm criticizing the technical basis of that article.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by Sangermaine on Friday September 29, 2017 @06:39PM (#15369872)
I think you're fixating on the word "fraud" which, reading the piece, I think the author is wrongly using to describe the advice his counsel has given him since the entire discussion is about illegal securities offerings.

So, mentally set the word "fraud" aside if that's bothering you and consider the article.

>But this article is not useful to anyone else trying to make a similar decision.

If the analysis in the article is correct, it is absolutely useful. They key takeaway is this:

>Here’s the short of it. As far as we can tell, no matter what, tokens purchased for pre-functional products are securities. After it is functional, it depends.

>Here’s the short of it. As far as we can tell, no matter what, tokens purchased for pre-functional products are securities. After it is functional, it depends.

Of course, as you note below, Howey is a fact-dependent test and every offering requires its own unique examination. However, as a general guideline this is useful advice for others in a similar situation and provides guidance on the questions they should be asking about their potential ICO.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by AlexCoventry on Friday September 29, 2017 @09:37PM (#15370687)
> I do not agree that pre-selling a purely functional token is necessarily an offering of securities under Howey or otherwise. If the protocol is already specified, and the token has clear utility.

I agree it's not necessarily going to be deemed a security, and I am not a lawyer, but from my reading of Howey and related decisions I would say whether an instrument is deemed a security will come down to how it was marketed and what the general expectation and intent of the purchasers seemed to be. Since Howey emphasizes that only the function of the instrument matters, not the form, I would say that even if a cryptocurrency has use value, it could still be deemed a security if a large fraction of its purchasers mainly expect to achieve a passive profit by buying it. After reading the blog post, I can see why the Colony developers are being cautious

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by jon_richards on Saturday September 30, 2017 @06:16AM (#15372157)
Do concert tickets count as securities? What about when most of the tickets are bought by resellers using bots? Genuinely asking, seems like a badly worded law.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by AlexCoventry on Saturday September 30, 2017 @11:55AM (#15373453)
That's an interesting question. Based on this huge back and forth I think it's a gray area, where the details of the instrument matter a lot: https://www.sec.gov/divisions/corpfin/cf-noaction/ticketrese...

I don't know that it's a badly written law so much as one which gives its enforcers and arbiters a lot of latitude to decide its jurisdiction because the bad behavior it's trying to control is so hard to pin down legislatively. The law could certainly be abused, and probably has, but the cases I've read have left me with nothing but admiration for the wisdom and consideration with which it's been applied. And that's despite the fact that I have a generally libertarian bent and a general dislike of over-broad laws.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by collinvine on Saturday September 30, 2017 @12:51PM (#15373721)
It's a good question. From what I've read, they act like securities leading up to the event, but only for a one off event. Afterwards the instrument (ticket) has no value. That makes it unlike a security.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by zekevermillion on Saturday September 30, 2017 @10:15AM (#15372926)
Yes, I believe that's right.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by wmf on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:45PM (#15369027)
If the token trades on exchanges then it's no longer purely functional. And as the article says, if the function is not available yet then speculation is the only possible use.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by zekevermillion on Friday September 29, 2017 @10:24PM (#15370848)
I don't think it has to be "pure". Ethereum is not purely functional. However, it helps if it has a significant functional use.

It does seem that the best-advised projects avoid listing pre-sale tokens on an exchange. This hasn't stopped them from raising loads of money for their respective foundations, in exchange for cold wallets or invite codes.

The devil is always in the details. Very few people have the relevant experience to advise in this field with any confidence. I do not claim to be one of them.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by uiri on Friday September 29, 2017 @09:11PM (#15370572)
If they make claims in their ICO-related documents that the coin is not a security when it is in fact a security, then they are committing securities fraud. You're right that if they straight up said "this is an unregistered securities offering", it would not be fraudulent.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by kenbaylor on Saturday September 30, 2017 @10:00AM (#15372877)
That would be correct if the law was settled in this area. It is not. Generally you also need to prove intent for fraud, and if the law is not settled, it will be hard to prove fraudulent intent.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by collinvine on Saturday September 30, 2017 @12:49PM (#15373712)
One argument here is that the law is settled. If it's securities law that applies, as the SEC has started, then it's been settled for over 80 years.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by mannykannot on Friday September 29, 2017 @09:12PM (#15370578)
Could you expand on how just having a protocol specified is, in itself, useful?

As far as I can tell, no-one is saying that Colony is fraudulent, merely that its token looks like a security.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by mattbeckman on Friday September 29, 2017 @05:50PM (#15369562)
I understand the why, but ICO regulation is shifting the power of crypto from anyone (low-, middle-, upper-class) into upper-class only.

For example, the Filecoin ICO for U.S. participants was restricted to accredited investors, which required a proof of income above $200k/year. Obviously, ICOs are risky, and we can all see why someone with less income probably shouldn't invest as much money as someone making over $200k. However, preventing someone in a lower income bracket from making ANY investment feels like economic stratification.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by pavlov on Friday September 29, 2017 @06:37PM (#15369846)
The concept of accredited investors doesn’t exist in many (most?) European countries.

