News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by pavs on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @08:46PM (#1516475)
Trying my best not to sound rude, but Chris Pearson sounds extremely obnoxious. His analogies are all over the place and very defensive; most likely because he realizes that he is on the wrong end of the debate.

The license explicitly says it has to be GPL. End of discussion. He is making up his own rules!

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by brockf on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:11PM (#1516695)
Hahaha Chris is ridiculous. My favourite part is when he goes off on the massive tangent about his love of "systems" and just wants a "natural" flow. What is he even saying?

He wants to make money and is scared to GPL. Fair enough.

However, Matt and WordPress can sue him and they should. Stop these goofy debates and making Chris squirm awkwardly. Though it is kind of funny...

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by rick888 on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:19PM (#1516713)
"The license explicitly says it has to be GPL. End of discussion. He is making up his own rules!"

The license does. However, I don't think his theme uses actual wordpress code beyond function calls. I would hardly call this a derivative work.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by Otto42 on Thursday July 15, 2010 @04:12AM (#1517214)
It does actually go deeper than that, but really that's beside the point. Function calls into the WordPress code is enough.

WordPress has a public API... several of them, in fact. A theme doesn't use those, it makes direct calls to internal WP code, and it uses WordPress internal data structures. This is enough to make it a derivative work.

From http://www.gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-2.0-faq.html#Me... :

"Combining two modules means connecting them together so that they form a single larger program. If either part is covered by the GPL, the whole combination must also be released under the GPL—if you can't, or won't, do that, you may not combine them.

What constitutes combining two parts into one program? This is a legal question, which ultimately judges will decide. We believe that a proper criterion depends both on the mechanism of communication (exec, pipes, rpc, function calls within a shared address space, etc.) and the semantics of the communication (what kinds of information are interchanged).

If the modules are included in the same executable file, they are definitely combined in one program. If modules are designed to run linked together in a shared address space, that almost surely means combining them into one program.

By contrast, pipes, sockets and command-line arguments are communication mechanisms normally used between two separate programs. So when they are used for communication, the modules normally are separate programs. But if the semantics of the communication are intimate enough, exchanging complex internal data structures, that too could be a basis to consider the two parts as combined into a larger program."

Ultimately, it is a matter of interpretation, but all previous interpretation, including those made in courts of law, pretty much universally agree with Matt on this one. It's very difficult to consider a theme to be a "separate program" when it's deep-linking to internal functions and data structures and it also cannot run independently.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by tzs on Thursday July 15, 2010 @08:19AM (#1517563)
> Ultimately, it is a matter of interpretation, but all previous interpretation, including those made in courts of law, pretty much universally agree with Matt on this one.

There have been no court cases I'm aware of that have dealt with this in the context of a GPL program. There are, however, numerous cases where the code being called was not GPL, and they have pretty much universally ruled that the FSF position is wrong--blob of code X calling into blob of code Y does NOT make X a derivative work of Y.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by Otto42 on Thursday July 15, 2010 @03:25PM (#1518856)
In the specific context of a GPL program, no, but there is case law backing up my argument. Micro Star v. Formgen for example, held that a Duke Nukem 3D map file (which contained no code or anything else from the game itself) was a derivative work because it referenced artwork and other materials from the game's files.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by tzs on Thursday July 15, 2010 @05:06PM (#1519188)
A Kozinski opinion. Those are always entertaining. Most judges write very dry and formal opinions. Kozinski opens with "Duke Nukem routinely vanquishes Octabrain and the Protozoid Slimer. But what about the dreaded Micro Star?"

