News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by musage on Saturday September 02, 2017 @11:53PM (#15159600)
Capitalism only works in optimizing those things it measures in the first place. Progress of society does not even enter into it, at all. If 300 million people had nothing and screamed in pain all day, and one person had it it all and multiplied it by X, the GDP would be multiplied by X. So what kind of measure is that?

I also find it interesting that nobody even mentioned capitalism "not working". The comment said that any mention of capitalism is often followed by generic praises. I guess another form of that is "capitalism brought us great things, and is better than the alternatives we had so far, but [criticism of some aspects or consquences of it]" -- which acknowledges that it "works", just like using coal to heat your home works, like many things undeniably work; yet even that would raise the above question, how come it's treated like a religion? If it's so great, why so defensive to the point of scoring own goals?

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:10AM (#15159649)
> Progress of society does not even enter into it, at all.

Capitalism in America, 1800-1900, brought along with it enormous, unprecedented, and historic improvements in longevity, height, and reductions in infant mortality.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by pdkl95 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:40AM (#15159720)
Capitalism was present in that area, but it was not a requirement for growth. The actual improvements in that era was from the industrial revolution. The development of the steam engine, machine tools, and manufacturing innovations like interchangeable parts. With that start, the amount of exploitable energy per-capita skyrocketed. Science, technology, and our standard of living have have been riding that wave ever since.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:08AM (#15159938)
The industrial revolution was a consequence of free market capitalism.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by EGreg on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:29AM (#15161095)
Way to attribute credit for every technological advance to one economic system. Yes I am sure it had nothing to do with the scientific discoveries going on at the time. I am sure the dinosaurs going extinct was the result of socialism.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by kobeya on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:43PM (#15163422)
Or did the scientific advances happen because there was an incentive compatible system in place to share in the profits of that advancement of knowledge?

The Enlightenment followed the rise of mercantilism, not the other way around.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by mixmastamyk on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:25AM (#15159830)
How does industry get built without capital? (Honest question.)
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by c22 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:17AM (#15159967)
The antithetical of capitalism isn't a world with no capital. The distinction between capitalism and competing ideologies is in who "owns" the capital and how it is directed.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by EGreg on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:25AM (#15159690)
China has moved the largest number of people out of poverty ever, in absolute numbers, in a couple decades. Despite all the articles about "ghost cities", the average income went up by 500% every 10 years.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by adventured on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:37AM (#15159865)
Definitely. China accomplished that by specifically disabling large aspects of Communism in their economic model and shifting substantially toward a greater free market model. Capitalism enabled the greatest poverty reduction in human history, at hyper speed.

Jack Ma, Pony Ma, Robin Li, Hui Ka Yan, Wang Jianlin etc., and all the technology and industry - all were impossible under their former Communist economic model (as conveniently demonstrated by every other Communist nation that has previously existed, including Mao's China).

Nearly every prosperous nation on the planet heavily utilizes the free market, including all of Scandinavia. The post WW2 benefits of the free market system globally have been truly extraordinary, resulting in the lowest rates of famine, war, violence and poverty in all of recorded history.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by EGreg on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:41AM (#15161136)
China does not have a greater free-market model than the USA did during the 20th century. The problem is playing a correlation game and attributing absolutely every advance to the free market while attributing every decline to "socialism".

Clearly, the move of farmers to newly built cities was centrally planned by a huge central government. There's just no way all those privately owned businesses got together and said "let's build cities". It is a collective action problem. The same thing took much longer after the Great Depression, as John Steinbeck writes about in his novelsz

You can see similar advancements in all the new USSR Republics across the Soviet Union which came from pre industrial conditions to sky high literacy rates and electricity and manufacturing in a span of a few decades. I am talking about Muslim countries like Uzbekistan, Turkemenistan, etc. becoming much more prosperous, under Communist rule. So to claim that only Capitalism is capable of lifting masses out of poverty is certainly not true.

