A friend of mine offered a student some programming help. They used Paypal to pay. The student decided they didn't want to pay and told Paypal it was a fraudulent charge. Now my friend doesn't have the money and a strike against their account. (They contested that the charge was valid, but Paypal didn't care.)
BTC sadly is up to $3 in transaction fees, so it's not too lightweight at this point.
[1] http://www.slate.com/articles/business/moneybox/2015/09/venm...
[2] http://gizmodo.com/reminder-venmo-wont-protect-you-from-scam...
[3] http://jolt.richmond.edu/2016/10/21/ignoring-the-venmo-user-...
The big difference between the two services is PayPal is designed mainly for commercial activities and Venmo is designed for already established friends to more easily chip in for gas.
The friend was very naïve to accept a PayPal payment for a business transaction that wasn't covered by PayPal's Seller Protection while simultaneously expecting PayPal to protect against fraud. PayPal does cover sellers when there are unauthorized (or "unauthorized") charges but it doesn't apply to services, just physical goods (and excludes certain items like gift cards). It's like saying that the post office shouldn't be trusted to deliver greeting cards because a stranger sent you a fake check through the mail.
[I've successfully used PayPal's seller protection for an unauthorized charge and it was a real easy process.]
The point was to warn people not to use PayPal. It doesn't matter if it was naive when most people would expect PayPal to process a transaction.
You don't need to take my word for it. PayPal has a long and majestic history on HN consisting of hundreds of stories of how terrible PayPal is.
Btc has grown to fill the large tx space but there are trustworthy coins designed for smaller, cheaper interpersonal txs.
Don't use etherium for interpersonal because thet're not aiming for this use case long term. They want to be an underlying platform where ltc/doge were explicitely designed to settle small debts with friends or tip cam strippers. You don't have touse it on those strippers but if it's good enough for them, you should take a look.
This. 1 of my boxing trainers was using Venmo since 2016, and he even asked me to pay him through that at that time. So I came home and did some research, and in that process, found some payments that my other trainee friends had made to him, on his facebook wall.
I was like WTF?! Why would anyone broadcast their financial transactions, that too for something like Personal Training.
Moreover, the transactions I saw, for the exact same type of training I was receiving (pad work followed by sparring for 1 hour), was 20% to 40% less than what I was paying, and I felt like I was a sucker. I stopped training with him a few weeks later.
Never used Venmo either.
I have no interest in using an app that by default
broadcasts my transactions to everyone
I haven't seen the default in some time, but it's very simple to change the privileges on a transaction (2 clicks, immediately visible on every transaction), which apply to all your future transactions unless you change it back. Cold comfort, but there you go. .. it had the audacity of asking for my SSN.
I'm frankly surprised that PayPal doesn't require a SSN for the same activities... or maybe they do. Venmo help[1] indicates they are required to do so for users with certain volumes (several hundred dollars per week) by the U.S. Treasury. Why would Paypal and other vendors not have the same requirements?[1] https://help.venmo.com/hc/en-us/articles/217532197-Social-Se...
I totally recommend giving it a try if you haven't already.
A pain? It's by far the most painless of all the payment platforms I've used. I can request a withdrawal at 9am and have it in my account by 1pm. I've never seen that level of service on any other app.
At least that's my observation. I do it from Commbank > other banks all the time and they don't have to do anything manually each time to receive the money - just a day or so later the money appears in their account.
This is such an astounding deal breaker for me. I'm honestly more than a little surprised it's even legal. It just sounds like one of those things that wouldn't be because of course it's a bad idea and everyone agreed on that like 100 years ago or something.
Some see this as a disadvantage of Square Cash--they say individual transactions clog their checking account statements, they prefer to withdraw a consolidated amount from their Venmo balance.
I don't like to have random balances on money-transfer startups' system, especially since it's uninsured.
You can change the default visibility in settings to only you and the person you're sending money too.
Also, your PayPal balance is not FDIC insured either.
I find Venmo a lot easier to use than PayPal and far more people I know are on there vs anything else. I do wish it auto deposited to a bank account like Square Cash though.
Wire transfers are generally cost prohibitive, and even assuming no fees, it’d be strange (and more time consuming) to ask a friend for their bank details to wire them $10 for pizza.
Sure an account number + sort code is slightly less easy to input than an email address but it's hardly difficult and after the first time my bank will remember it anyway.
I have no interest in using an app that by default broadcasts my transactions to everyone, and that makes it a pain to get money out of its non-FDIC insured closed system. With Facebook or Square, the money gets pushed and pulled directly to my bank account, simply by adding a debit card.
Plus, when I did try to sign up once a long time ago… it had the audacity of asking for my SSN. I flat-out refused and refused to use Venmo ever since.