A (very) progressive tax rate with a few ways of reducing the tax based on social (e.g. number of children, etc) criteria would probably work better here.
So even when tiered, a person earning under some amount in total might get a lower tax rate than a person earning a higher amount but it is still flat.
The "flat tax" would be taxed on all jurisdiction. So call it a "universal flat tax". That way, there is no persuasion to register in a foreign country and it would dissuade multi geography registrations as you would just be taxed in multiples by each territory.
To avoid double taxation, perhaps, a company can register in multiple countries but since the tax is the same everywhere, the portion of the x% taxed would be proportionally divided to the territories.
This assumes of course that the whole world agrees on one tax policy and tax havens are eliminated. :)
They say there should be a 20% tax, on any income above the $35,000 a year threshold. While it still does effect people on the lower end more, the first part of their income is at least partially untaxed.
And the bar is low enough that the super rich will not be able to create schemes to keep there income under that bar.
Tell this to the nations which have successfully implemented a flat tax:
http://www.economist.com/node/3860731
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flat_tax#Countries_that_have_f...
It's ironic that a number of former Soviet countries have moved on to the flat tax, while the west has a progressive income tax (#2 plank of the Communist Manifesto).
Compare them to slowly declining western European countries like Italy and Spain.
People/politicians are very creative in what is to be considered essential.
For me personally - I would add one more change that most people don't like. I would put an actual cap on total income tax that can be paid in a single year. The reason for this is that these progressive systems act as a social welfare system that transfer money. That's why people propose a flat tax. Well, flat tax is much better but still presents the possibility for a wealthy person to pay, for example, 200k in income tax in a year. A lot of people would say "so what?". Well, I believe income tax shouldn't be treated as a maximum pain threshold. The basis of taxation is to fund public goods. We all consume roughly the same amount of public services on average. If someone is paying something like 200k a year in income tax they are paying way, way above anything they could possibly consume in public goods/services for that year.
But "no loophole tax" might be a better characterization of the flat idea, yes?
Maybe single means a complex function? I doubt it.
Remember that Flat Tax is also called Fair Tax. The concept of fairness is central.
Flat tax rate has nothing to do with the loopholes, those are completely orthogonal. You could as well say "a simple progressive tax rate ...".
If you meant to say 1) close all loopholes, and 2) implement flat tax rate, then OK, but those are still two different things. In that case, what's wrong with 1) close all loopholes, and 2) leave the progressive tax rate?
I mean, I am not an economist, I have no idea if that would work or not(probably not)
So Amazon would own the entire supply chain: Manufacturing widgets, selling widgets, storing widgets, shipping widgets, handling returns, etc. They already sort of do this, but if you add a 20% tax at each hop they would eliminate the remaining hops as fast as they possibly can or buy the hops.
And you could never start a small business, because everyone who'd want to buy from you would save a ton of money doing it themselves. By not taxing business transactions, it's zero additional cost to have someone else do something for you, so it makes it possible to grow a small business.
In particular, grocery stores with a 2% margin would be hit hard.
By having a flat tax it doesn't make sense to shift 'money in' under different categories because all gets taxed the same rate.
So for example, income, capital gains, dividends would all be taxed at 10% or 15% or whatever.
You can already do this today. Eventually you will need to sell and pay the taxes, eg. if interest rates rise and it's no longer worth it or when you die and have to pay the loans off.
> Or, you could leave it all in a company that you own, draw no income and have the company pay for your housing, meals, travel, etc.
If your company pays for your personal expenses like housing, it's taxable as income. Lots of SV companies pay for their interns' housing and the rent was always listed on their W2's.
Sure, but it can be a strategy to reduce taxable income. My point is that people at the top end are highly incentivized to avoid taxes and will find ways to do so. I'm not making any policy prescription, tax policy is hard and I don't claim to know what's optimal or even necessarily better.
Obviously this is a terribly contrived example, but it is somewhat descriptive of the type of strategy used to reduce taxable income. Things are obviously more complicated when you have numerous types of income from domestic and foreign sources.
Keeping it in the company would then be irrelevant (the more you keep in the company by not paying yourself a salary, the higher the corporate taxes).
I also don't think you could easily manage raising the effective corporate tax rate very much without seeing further offshoring of profits, which is the present situation. We presently live in a world where capital movement has been liberalized and the movement of people(Schengen notwithstanding) has not. So even if you have some sort of profit/income agnostic flat tax, any business that can seek lower tax rates abroad will.
The Code of Hammurabi describes Babylonian taxes and the manners of levy. The Egyptians and Romans levied income taxes. There is of course the gafol/Danegeld/heregald of the Anglo-Saxons. You've got taxes/tolls paid by merchants on the Silk Road and certainly I've read of taxation in Ashoka's era and other sub-continental sovereignties.
You have the taxation/feudal levy system that existed even in archaic Greece where boats, rowers and soldiers were expected to be provided by patricians in times of war.
China (especially) and Japan have long histories of taxation.
The idea that recorded human history has been mostly without tax seems to be ahistoric.
Sure. Which is why it's a bit ridiculous to say there has been a millennia of income tax we have been learning from.
Tax in general has existed - progressive income taxes, however, seem to be a fairly recent development. Purely in the administration sense, it would have been far more difficult to do in the past and as a progressive tax system does not actively benefit the people in power in a feudal or imperial government, it would be unlikely for a progressive tax to be implemented, especially one that exists in peace-time. In fact, feudal era taxes seem to have been actively regressive.
Removing a progressive tax system, something I believe is a bad idea to do, wouldn't roll things back to older systems of taxation. We wouldn't sacrifice the development of financial policies and tax frameworks, and we didn't arrive at the concept of a progressive system because of hundreds of years of failed tax policies. We have a structurally different government than countries did for hundreds of years prior.
The first "bank" was also founded much earlier than 1000 years ago (and wasn't a bank), but we did know a bit about financial systems even before then.
edit: at that point, if we threw out the tax system, why not just get rid of states and corporations and start everything from scratch, said the junior dev
You eventually have to define your terms, and those definitions will have the loopholes embedded in them.
That's not to say that simplification is useless. It would still cut a lot of waste out of the costs of collection, enforcement, and compliance.
I disagree. I simple flat tax rate where everything is taxed at a single rate would close every single one of the loopholes above, if only by making it moot.
The fact that the rich can maneuver themselves into a much lower tax rate than the average person presents a significant, unfair advantage in my opinion. A flat tax rate would make things much more equitable. Plus it would asimplify the tax code tremendously.