I am not saying Communist (or Islamist, or Nazi or Fascisy) ideology is good to have at the state level. I am saying NO IDEOLOGY IS GOOD at the state level. And in the USA, the worship of Capitalism is on the level of Islam in Saudi Arabia.

Capitalism has produced toms of negative externalities. The ecosystems of the world are all going to shit. We are living on resources borrowed from future generations, and it is unsustainable. Those rates of famine you are talking about have also been accompanied by the largest rise in desertification of farmland, deforestation, pollution of natural ecosystems and extinction of species around the world. And let's not forget the greenhouse gases. When will the bill come due? Will we be thanking those industrialists?

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by bigmanwalter on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:22AM (#15160116)
And yet, it's also resulted in the highest ever recorded rate of anxiety, depression and suicide. Despite all the gains seen to capital, the average person is either completely overworked or struggling to find a job, is finding it increasingly difficult to own their house and feels more and more alienated from their local community to the extent that they prefer to live in online fantasy worlds.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by bigmanwalter on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:29AM (#15160133)
Capitalism in the 21st century has also resulted in the highest ever recorded rate of anxiety, depression and suicide. Despite all the gains seen to capital, the average person is either completely overworked or struggling to find a job, is finding it increasingly difficult to own their house and feels more and more alienated from their local community to the extent that they prefer to live in online fantasy worlds.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by ehnto on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:20AM (#15160279)
That could be due to the reporting and diagnosis of those illnesses or lack thereof in earlier times.

I don't disagree that capitalism optimizes for the wrong metrics. I simply don't have the knowledge one way or another to say it would or wouldn't be possible to have such progress without capitalism but I wonder if we haven't hit some kind of peak comfort in technology, and we should really start shifting focus to reaching a peak humanity instead. Everyone has a smartphone yet it hasn't made them happy for example.

I think we simply missed some refinements and balances on our march to success.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @05:17AM (#15160449)
> Everyone has a smartphone yet it hasn't made them happy

Wasn't there a comedy shtick about how incredible it is to fly at 30,000 feet in a padded seat sipping a drink crossing the country, and yet complain about the flight being 5 minutes late?

I wonder how you propose society should fix that.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by sooheon on Sunday September 03, 2017 @06:00AM (#15160596)
Louis CK, if we're thinking of the same bit. He makes exactly the point that it's not the magnitude of your material wealth that makes you happy. We think it should, which is why when it does not, comedy can be found. A system which only seems to measure and increase wealth is not going to produce many happy people.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by ehnto on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:00AM (#15160999)
Well, since you wondered! I don't have a solution. Or even a coherent summary of the problem. I'm not sure the problem is with capitalism specifically but how we've coerced all parts of life to align with it, when perhaps that wasn't necessary. An incredible amount of society is geared for nothing but enabling commerce. Career, status, housing, cars, gadgets, even areas of academia are just part of the pipeline of commerce.

I think we encourage people to chase a red herring, and to fail to catch it causes people huge distress, it's all they can focus on. But even if you are successful you can still come to realise it was all just part of the machine of commerce, and that's not really a very human or very compelling story.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by SamReidHughes on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:13PM (#15162897)
People are coerced into doing useful stuff for other people in all societies.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by dnautics on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:37AM (#15160334)
>highest ever recorded rate of anxiety, depression and suicide

What a problem to have!! You could instead be worried about plague, influenza, capricious wars, kidnapping, enslavement, childbirth, or the chirurgeon's leeches.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by bigmanwalter on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:50AM (#15160371)
Some would argue that a lifetime of depression causes more pain than a quick death by sword or plague. The goal is to eliminate suffering, not create new kinds.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @05:03AM (#15160410)
I suspect your preference for death by being chopped up or plague would evaporate if you were faced with it.

(Perhaps you don't know that death by sword was hardly quick. Death from sword injuries usually came hours or days later of agony. Star Wars has perpetrated a myth that hacking someone with a sword is somehow elegant and civilized.)

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by bigmanwalter on Sunday September 03, 2017 @05:07AM (#15160416)
Depression can last many years. I doubt you would brush it away so quickly if you'd ever experienced it.

