News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Thesis and the GPL by joshkaufman on Sunday July 18, 2010 @03:33PM (#1526523)
There's a straightforward way to resolve this once and for all: if Thesis is indeed GPL, then it doesn't matter what license Pearson uses - anyone can legally copy/distribute/modify/fork/sell Thesis publicly right now, even if Pearson continues to opine that the code is distributed under a different licence. GPL is GPL.

Pearson will most likely sue the first person who actually does this (and refuses the Cease-and-Desist that precedes the suit). The courts will then determine whether or not Thesis is indeed GPL, or whether the distribution was in violation of Pearson's intellectual property rights.

Until someone actually does this, the debate will continue - there's enough ambiguity that the issue won't be resolved until ruled upon by the courts. I really doubt Matt/Automattic will push the issue - there's a lot to lose and almost nothing to gain. (Matt said in a previous thread he thinks Thesis' code is "junk" and doesn't want it in core.)

Until Thesis is publicly distributed and legally challenged, the status quo will continue: Thesis will effectively be private code, and Pearson's position will prevail.

Re:Thesis and the GPL by ekiru on Sunday July 18, 2010 @03:59PM (#1526584)
I think that this is a misconception that results from the frequent failure of people to make the distinction verbally between "Thesis is legally required to be GPL if redistributed" and "Thesis is GPL". I expect most of the people who make this mistake are aware of the distinction and are simply using "Thesis is GPL" as shorthand for "Thesis is required to be GPL", but it leads to confusion as in your comment.

IANAL, but the following is my understanding based on the my lack of awareness of anyone licensing code as GPL (even the FSF) who has ever claimed that what you suggest is legal.

Thesis is currently under whatever proprietary license Pearson distributes it under. He probably is legally required to distribute it only under the GPL. There are two obvious ways he can deal with this: stop distributing it or distribute it under the GPL. In the event that he takes the latter path, then people will be able to legally copy/distribute/modify/fork/sell Thesis. However, for now, no one has any license to Thesis' code other than what Pearson has granted them.

The GPL can't force code to be released under the GPL. It can only forbid releasing it under other terms.

Re:Thesis and the GPL by jp_sc on Sunday July 18, 2010 @05:59PM (#1526844)
The clause 5 of the GPL v2 says:

    5. You are not required to accept this License, since
    you have not signed it. However, nothing else grants 
    you permission to modify or distribute the Program or 
    its derivative works. These actions are prohibited by 
    law if you do not accept this License. **Therefore, by 
    modifying or distributing the Program (or any work based 
    on the Program), you indicate your acceptance of this 
    License to do so, and all its terms and conditions for 
    copying, distributing or modifying the Program or works 
    based on it.**
IANAL but it looks like Thesis could be implicitly GPL'ed.
Re:Thesis and the GPL by bad_user on Sunday July 18, 2010 @06:18PM (#1526900)
You have to prove first that Thesis is a derivate work ... it might seem obvious to some, but it's better to ask a real lawyer or at the very least people with adequate paralegal experience ;)
Re:Thesis and the GPL by hristov on Monday July 19, 2010 @02:58AM (#1527853)
This is a good point, but honestly I doubt this particular provision will be enforced by the courts.

If Thesis is to be held to this provision, it actually requires a contract formation, which means that the Thesis owners must have been aware of this GPL provision and must have intended to enter into a contractual relationship and all the other conditions of contract formations must have existed. This is really questionable. The Thesis owners could say that they were never aware of this provision and they never intended to be bound by it.

Of course if they say that, they will not qualify under the GPL, which may mean they are guilty of copyright infringement (if they do use GPLed code). But it is still possible that they can hold this position and accept their copyright liability (or perhaps try to use other arguments to deny their liability under copyright law). And if they do hold this position and if you have copied the Thesis code, then you are yourself guilty of copyright infringement and have no excuse.

So, I would not rely on section 5 of the GPL in this case.

This is all academic discussion, none of this is legal advice, and if you are actually considering using the Thesis software, please consult your own attorney.

Re:Thesis and the GPL by hristov on Sunday July 18, 2010 @04:09PM (#1526605)
It does not actually work like this. I am sure Thesis does include at least some original (i.e., not previously GPLed) work. Thus, the person that created that original work is the proper copyright holder. Thus, if you copy Thesis you will be guilty of copyright infringement, and the fact that it does include some GPL code won't help you.

As the matter now stands, if it is true that they use GPLed code, that means that whoever distributes Thesis is guilty of copyright infringement, which means that the owner of the original GPLed code can sue Thesis for lots of money. But that does not mean that anyone can copy Thesis.

Put in other words, the viral effect of the GPL is not automatic. If you use GPLed code in your code it does not mean that your code is automatically GPLed. It means that you have a choice to (i) voluntarily GPL your code, (ii) get rid of the GPLed code from your code or (iii) be guilty of copyright infringement and face the consequences.

This is intended as an intellectual discussion of the matter and is not legal advice.

