skitzzo
Google Shares Down Nearly 10% After Missing 4th Quarter Targets
Bill Gates, Blackwater, and Monsanto. Conspiracy Theater
Adobe Quietly Eliminates Creative Suite Subscriptions
CNET Injecting Malware into Downloads
This is getting old... but Sony Hacked Again
To be honest, I'm surprised we got this kind of response from Google at all. They generally don't weigh in on SEO theory.
Then you followed that statement up by saying that the title isn't true.
While I most definitely appreciate you weighing in on the issue, I feel you would better serve readers by explaining whether the initial statement, the title, or both are inaccurate.
Are you saying email reputation wasn't the reason his site was penalized, that he didn't have a tip from a Google employee, or that email reputation doesn't factor into the search rankings?
Google Setting Aside $500M to Settle DOJ Charges
Google Embraces Flash... as a Fallguy for Chrome Hack
$90 iPad Cases for $5 in ATT Online Store (and it's legit)
Amazon Terminates Illinois Affiliates
Woops Looks like WordPress Itself isnt 100% GPL Either
Google Censors Torrent Sites – Except The Pirate Bay
GPL themes are able to be shared and redistributed however the end user sees fit.
That's the big difference. I can sell GPL themes myself for half price & they have no recourse. People can give GPL themes away for free and the developers have no recourse.
That's what the debate is about, whether themes inherit the GPL or not.
No one (that I know of) is arguing the GPL doesn't apply at all. What people, such as myself are arguing is that the GPL doesn't automatically apply to wOrdPRESS themes.
While Chris may not have stuck on point about the gray areas within the license (it is FAR from explicit), that doesn't mean they don't still apply. And last I checked, we're still innocent until proven guilty in regards to the kinds of accusations Matt is making.
Matt is the one with the burden of proof here, not Chris and Matt most certainly hasn't achieved the requisite level of proof IMO.
http://twitter.com/photomatt/status/18536188489
http://www.flickr.com/photos/mg315/4792383313/ (Matt claiming Chris verbally abused Jane Wells)
http://twitter.com/photomatt/status/18529673700 (Matt calling Chris a "non-coder" and impugning the Thesis theme)
http://twitter.com/photomatt/status/18533505517 (Matt calling Thesis "scammy")
http://twitter.com/photomatt/status/18535500457 (Matt blatantly patronizing Chris)
And in the interview, when Chris brings up the issue of Matt being more responsible with his actions, Matt deftly dodges the questions. As I said before, while I think Chris came off a bit wound up, it's understandable given the context of the accusations that had been leveled by Matt prior to this interview.