News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by slantyyz on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @09:57PM (#1516657)
Obnoxious or not, I think the point of contention is whether a theme can considered a derivative work or not. I think you can easily find lawyers who would have no trouble arguing either side of the case.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by pavs on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:01PM (#1516666)
So find me a lawyer (more than just a blog post) who have successfully contented against such a case.

Did you watch the whole interview? His views has nothing to do with laws, nothing to do with grey areas within the license (from my understanding GPL is very explicit about this); he basically said "I don't wanna do this because, I don't wanna do this."

How can you rationalize with that?

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by skitzzo on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @11:27PM (#1516858)
Did you notice that Matt wasn't able to produce a lawyer who successfully contended that themes were derivative works? Sure the SFLC chimed in but what do you think their opinion would be given that they are the Software Freedom Law Center?

While Chris may not have stuck on point about the gray areas within the license (it is FAR from explicit), that doesn't mean they don't still apply. And last I checked, we're still innocent until proven guilty in regards to the kinds of accusations Matt is making.

Matt is the one with the burden of proof here, not Chris and Matt most certainly hasn't achieved the requisite level of proof IMO.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by slantyyz on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:05PM (#1516683)
Look at the two links provided in one of my other comments pointing to perpetualbeta.com. That guy is an IP lawyer who provided some opinion that is not on the side of Wordpress.

EDIT: Not many licenses have been challenged in court, including the GPL. Do you have any cases to cite in favor of GPL?

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by slantyyz on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:15PM (#1516703)
From your search link, I don't see any results of cases where the infringement wasn't based primarily on redistribution of the original work.

I don't think that Thesis is distributed with a copy of Wordpress. I definitely think it's a sketchier argument to make with a theme. Settlement of a case doesn't always mean that the defendant is going to lose either. It can also mean that the cost and distraction of a protracted suit makes it easier to swallow the cost of the settlement.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by pavs on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:39PM (#1516767)
You are right they are different issues. Personally I would like to see Matt and FSF go after him and end the debate once and for all.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by slantyyz on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:49PM (#1516786)
That would make for an interesting case, and if I'm not mistaken, the first real test case for the GPL.
Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by p_alexander on Thursday July 15, 2010 @03:01PM (#1518772)
He isn't an IP lawyer. He's a real-estate foreclosure and bankruptcy lawyer. In his bio at the law firm he co-founded I can't find a mention of any IP-related expertise: http://ricardolaw.com/michael-alex-wasylik/

Not to say that his argument couldn't fly, but I'm not sure I would give it that much credence either.

Re:Would WordPress Sue The Maker Of Thesis WordPress Theme? ... by pavs on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:09PM (#1516692)