Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously...
by lionhearted on Sunday July 18, 2010 @05:31PM
(#1526779)
Facetiousness aside, that's a neat anecdote, but the point stands. Original commentor said there were three options - destitute and possibly homeless old people, after the fact emergency spending, or some sort of pension system. That ignores family/community ties, which is in my opinion a much better solution. You can disagree, but not even presenting it as an option is either being disingenuous or missing a really obvious potential solution.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously...
by philwelch on Sunday July 18, 2010 @06:25PM
(#1526924)
The government can't mandate interdependent families and communities. Those either happen or they don't. They can mandate social security.
Interestingly, the government can also mandate compulsory euthanasia for the elderly.
Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously...
by s3graham on Sunday July 18, 2010 @09:48PM
(#1527341)
> Interestingly, the government can also mandate compulsory euthanasia for the elderly.
I can't see it happening with short-term elections to office.
Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously...
by _delirium on Monday July 19, 2010 @02:13AM
(#1527772)
I guess I tend to group that with the other missing fourth option, "hope everyone saves for retirement". I agree that yes, ideally, people would all find some way to take care of themselves for retirement, whether out of savings, or with family, or some other method. But empirically, in modern societies a lot of elderly end up penniless and alone, so the question is what we do about that.