News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by skybrian on Sunday July 18, 2010 @04:17PM (#1526624)
I find it useful to remember that finance can only solve problems to the extent that it changes what people do in the real world. What is retirement savings, but a way for older people to convince younger people to do work for them? Money is a persuasive way of doing that, but regardless it's older people depending on younger people to take care of them.

Compare these scenarios: - people save for retirement, so many old people are have money to spend. Lots of young people go into occupations that help old people because that's where the money is. - the government provides pensions, so many old people have money to spend. Lots of young people go into occupations that help old people because that's where the money is.

Either way, the real-world effect is the work that young people do.

There are always risks and they can't be wished away. The government could change the pension plan. (But note that in the U.S, social security is very well defended in Congress, and more older voters makes it more secure.) Or the price of services that old people need could go up because there are fewer workers or because they dislike the work.

As an individual, having above-average savings helps, but by definition everyone can't be above-average. If all retirees double their savings and supply is fixed then inflation is inevitable. To a first approximation the only real-world solutions are to increase the number of workers (immigration or increased birth rate) or to to increase productivity so fewer younger workers are needed.

There are no comments on this comment yet.