News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by lmilcin on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @09:54AM (#15284584)
Let's assume you swiped my card and now you have full contents of my credit card.

For the fraudster to receive any funds from my account they would have to go with that data somehow to my issuing bank and have their transaction request accepted.

My bank will never do this because my card is a secure one. They expect it to generate a signed document listing the details of my transaction along with the name (ID) of the merchant and terminal performing the transaction. The message also certifies that the PIN I entered was successfully verified by my card. The message can only be created by the card using my PIN. This requires the card to be stolen along with the PIN.

The only money I can loose in case my card is stolen without the PIN is up to a floor limit for offline transactions. It's peanuts but it allows for quick transactions for example from vending machines.

The gist of the story is to move to a bank that cares for security.

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by Bartweiss on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @10:57AM (#15285196)
> The message also certifies that the PIN I entered was successfully verified by my card. The message can only be created by the card using my PIN. This requires the card to be stolen along with the PIN.

Forgive my ignorance, but aren't most sellers in America willing to process transactions (even large ones) without PIN entry?

I realize pin-and-chip is a largely secure scheme, but the chip rollout in the US hasn't actually implemented a two-factor system.

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by lmilcin on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @11:12AM (#15285314)
Credit card payment organization will hold merchants, acquirers, issuers liable for fraund if the party is lagging behind in security even if it can't be shown directly that the fraud was their fault. This is called liability shift.

http://www.emv-connection.com/best-practices/what-is-the-fra...

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by chipotle_coyote on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @12:53PM (#15286361)
The page you linked to says that gas pumps ("Automatic Fuel Dispensers") are exempted from liability shift until October of this year. But that's actually out of date information: the exemption for ATMs has been pushed to October 2017 (from the original date of October 2015), but gas pumps aren't required to go that route until October 2020:

https://usa.visa.com/visa-everywhere/security/emv-at-the-pum...

While I don't doubt they're already out there, I don't recall ever seeing a gas pump in the US with a chip reader.

Also, it's at leas worth noting that technology for skimming chip-based transactions already exists in the wild:

https://krebsonsecurity.com/2017/01/atm-shimmers-target-chip...

The "shimmers" take advantage of poor implementations of the EMV standard, but the chances strike me as fairly high that there's going to be a lot of poor implementations of EMV out there in the wild. (Not only is the less secure "chip and signature" approach common in the US, I've made more than one purchase with what could be described as "chip and nothing": put my card in a chip reader and make a purchase without being asked for either a PIN or a signature.)

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by otakucode on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @03:23PM (#15287974)
There was a presentation at either the latest Black Hat or Defcon (forget which, been watching presentations from both the past few weeks) with a live demo of a really nifty EMV fraud system. Rather than stealing card info, you'd install shimmers in a bunch of ATMs or other such places, then run a system where people could pay for access to the card at a certain location at a certain time. Walk up to the ATM and money comes out. The money comes from an account which (I believe) was being used at the time (or within a few minutes of it) on one of the far-away bugged machines.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by tedmiston on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @02:37PM (#15287529)
Correct - we only have chip, not chip + pin in the US. Sometimes the chip requires a signature and the merchant sets their own threshold.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by NegativeLatency on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @11:13AM (#15285332)
I think you're correct. I have a credit card from a major bank here and there's no pin associated with it. It does have a chip though.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @10:30AM (#15284901)
>up to a floor limit for offline transactions.

Buy stolen CCs without pin in large volume

Set up online merchant account (eBay is common), use software to scrape and copy listings for popular products that cost less than the floor amount but more than your costs. When someone orders a product and the payment clears automatically put in an order for the product on a different website (preferably one that allows a guest checkout). Automate more and more parts of the process as time goes on (e.g. using a different card when one is declined)

Keep the transaction volume low and you're basically printing money at the rate of the difference between card info cost and item cost.

This is a pretty common tactic to monetize large volumes of CC#s.

It doesn't help that most merchants don't cross reference billing address with the bank and some don't require the security code.

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by captainmuon on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @05:19PM (#15288913)
Clever, but how do you receive money in that scheme? You need an account under a fake name, right? That seems really hard to get (as it is a prerequisite for all kinds of crimes).
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by fragmede on Wednesday September 20, 2017 @11:08AM (#15294556)
Stolen CC numbers sound like hard things to get in the first place, but they're available online. Fullz (identity-stealing kits w/ SSN and driver license info) and bank drops are similarly available, for a higher fee, as well as aged accounts for many sites.
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by djsumdog on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @10:28AM (#15284895)
So the skimmers in the article are pretty basic, but there are more advanced ones that have pin hole cameras to record pins too. You could also mitm the keypad too with another patch line.

Two years ago at defcon, someone presented on advanced skimmers that could read chips too. He claimed they need a network connection to work, as there's only a two minute window to reuse the same token.

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by reaperducer on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @12:29PM (#15286103)
> You could also mitm the keypad too with another patch line.

This was noted in the article. There appears to be availability on the board for an extra connection.

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by convolvatron on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @01:16PM (#15286571)
it seems like the pin entry has to be associated with the card
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by otakucode on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @03:19PM (#15287944)
> For the fraudster to receive any funds from my account they would have to go with that data somehow to my issuing bank and have their transaction request accepted.

Not quite. The one who gets your card info probably won't use it. They will more likely sell it. If the person who buys it can't use it, whoops, too bad.

Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by tzs on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @01:48PM (#15286929)
How do large online purchases work with your card?
Re:Gas Pump Skimmers by exabrial on Tuesday September 19, 2017 @05:03PM (#15288782)
what bank?