Private companies can sell their shares to anyone who wants to buy them, and the government has no say unless there is actual criminal fraud involved.

Americans tend to think of Europe as full of “nanny states”, but this is one instance where the United States is seriously nannying its citizens by removing a core freedom of capitalism from them.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by jMyles on Friday September 29, 2017 @06:26PM (#15369783)
I assert that this is the entire point of all economic intervention by the state.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by the_stc on Friday September 29, 2017 @06:36PM (#15369840)
Yep. And then Filecoin doesn't even sell equity! It's gross. With our company we're trying to do right by investors. We're completely in violation of the SEC memo. In fact, that's what galvanized us to 100% offer shares instead. We were going to do it before, but the SEC really set us straight: If we're going to be in violation of regulations we might as well make the most of it.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by Sangermaine on Friday September 29, 2017 @06:43PM (#15369886)
Are you saying that instead of an ICO, you've now decided to do an unregistered share offering, and you're knowingly doing this in violation of the law? You do realize you can face criminal penalties for this, right?
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by wmf on Friday September 29, 2017 @06:49PM (#15369929)
Based on previous comments it sounds like their business is fundamentally illegal anyway (prostitution?) and thus it's pointless for them to comply with SEC regulations. But this approach doesn't generalize.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by SomeStupidPoint on Friday September 29, 2017 @07:12PM (#15370062)
I disagree with the assessment that because you're committing one crime, you should commit two.

For example, lots of drug dealers get busted on tax related charges. Being the pimps busted on securities laws isn't impossible, especially if you set that up as a slam-dunk case while making the other hard to prosecute.

Not commenting on their specific case, but that reasoning is dubious.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by the_stc on Friday September 29, 2017 @07:22PM (#15370105)
We agree. For instance, we have a very strong anti-drug stance, despite not thinking it's immoral. We just don't want to draw unnecessary attacks against our platform.

The SEC thing was probably unavoidable anyways.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by the_stc on Friday September 29, 2017 @06:56PM (#15369961)
Exactly. Being ethical is more important than being legal.

To be fair, our entire business model is illegal in the US, and mostly illegal in many countries. We already have to deal with the penalties for running an escort agency.

On the plus side, it's a good business model so our chance of success is pretty high. If we end up having good returns, there will be less complaints and we'll be less of a target for the SEC organically.

We intend to be the first blockchain-funded cypherpunk unicorn. It would set a bad precedent if we didn't treat investors fairly.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by KGIII on Friday September 29, 2017 @09:15PM (#15370593)
You know you're going to prison, right?

SEC doesn't much care if you did right by investors. Hell, you're helping prove intent - right here in this post. Add conspiracy to your charges, by the way.

Seeiously, consult a lawyer. You're going to go to prison.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by the_stc on Friday September 29, 2017 @10:48PM (#15370929)
It's our view that the SEC part won't be what pushes us over the edge. 100% what we're doing is not legal, it's in our business plan. SEC won't care if investors are OK, yes. But if investors are OK, they won't be filing complaints and there will be less pressure to go after us. Not a defense! Just a delaying factor. Prosecution isn't free. Far easier to shut down ICOs that aren't operating as proper anonymous extrajurisdictional companies. They can go after us, but it's a terrible ROI for them.

But that is not what we're counting on!

Basically we asked: What if everything related to sex work was legal? What would the inevitable startup look like? With modern privacy tech, we can attempt to try it. We can ignore legal issues by operating extrajurisdictionally and anonymously.

This article discusses our technical setup: https://medium.com/@PinkApp/pink-app-trading-latency-for-ano... - excuse the clickbait title. Please let me know the flaws you see! Latency could be a killer, but we think we can mitigate it.

The core team, people that know real-world ID, are very few. Within a few months we plan to move nearly exclusively to high-latency communication methods.

By having trustless contractors run public-facing aspects of the business, the core team's opsec attack surface is drastically reduced. We have contingency plans, so even in case of arrest or death, the system can be restored from backup. Maybe one day there will be private mature smart contracts and we can codify it. Meanwhile we'll rely on lawyers and other trusted parties.

It may sound crazy ... a libertarian cypherpunk dream. But think how if you told people that it'd be popular to send non-refundable Internet money to a hidden internet service that promises to give it to an anonymous drug dealer on the other side of the planet to mail you drugs via the US Postal Service and that people would willingly trust them and it'd all be safer than using the street ... well people would have called you crazy! Yet it's popular and darknet services do exist that haven't had their operators busted.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by KGIII on Friday September 29, 2017 @11:28PM (#15371053)
> It may sound crazy ...

I don't offer an opinion on your business methods, recovery methods, or even the morality.

Instead, I point out that you're going to go to prison. As noble as you think your cause, they most absolutely will not care. Also related: I'd not count on jury nullification.