A key point from the opinion:

"Micro Star further argues that the MAP files are not derivative works because they do not, in fact, incorporate any of D/N-3D's protected expression. In particular, Micro Star makes much of the fact that the N/I MAP files reference the source art library, but do not actually contain any art files themselves. Therefore, it claims, nothing of D/N-3D's is reproduced in the MAP files. In making this argument, Micro Star misconstrues the protected work. The work that Micro Star infringes is the D/N-3D story itself--a beefy commando type named Duke who wanders around post-Apocalypse Los Angeles, shooting Pig Cops with a gun, lobbing hand grenades, searching for medkits and steroids, using a jetpack to leap over obstacles, blowing up gas tanks, avoiding radioactive slime. A copyright owner holds the right to create sequels, see Trust Co. Bank v. MGM/UA Entertainment Co., 772 F.2d 740 (11th Cir.1985), and the stories told in the N/I MAP files are surely sequels, telling new (though somewhat repetitive) tales of Duke's fabulous adventures. A book about Duke Nukem would infringe for the same reason, even if it contained no pictures."

They use that same notion, that the MAP file is encoding a D/N story, in dismissing the claim that it is the user making the derivative work, not Micro Star. It doesn't seem to be the artwork per se that's the problem for Micro Star--it's that it is telling a D/N story.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by regularfry on Thursday July 15, 2010 @03:48PM (#1518923)
You know when you take a stance, and you say "What would it take for me to change my opinion on this?" Yeah, this is one of those situations for me. Have you got a cite?
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by tzs on Thursday July 15, 2010 @04:01PM (#1518963)
Lewis Galoob Toys, Inc. v. Nintendo of America, Inc. is relevant, as is Sega v. Accolade.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by regularfry on Friday July 16, 2010 @05:31AM (#1520729)
Sega v Accolade is food for thought. I don't think it's directly relevant, dealing as it does with direct copying (and an associated trademark claim, but I'll ignore that), but there are some tangential opinions in there that might have a logical bearing.

Galoob is fascinating - thanks for that, I've not read it before.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by Concours on Thursday July 15, 2010 @03:00AM (#1517148)
Mr. Chris Pearson , excuse me Sir, I don't want to be rude but you are an idiot, but the bad part of it: he doesn't even know it. Wordpress is GPL, everything build on Wordpress has to be GPL as the licence states. End of the discussion, he has to understand, it's not about what he wants or doesn't want, what he thinks or doesn't think, those are just the fact, you don't like it, go pick another platform. Mr. Chris Pearson , you are wrong, it's not about what you decide or not, those are the rules of GPL.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by lukevdp on Thursday July 15, 2010 @06:30AM (#1517409)
I agree with this entirely. Chris is making his decisions based on what he thinks the rules should be rather than what the rules are
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by duck on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:34PM (#1516750)
Exactly... and it is obvious the Chris came into this discussion with his mind set (and not open) and didn't listen to a single thing Matt said.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by rick888 on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:40PM (#1516768)
"Exactly... and it is obvious the Chris came into this discussion with his mind set (and not open) and didn't listen to a single thing Matt said."

Do you think Matt would have changed his mind either? From his tweets and past interviews, he doesn't seem like he will ever change is mind about derivative works.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by tjogin on Thursday July 15, 2010 @09:11AM (#1517659)
It seems to me that Matt went into it not wanting to sue, and is now considering it. That's a change of direction, if not opinion.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by rick888 on Thursday July 15, 2010 @09:34AM (#1517702)
"It seems to me that Matt went into it not wanting to sue"

He still hasn't changed one bit on his opinion of plugins/themes and the GPL.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by tjogin on Thursday July 15, 2010 @11:06AM (#1518020)
He wasn't really offered a compelling argument to do that, so that's no surprise.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by rick888 on Thursday July 15, 2010 @11:23AM (#1518070)
"He still hasn't changed one bit on his opinion of plugins/themes and the GPL."

Well, matt wasn't offering a compelling argument for chris to release under the GPL either, so I guess they are even.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by tjogin on Thursday July 15, 2010 @11:45AM (#1518145)
Complying with the license to avoid breaking the law and risking a lawsuit is usually a very compelling argument for a business person. But not this one, that much is clear.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by rick888 on Thursday July 15, 2010 @01:09PM (#1518384)
"Complying with the license to avoid breaking the law and risking a lawsuit is usually a very compelling argument for a business person. But not this one, that much is clear."

