News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by _delirium on Sunday July 18, 2010 @01:04PM (#1526136)
That's basically why Social Security was first introduced, and I think it still makes some sense. Looking at it in the other direction, it's more or less a fact that a large proportion of people won't save for retirement. Therefore, you have three choices: 1) a bunch of destitute and possibly homeless old people; 2) some sort of after-the-fact spending to provide emergency services/shelter/care for destitute elderly; or 3) some sort of mandatory pension system to make sure elderly don't become destitute in the first place.

People generally find #1 unpalatable, so the practical choices are #2 versus #3: do we set up some sort of general pension system to make sure elderly make at least a bare minimum income to stay off the streets (currently $20k/yr or so), or do we instead set aside money to spend on housing and caring for destitute elderly, e.g. through government-run nursing homes?

Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by lionhearted on Sunday July 18, 2010 @04:46PM (#1526683)
> Therefore, you have three choices:

You missed the one that was used for all of human history:

4. Family ties, raise your kids well and establish that they should support you in old age. Bonus: Also gives an incentive to keep strong, healthy families together.

Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by pavlov on Sunday July 18, 2010 @05:15PM (#1526741)
There's another historical alternative:

5. When an old person becomes useless, drug him senseless and throw him off a cliff.

Allegedly this was customary among the ancient Sardinians in pre-Roman times. The drug they used on the elderly before killing them induced a sinister grimace, giving root to the expression "sardonic grin":

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/science-news/5344257/Myst...

Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by lionhearted on Sunday July 18, 2010 @05:31PM (#1526779)
Facetiousness aside, that's a neat anecdote, but the point stands. Original commentor said there were three options - destitute and possibly homeless old people, after the fact emergency spending, or some sort of pension system. That ignores family/community ties, which is in my opinion a much better solution. You can disagree, but not even presenting it as an option is either being disingenuous or missing a really obvious potential solution.
Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by philwelch on Sunday July 18, 2010 @06:25PM (#1526924)
The government can't mandate interdependent families and communities. Those either happen or they don't. They can mandate social security.

Interestingly, the government can also mandate compulsory euthanasia for the elderly.

Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by s3graham on Sunday July 18, 2010 @09:48PM (#1527341)
> Interestingly, the government can also mandate compulsory euthanasia for the elderly.

I can't see it happening with short-term elections to office.

Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by _delirium on Monday July 19, 2010 @02:13AM (#1527772)
I guess I tend to group that with the other missing fourth option, "hope everyone saves for retirement". I agree that yes, ideally, people would all find some way to take care of themselves for retirement, whether out of savings, or with family, or some other method. But empirically, in modern societies a lot of elderly end up penniless and alone, so the question is what we do about that.
Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by jarek on Sunday July 18, 2010 @05:00PM (#1526708)
Downside: using children as your old age insurance policy gives an incentive to have as many children as possible within your means on an already overpopulated planet.
Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by lionhearted on Sunday July 18, 2010 @05:28PM (#1526766)
> ...as many children as possible within your means on an already overpopulated planet.

I did some casual research on this - long story short, I think the planet will support at least around 600 billion people fine. You need to speed up nitrogen cycles for food, which we can already do. Energy is the big bottleneck right now, but fusion or whatever comes afterwards will likely make energy almost-free. Further out, molecular engineering and nanotechnology looks incredibly promising...

...anyway, the world isn't really so densely populated. I couldn't find the exact paper while googling, but you could fit all of the world's population in a fairly small state (Maine?) with the same population density as present-day Paris.

More people means more great people, more innovation, more good stuff happening faster. Nitrogen cycles, food, pollution are the bottlenecks. But population 600 billion should be fine and the world will be prosperous if we get there.

Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by Daishiman on Sunday July 18, 2010 @07:19PM (#1527033)
I don't want a planet where most of its natural resources are dedicated to maintaining a massive population. I'd much rather have a world where human influence is strong within its own sphere but leaves most ecosystems as pristine as possible.

Greater human population is antithetical to biodiversity and low pollution. That should probably be a greater ethical imperative than maximizing population numbers.

Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by jarek on Sunday July 18, 2010 @06:05PM (#1526866)
Advocating the past's policies with the future's hoped for or even expected technology is not really what I'd call responsible. At the current time we're not close to having the technology that would let a metropolis the density of Paris feed itself without depending on a comparatively sparsely populated area at least thrice again the size.
Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by lionhearted on Sunday July 18, 2010 @06:57PM (#1526989)
That position is a reasonable one and I respect it, but I disagree. Necessity is the mother of invention, and technology is usually developed in response to need. Thus, "don't expand until the technology is there" is a bit of a catch-22: Population growth will drive demand and funding for new ways to solve the challenges that come with it.

Also, population 600 billion doesn't happen overnight - we're almost certainly in good shape for the next 50-100 years, I'd argue the decline in population in some Western countries is a much greater threat to prosperity, health, and happiness than any increase in population could be.

Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by crpatino on Monday July 19, 2010 @11:06AM (#1528897)
> Necessity is the mother of invention, and technology is usually developed in response to need.

This is some position I respect but disagree with. For one reason: it is pure observation bias.

Those who fail to invent at the face of Necessity take the hit, hunker down and die in anonymity. On the other hand, the ones who prevail have their names written in history as legendary inventors and innovators. Rinse a repeat over a couple thousand years and everybody knows that "Necessity is the mother of invention, and technology is usually developed in response to need".

Malthus is highly misunderstood as having stated that doom in unavoidable. What he actually said is that unconstrained population growth will eventually be forcibly constrained by hard physical and ecologic limits. I'd rather have rational planning or cultural taboos limit the max human population in any given region.

Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by jarek on Monday July 19, 2010 @06:10PM (#1530363)
I don't disagree with invention and creativity and a role of a problem in motivating the two -- I can't, really, having ended up writing a couple of odes to it on HN in the past.

However, I prefer my necessities not to involve potential humanitarian catastrophes. The steam engine, the rapid advancement of powered flight technology, and Google were all created in response to a need, but none of these needs were of the "young people will starve and old people will be left desolate if we don't come up with something" variety.

We're not short on need for cheaper energy right now; I don't think we ever were. (More efficient agriculture is a slightly more complex subject due to political reasons.) Maybe someday we will be at a point where we can safely adopt a policy of encouraging lots of children, but right now it seems a little irresponsible.

Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by lincolnq on Monday July 19, 2010 @01:19PM (#1529371)
I would love to see a blog post on this.
Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by Retric on Sunday July 18, 2010 @03:01PM (#1526448)
We also have government run nursing homes and plenty of destitute old people live in them. But, even for a selfish person SS is not exactly a terrible idea. Consider, pensions and SS have a huge benefit over traditional forms of investing.

Imagine setting one up a pension for a group of savvy investors. As you near retirement you pool your money with 10,000 other people and all split the dividend each month (based on what % you put in). As people start to die off there is a smaller pool of receptions who keep getting a larger monthly check. Granted you lose the ability to give money to your spouse/children when you die, but you don't need to worry about outliving your savings. (Assuming the fund is not mismanaged etc.)

PS: There are many problems with SS, but when you consider it's inflation adjusted it represents a vary large and vary safe investment. (Run a Monte Carlo Analysis assuming you are only willing to accept a 1% risk of running out of money at 100 and a safe retirement takes a huge nest egg.)

Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by byrneseyeview on Sunday July 18, 2010 @03:45PM (#1526546)
That structure is often called a Tontine. It's illegal, because after a while it's basically a massive monetary reward for offing your fellow investors.
Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by Retric on Sunday July 18, 2010 @06:13PM (#1526886)
Yep, that's a major bug with the simple implementation.

The simple solution is to cap the benefit and and use a large enough pool that no single death ever makes a big difference on it's own. Which gives you something like "Long Term Care Insurance" is basic a bet that you will live long enough to need it, which is subsidized by those who don't. The benefit is also fairly small so a reasonably large company is not going to try and collect.

Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by sp332 on Sunday July 18, 2010 @04:18PM (#1526625)
Hah, just watched the movie Charade last night where exactly this happens.
Re:To retire comfortably, under-40 workers need to seriously... by cma on Sunday July 18, 2010 @05:21PM (#1526754)
In Thomas Paine's Agrarian Justice, he uses similar logic was well (in part; his main argument is that improving land doesn't entitle you to the land, but only to the improvement, and that a reasonable land-tax can address this). He also anticipates Malthus by considering a future steady-state population.

http://www.thomaspaine.org/Archives/agjst.html