You do what you've got to do, but you are going to prison if you follow up on this plan. There are a few things one shouldn't play with; firearms, nuclear weapons, and the SEC.

If you're okay with long term incarceration and fiscal penalties that could bankrupt Bill Gates, knock yourself out. If you can be tied to your online messages declaring intent, it's really going to make for an angry judge. I've seen angry judges, they remind me of honey badgers.

Seriously, I highly recommend you seek legal council from a qualified legal professional licensed to practice in your jurisdiction. Morality and consumer complaints aren't actually things the SEC care about. They are only marginally less aggressive than the IRS.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by the_stc on Saturday September 30, 2017 @03:47PM (#15374693)
I never suggested morality will prevent a judge or jury. Just that doing fewer bad things results in fewer complains results in less likelihood of spending prosecutor effort on us. But probably when our share price hits $25+ we'll be big enough that someone will decide to go after us for real.

If our opsec fails, I'll end up in prison, very probably. That's what contingency plans are for: the project can keep operating without me. Meanwhile that's going to take a ton of effort and time, so I can the project to a point where I'm not vital.

Lawyers opinions are the same. No lawyer will advise their client to be the founder of an illegal enterprise. This is not much of an insight. Other than that, most lawyers are not capable of assessing opsec risk.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by mindslight on Saturday September 30, 2017 @05:13PM (#15375015)
Oooh prison. From what I understand, most revolutions usually involve people just dying. Granted, the customary prize is obtaining power for yourself, rather than spreading most of it around by creating a new decentralized Schelling point.

At any rate, don't you think it's a bit useless to tell someone determined to obviate the government to go ask a government agent for advice?

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by QAPereo on Saturday September 30, 2017 @11:09AM (#15373173)
Prison will be unfortunate, but it's the felony record that will really end his professional life.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by ceejayoz on Saturday September 30, 2017 @12:19PM (#15373566)
> We can ignore legal issues by operating extrajurisdictionally and anonymously.

That's what the Silk Road folks thought.

The feds can screw up a million times. You only have to do it once.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by the_stc on Saturday September 30, 2017 @04:06PM (#15374768)
You're right, opsec is stressful! That's why the core team's plan is to get the system running and then hire people to handle interactions. We will focus on things in the background. The core team will only use high-latency-methods like email. That reduces our opsec footprint very much.

And our contingency plans will enable another team to pick things up to restore from backups und continue operating.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by beepboopbeep on Friday September 29, 2017 @05:56PM (#15369598)
As if the power of crypto doesn't lie in those that can afford server farms.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by sjcsjc on Friday September 29, 2017 @12:47PM (#15366862)
Interesting discussion of the legalities. They say they're not doing the sale until they have a fully functioning platform that relies on tokens to function.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by proofofstake on Friday September 29, 2017 @04:59PM (#15369160)
But that's putting the cart before the horse. You need the ICO to get enough investment to build out your platform, when you have a fully functioning platform, who still needs investment?

And if a platform is a prerequisite: Just build the barest possible platform MVP, much like a pre-launch landing page.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by femto113 on Friday September 29, 2017 @06:44PM (#15369896)
When you have $250,000,000 with no clear nor enforceable legal obligation to the people who gave it to you, who still needs a fully functioning platform?
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by rwallace on Friday September 29, 2017 @07:36PM (#15370177)
Hopefully ethics will prompt most founders to make a good-faith attempt to deliver value for money, but in case anyone is tempted otherwise, bear in mind that the legal obligation may turn out to look much more clear and enforceable in court than it does on HN.
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by AndrewKemendo on Friday September 29, 2017 @05:12PM (#15369261)
His point is that token sales aren't investments in the sense that you are talking about because that would, in his words, be securities fraud.

The token is a "currency" that people are buying into through some exchange rate to participate in a market with token denominated currency.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by erikb on Saturday September 30, 2017 @06:13AM (#15372149)
In a high risk game like this, where the rules are actually not established yet, you always risk going to jail. No amount of lawyers can protect you. The only safety is marching forward quickly so you will be one of the top three players in this game. Number one will make the profit, number two will find a way to live, number three will be bought be either no 1 or no 2. However if you lack behind so far, that you are nuicance but don't have any real market share, you actually just need to get rid off.

So what they are doing is the opposite of what they should be doing. They should invest their money and grab market share, get as many investors on board as possible, fine tune their market strategy and technology so they can beat whoever they consider competition. Short: They should earn their place at the top.

What they do instead is waste the money to buy imaginary safety (the law about Coins is still uncertain, what can a lawyer do) and then even use it as an excuse to not move forward. There's zero chance to win this way.

Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by s73ver_ on Friday September 29, 2017 @05:56PM (#15369597)
So, what do you do with these "tokens" once you've bought them? Let's say I get 10 tokens. What happens then?
Re:The Colony token sale would have been committing securiti... by wmf on Friday September 29, 2017 @06:38PM (#15369864)
They go up ~10x (don't ask why; you don't want to know) and then you sell them.