I was about to argue this, but the more I thought about it, I agree with it.
To put it as I understand it, using GPL code doesn't automatically make your code GPL; it places a legal requirement on you to either license your code as GPL, or to not distribute the source or product. If the author doesn't license his software, then nobody else can take and use it, but the author is in violation of copyright due to the unlicensed use of GPL code.
The virality of the GPL is a requirement of the license, not an automatic effect upon using GPL code.
IIRC, the following article by Pamela Jones of Groklaw discusses the issue: http://lwn.net/Articles/61292/
As the matter now stands, if it is true that they use GPLed code, that means that whoever distributes Thesis is guilty of copyright infringement, which means that the owner of the original GPLed code can sue Thesis for lots of money. But that does not mean that anyone can copy Thesis.
Put in other words, the viral effect of the GPL is not automatic. If you use GPLed code in your code it does not mean that your code is automatically GPLed. It means that you have a choice to (i) voluntarily GPL your code, (ii) get rid of the GPLed code from your code or (iii) be guilty of copyright infringement and face the consequences.
This is intended as an intellectual discussion of the matter and is not legal advice.