5. You are not required to accept this License, since
you have not signed it. However, nothing else grants
you permission to modify or distribute the Program or
its derivative works. These actions are prohibited by
law if you do not accept this License. **Therefore, by
modifying or distributing the Program (or any work based
on the Program), you indicate your acceptance of this
License to do so, and all its terms and conditions for
copying, distributing or modifying the Program or works
based on it.**
IANAL but it looks like Thesis could be implicitly GPL'ed.If Thesis is to be held to this provision, it actually requires a contract formation, which means that the Thesis owners must have been aware of this GPL provision and must have intended to enter into a contractual relationship and all the other conditions of contract formations must have existed. This is really questionable. The Thesis owners could say that they were never aware of this provision and they never intended to be bound by it.
Of course if they say that, they will not qualify under the GPL, which may mean they are guilty of copyright infringement (if they do use GPLed code). But it is still possible that they can hold this position and accept their copyright liability (or perhaps try to use other arguments to deny their liability under copyright law). And if they do hold this position and if you have copied the Thesis code, then you are yourself guilty of copyright infringement and have no excuse.
So, I would not rely on section 5 of the GPL in this case.
This is all academic discussion, none of this is legal advice, and if you are actually considering using the Thesis software, please consult your own attorney.
IANAL, but the following is my understanding based on the my lack of awareness of anyone licensing code as GPL (even the FSF) who has ever claimed that what you suggest is legal.
Thesis is currently under whatever proprietary license Pearson distributes it under. He probably is legally required to distribute it only under the GPL. There are two obvious ways he can deal with this: stop distributing it or distribute it under the GPL. In the event that he takes the latter path, then people will be able to legally copy/distribute/modify/fork/sell Thesis. However, for now, no one has any license to Thesis' code other than what Pearson has granted them.
The GPL can't force code to be released under the GPL. It can only forbid releasing it under other terms.