People generally find #1 unpalatable, so the practical choices are #2 versus #3: do we set up some sort of general pension system to make sure elderly make at least a bare minimum income to stay off the streets (currently $20k/yr or so), or do we instead set aside money to spend on housing and caring for destitute elderly, e.g. through government-run nursing homes?
You missed the one that was used for all of human history:
4. Family ties, raise your kids well and establish that they should support you in old age. Bonus: Also gives an incentive to keep strong, healthy families together.
5. When an old person becomes useless, drug him senseless and throw him off a cliff.
Allegedly this was customary among the ancient Sardinians in pre-Roman times. The drug they used on the elderly before killing them induced a sinister grimace, giving root to the expression "sardonic grin":
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/science-news/5344257/Myst...
Interestingly, the government can also mandate compulsory euthanasia for the elderly.
I can't see it happening with short-term elections to office.
I did some casual research on this - long story short, I think the planet will support at least around 600 billion people fine. You need to speed up nitrogen cycles for food, which we can already do. Energy is the big bottleneck right now, but fusion or whatever comes afterwards will likely make energy almost-free. Further out, molecular engineering and nanotechnology looks incredibly promising...
...anyway, the world isn't really so densely populated. I couldn't find the exact paper while googling, but you could fit all of the world's population in a fairly small state (Maine?) with the same population density as present-day Paris.
More people means more great people, more innovation, more good stuff happening faster. Nitrogen cycles, food, pollution are the bottlenecks. But population 600 billion should be fine and the world will be prosperous if we get there.
Greater human population is antithetical to biodiversity and low pollution. That should probably be a greater ethical imperative than maximizing population numbers.
Also, population 600 billion doesn't happen overnight - we're almost certainly in good shape for the next 50-100 years, I'd argue the decline in population in some Western countries is a much greater threat to prosperity, health, and happiness than any increase in population could be.
This is some position I respect but disagree with. For one reason: it is pure observation bias.
Those who fail to invent at the face of Necessity take the hit, hunker down and die in anonymity. On the other hand, the ones who prevail have their names written in history as legendary inventors and innovators. Rinse a repeat over a couple thousand years and everybody knows that "Necessity is the mother of invention, and technology is usually developed in response to need".
Malthus is highly misunderstood as having stated that doom in unavoidable. What he actually said is that unconstrained population growth will eventually be forcibly constrained by hard physical and ecologic limits. I'd rather have rational planning or cultural taboos limit the max human population in any given region.
However, I prefer my necessities not to involve potential humanitarian catastrophes. The steam engine, the rapid advancement of powered flight technology, and Google were all created in response to a need, but none of these needs were of the "young people will starve and old people will be left desolate if we don't come up with something" variety.
We're not short on need for cheaper energy right now; I don't think we ever were. (More efficient agriculture is a slightly more complex subject due to political reasons.) Maybe someday we will be at a point where we can safely adopt a policy of encouraging lots of children, but right now it seems a little irresponsible.
Imagine setting one up a pension for a group of savvy investors. As you near retirement you pool your money with 10,000 other people and all split the dividend each month (based on what % you put in). As people start to die off there is a smaller pool of receptions who keep getting a larger monthly check. Granted you lose the ability to give money to your spouse/children when you die, but you don't need to worry about outliving your savings. (Assuming the fund is not mismanaged etc.)
PS: There are many problems with SS, but when you consider it's inflation adjusted it represents a vary large and vary safe investment. (Run a Monte Carlo Analysis assuming you are only willing to accept a 1% risk of running out of money at 100 and a safe retirement takes a huge nest egg.)
The simple solution is to cap the benefit and and use a large enough pool that no single death ever makes a big difference on it's own. Which gives you something like "Long Term Care Insurance" is basic a bet that you will live long enough to need it, which is subsidized by those who don't. The benefit is also fairly small so a reasonably large company is not going to try and collect.
The article suggested planning for 30 years in retirement. If that follows a working life of 40 years which follows a childhood of 25 years, then each working person is supporting 1.5 dependents. Assuming a steady-state population; if you have a baby boom followed by a baby bust followed by another baby boom, it gets worse. That's a big obligation.
Compare these scenarios: - people save for retirement, so many old people are have money to spend. Lots of young people go into occupations that help old people because that's where the money is. - the government provides pensions, so many old people have money to spend. Lots of young people go into occupations that help old people because that's where the money is.
Either way, the real-world effect is the work that young people do.
There are always risks and they can't be wished away. The government could change the pension plan. (But note that in the U.S, social security is very well defended in Congress, and more older voters makes it more secure.) Or the price of services that old people need could go up because there are fewer workers or because they dislike the work.
As an individual, having above-average savings helps, but by definition everyone can't be above-average. If all retirees double their savings and supply is fixed then inflation is inevitable. To a first approximation the only real-world solutions are to increase the number of workers (immigration or increased birth rate) or to to increase productivity so fewer younger workers are needed.