I love all the posts here about "breaking the law". I never see this much support when a content owner doesn't want their stuff shared on the torrent networks for free. Funny how politics plays into the rights and wrongs of society.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by tjogin on Sunday July 18, 2010 @11:16AM (#1525890)
Sure. Ignoring all the other reasons to pirate something, like lack of legal alternatives or whatever, most people who pirate a song, film or whatever, don't do it for profit.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by BriefEpisode on Sunday July 18, 2010 @06:57PM (#1526988)
But there are people or enterprises profiting in piracy. Go to The Pirate Bay and type in anything and click on the search result. Heck, even go to the splash page. There are ads.

The songs and films and software on The Pirate Bay aren't funding the corporations or artists with the copyrights, but they are funding the revenue stream of TPB itself.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by slantyyz on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @09:57PM (#1516657)
Obnoxious or not, I think the point of contention is whether a theme can considered a derivative work or not. I think you can easily find lawyers who would have no trouble arguing either side of the case.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by pavs on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:01PM (#1516666)
So find me a lawyer (more than just a blog post) who have successfully contented against such a case.

Did you watch the whole interview? His views has nothing to do with laws, nothing to do with grey areas within the license (from my understanding GPL is very explicit about this); he basically said "I don't wanna do this because, I don't wanna do this."

How can you rationalize with that?

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by skitzzo on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @11:27PM (#1516858)
Did you notice that Matt wasn't able to produce a lawyer who successfully contended that themes were derivative works? Sure the SFLC chimed in but what do you think their opinion would be given that they are the Software Freedom Law Center?

While Chris may not have stuck on point about the gray areas within the license (it is FAR from explicit), that doesn't mean they don't still apply. And last I checked, we're still innocent until proven guilty in regards to the kinds of accusations Matt is making.

Matt is the one with the burden of proof here, not Chris and Matt most certainly hasn't achieved the requisite level of proof IMO.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by slantyyz on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:05PM (#1516683)
Look at the two links provided in one of my other comments pointing to perpetualbeta.com. That guy is an IP lawyer who provided some opinion that is not on the side of Wordpress.

EDIT: Not many licenses have been challenged in court, including the GPL. Do you have any cases to cite in favor of GPL?

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by slantyyz on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:15PM (#1516703)
From your search link, I don't see any results of cases where the infringement wasn't based primarily on redistribution of the original work.

I don't think that Thesis is distributed with a copy of Wordpress. I definitely think it's a sketchier argument to make with a theme. Settlement of a case doesn't always mean that the defendant is going to lose either. It can also mean that the cost and distraction of a protracted suit makes it easier to swallow the cost of the settlement.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by pavs on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:39PM (#1516767)
You are right they are different issues. Personally I would like to see Matt and FSF go after him and end the debate once and for all.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by slantyyz on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:49PM (#1516786)
That would make for an interesting case, and if I'm not mistaken, the first real test case for the GPL.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by p_alexander on Thursday July 15, 2010 @03:01PM (#1518772)
He isn't an IP lawyer. He's a real-estate foreclosure and bankruptcy lawyer. In his bio at the law firm he co-founded I can't find a mention of any IP-related expertise: http://ricardolaw.com/michael-alex-wasylik/

Not to say that his argument couldn't fly, but I'm not sure I would give it that much credence either.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by pavs on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:09PM (#1516692)
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by babyboy808 on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @09:12PM (#1516544)
I honestly thought I was the only thinking this!
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by pavs on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @09:20PM (#1516562)
Confirmed this guy is obnoxious: http://i.imgur.com/wffx2.png

My respect for Matt just jumped ten-fold for being so calm with this guy and I am not even a fan-boy.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by Concours on Thursday July 15, 2010 @03:02AM (#1517153)
fully agree, I was impress from Matt, seems to be an extremely smart and calm Guy.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by freerobby on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:23PM (#1516725)
Agreed.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by wingnutart on Thursday July 15, 2010 @05:48PM (#1519339)
Chris was a jerk this entire interview. Over and over again he was ranting and shouting Matt down. Matt was superb throughout; calm, patient, and prepared. He had one blurt-out, while Pearson frantically dug his own grave. Totally agreed.