Re:Thesis and the GPL by cheald on Sunday July 18, 2010 @05:05PM (#1526720)
I was about to argue this, but the more I thought about it, I agree with it.

To put it as I understand it, using GPL code doesn't automatically make your code GPL; it places a legal requirement on you to either license your code as GPL, or to not distribute the source or product. If the author doesn't license his software, then nobody else can take and use it, but the author is in violation of copyright due to the unlicensed use of GPL code.

The virality of the GPL is a requirement of the license, not an automatic effect upon using GPL code.

Re:Thesis and the GPL by cschwarm on Sunday July 18, 2010 @07:26PM (#1527057)
IIRC, the following article by Pamela Jones of Groklaw discusses the issue: http://lwn.net/Articles/61292/
Re:Thesis and the GPL by wzdd on Sunday July 18, 2010 @05:06PM (#1526723)
People are taking issue with the specific legal test you're proposing, but the fact that you are proposing a legal test as a way of resolving the issue is very sensible. This is a legal issue, and it should be tested using the law.

Unfortunately, or fortunately, this doesn't seem to be the way suspected GPL violations are resolved. More frequently there is a community consensus and a public shaming of the responsible company (e.g. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=790316). The issue then becomes one of how much negative publicity the company is willing to take.

IOW although "GPL violations" are described in legal terms, could be legally tested, and refer to legal documents, the issue of illegality takes second place to a fuzzier issue of "fairness", which changes from community to community and project to project.

Re:Thesis and the GPL by joshkaufman on Sunday July 18, 2010 @07:47PM (#1527105)
Absolutely - in this case, I don't think any amount of public shaming will convince Pearson to give up millions in ongoing revenue. The only way to test this legally is for someone to step up and take the risk of legal action, so a court can rule on it.
Re:Thesis and the GPL by sscheper on Sunday July 18, 2010 @03:55PM (#1526570)
Is it a crime to put your life into creating something, marketing it extremely well, attracting a ton of avid fans/users, and deciding that he or she doesn't want others undercutting the price?
Re:Thesis and the GPL by cheald on Sunday July 18, 2010 @04:55PM (#1526699)
If you violate a license as the foundation of that work? Not a crime, but certainly a civil violation of said license. Thesis' author has ignored the terms of the license of the software that he used in the construction of his own software, but ignorance does not merit pardon. Thesis, by inclusion of GPL code, is required to be licensed under the GPL. Failure to do so is unlicensed usage of the code; ie, copyright infringement. Either he is in violation of copyright by using code outside of the license, or he is in violation of the license by not GPLing Thesis itself. Either way, the author is in breach of someone's rights, and Thesis, as a work, may only be legally distributed under a GPL license.

I can't say I blame him for putting up a fight, since it's his bread-and-butter and GPLing it would cut his financial knees out from under him, but it's not even a debate at this point whether or not GPL code is included in Thesis. This is a fight that he can't win.

Re:Thesis and the GPL by ekiru on Sunday July 18, 2010 @04:01PM (#1526590)
It is illegal to take someone else's copyrighted code and create derivative works of and redistribute it in ways they have expressly forbidden you to do so in the license which gives you your right to use it.
Re:Thesis and the GPL by carbocation on Sunday July 18, 2010 @04:00PM (#1526585)
If by doing so you violate copyright law by using someone else's code in a way disallowed by the license under which you got access to the code in the first place, then yes.

(I'm not well enough versed in this particular debate to weigh in, but there is an answer to that question, in general, and it hinges on specific details of one's implementation of "creating something.")

Re:Thesis and the GPL by simonw on Sunday July 18, 2010 @04:36PM (#1526658)
Is it moral to make money from other people's work against both their wishes and the terms of their license?
Re:Thesis and the GPL by slantyyz on Sunday July 18, 2010 @06:24PM (#1526920)
Morality, Ethics, Capitalism, License Agreements and the Law... no matter how you may see that they overlap, they're all separate things.

In the end, it's the laws of the land that you're in that matters. As far as I know, I don't believe that these arguments on what is a derivative work are anything more than opinion. Settled cases are not equivalent to legal precedent.

The best thing that could happen for everyone involved is that it goes to trial and ends with a judgement, and then all this posturing and pontificating will hopefully come to a merciful end.

Re:Thesis and the GPL by hristov on Sunday July 18, 2010 @04:10PM (#1526608)
No. Copyright infringement is a crime, however.
Re:Thesis and the GPL by mgunes on Sunday July 18, 2010 @04:27PM (#1526636)
Arguably pedantic note: under most jurisdictions, copyright infringement is a non-criminal offense in civil law.
Re:Thesis and the GPL by carbocation on Sunday July 18, 2010 @04:40PM (#1526667)
To be equally pedantic but in a more geographically limited fashion: in the US, there are criminal copyright statutes. =)
Re:Thesis and the GPL by hristov on Sunday July 18, 2010 @04:42PM (#1526675)
It is a crime under US federal law, as well the laws of most industrialised countries. However, you are right in a way in that not all copyright infringement is a crime under US law.