In fact that is pretty much what all such crashes are - savers losing out to the producers. Although not widely acknowledged it is practically policy to promise (in both the state & private sector) gravity defying returns and then let savers down with short sharp shocks. The actuarial assumptions for pensions are returns in the region of 6-8%. The only way savings on average can reach these returns is if there is amortized monetary inflation of 6-8% or 4-6% in real terms if you generously give 2% for productivity. This is of course significantly more than the modal average inflation rate, whence the need for 'corrections'.
The unaddressed issues are do pensions perform better than worse than average (consider during the boom private equity was routinely making 20% returns leaving less on the table for everyone else)? And what about borrowers who borrow not to invest, but because of urgency (not a significant amount of money after houses became state backed investments, which leaves gamblers, current accounts and cash in circulation to try to balance that see-saw).
Governments, and other people in general, can always screw you over. By "trusting" the government, you are just cutting out the middle men who give you a false sense of security and imperviousness to other people's actions and take a commission.
In other words, you get what we've got, which doesn't even work.
There is no chance that people could be "forced to save" as that has always turned into another tax in every place it's been implemented.
And who wants to retire? I'll retire when I'm dead, until then I'm gonna be busy doing stuff(work or otherwise). And I'm saying this as someone who's got no money.
And governments are not good at this sort of thing. Take the Irish government for example(my home country), ran a massive surplus for years during the boom, saved a nice little nest egg. It was supposed to be for public pensions(actually not supposed to, it WAS).
Then in 2008 they gave it to the banks. THEY GAVE IT TO THE BANKS!!!!!
edit: I concede that not everyone wants to work until they're in the grave.
Unless you die prematurely, no... You'll retire when you're too tired to do stuff, or when your health doesn't allow you to, or when you become unable to care for yourself in many other ways. Mostly it's not up to you when you stop "doing stuff" - even less if it's about earning money (who would hire an able and willing to work 60-70-yo these days? - realistically).
What old people who can't do anything anymore have done for millenia before social security and "retirement". Have my children take care of me.
Well that's plan B, plan A is to become very wealthy from the things I create and live off that.
And who said someone has to hire me? There are plenty of people here who work for themselves (or at least their customers). With webapps they don't even know what you look like, you could be a 90 year old dressed as Gandalf and it wouldn't matter as long as the sites good.
Not trying to say everything bad will happen, but that's a lot of assumptions... at some points you might be left with no support from yourself or family - and a lot of people find themselves in situations like that.
The bank bailout is really a bailout of people who took on mortgages they couldn't afford. People like your neighbours. Maybe even YOU. The alternative was to let nature take it's course: call in a million mortgages. Voters wouldn't like that...
It did not bail out ordinary people who had borrowed a little too much, these people are getting doubly screwed over. Paying extra taxes (which the governemt is raising, a large part of which is going to the banks) and they still have to pay back the loans on homes that are now in negative equity, on which rates have risen.
If nature were allowed to take it's course, the people who lent the money(other EU countries as it turns out) would have to take a hit(accept that they won't be getting all their "investment" back.
You can't just call in a loan, you know, contracts and all that, and why would the lender even want to do that? Who wants an unsellable thing like a house in Ireland(you can't sell them nowdays, no ones buying) instead of SOME of their money back.
So the current state of things in Ireland is homeowners that are in negative equity(everyone who borrowed since 2000 essentially) are prisoners. They can't sell, can't leave, they just have to take it(and both the government and the banks know this). And I'm sure the voters don't like that.
The houses haven't been built yet, and the guy has the loan out for them before he had permission for the plan, nevermind to build, and will now seek permission to build after the loan has been transferred to NAMA.
3400 homes at 2007 for sale prices is 3,400 x 300,000 = 1,020,000,000 euro.
This looks to me like they are building 3400 houses using government bailout money in the hope there will be some return on the initial investment. The property developer doesn't seem to be giving the original investment back. I am no expert, so my impression may be incorrect and the cheerleading tone of the article really confuses me.
I do not think people who took out mortgages they could not afford are blameless in this, they helped to drive the ridiculous prices. Property snakes and ladders.
To get back on topic, I can't imagine where the Irish Government, banks included, can expect to safely store money enough to provide for the retired population.
As a side note, Government should never be in the business of "Public Good" projects. Time and time again, government has shown that it cannot be trusted.
There are far too many variables in the system for most people to navigate successfully for 40 years straight, even if they are earnestly trying. You could have an extemely well diversified portfolio and still lose money when The Market as a whole tanks as a result of bad decisions of other people. You could have money saved up in multiple savings accounts or bonds and be out of luck when a government you didn't vote for fucks up and causes a period of hyperinflation. I'm not even mentioning things utterly out of individual control like a war resulting from an invasion by an aggressive, more powerful neighbour.
Implementation details such as retirement age are very important, of course, but a from mile-high view, providing a decent if not extraordinary living standard to millions of people seems exactly like the type of infrastructure and public good projects governments are normally the best option for.
/jarek, who nevertheless has more private savings right now than "a quarter of those surveyed"