Please note that my preference is to rid the world of both.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @05:17AM (#15160452)
Such depression is a medical condition, not a result of capitalism.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by bigmanwalter on Monday September 04, 2017 @04:14AM (#15166565)
PTSD is a medical condition, and is the result of capitalism's wars. Medical conditions and the results of capitalism aren't mutually exclusive.

For another example, consider cancers and other health problems brought on by unregulated pollution.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by WalterBright on Monday September 04, 2017 @02:41PM (#15170066)
Socialists start lots of wars.

Poland under communism became the most polluted country on the planet. Capitalism provides the surplus necessary to deal with pollution.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by bigmanwalter on Friday September 08, 2017 @02:37AM (#15198277)
Laissez faire capitalism has horrifically polluted our planet. Our climate is fucked. It is only through socially minded policies that we might fix it.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by splintercell on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:15AM (#15159658)
Capitalism in India (and many other countries), 1990- is bringing enormous, unprecedented and historic improvements in poverty levels.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by makotech222 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:18AM (#15159669)
State Capitalism / Socialism in the USSR did the same in less than half the time.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:15AM (#15159963)
US industrial agriculture kept the USSR afloat in the 70s as it was unable to feed itself. Kansas was dubbed "the breadbasket of the Soviet Union". The historical threat of famine ended in the US around 1800 and was an early dividend of free market agriculture.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by rev_bird on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:12AM (#15160092)
I'm not sure I see the connection. The United States lucked into natural resources more plentiful than lots of other places in the world, that's true, but is it meaningful that a country be able to "feed itself"? Obviously it's a valuable thing to have, strategically, but I don't see how "they had lots of imports" is necessarily an indictment of an entire economic system. Nobody makes fun of Ireland for importing $5 billion+ in foodstuffs every year, it's just one of the things they're short of.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:40AM (#15160343)
The Ukraine fed europe until its agriculture was collectivized. Famine resulted. Collectivization of agriculture has been tried again and again, and famine always results.

You might want to read up on Lenin's New Economic Policy:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Economic_Policy

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by rev_bird on Sunday September 03, 2017 @05:13AM (#15160439)
Will do, thanks for the recommendations.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by EGreg on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:50AM (#15161168)
The USSR did indeed have problems after collectivizing farms in the Ukraine. However, that ended much earlier than the 70s. The USA did a lot to counteract the USSR. The Marshall Plan helped Europe recover after World War 2, but not USSR or Eastern Bloc. NATO was created to counteract the Warsaw Pact. The USA claims to have lost a lot in WW2 but perhaps you forget that the USSR lost 30 million people! Most of these people were men.

And yet, within a few short decades, without much economic help from the USA, the USSR not only rebounded but helped raise many Muslim republics like Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, etc. from a pre-industrial age to sky high literacy rates, spread electricity, manufacturing etc. The average quality of life greatly improved under the USSR. Everyone started speaking Russian.

Empires tend to do this kind of thing in general, regardless of their economic system. When we say "Chinese invented paper 2000 years ago" or "Arabs invented algebra" what we are really talking about is empires which disseminated knowledge that was obtained in one part of it by some people.

What would you say these republics had before "Communism" came? Was it Capitalism? Because they were dirt-poor on average per capita and couldn't read.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:35AM (#15161605)
America provided enormous assistance to the USSR during WW2.

https://www.rbth.com/business/2015/05/08/allies_gave_soviets...

Consider the difference in the economies of east and west Germany. Consider the wall the Soviets had to build to keep people from leaving to western europe. It wasn't just a fence - it was barbed wire, guard towers, minefields, machine guns, etc. I traveled through it in 1969 for a tour of East Berlin. It was no joke.

As for the Marshall Plan, most of it went to rebuild Britain and France.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan#Expenditures

West Germany turned to free market capitalism after WW2, and that's where the economic miracle happened, becoming the strongest economy in europe, despite having been quite thoroughly devastated and looted, and having lost a generation of men.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by sooheon on Sunday September 03, 2017 @06:09AM (#15160630)
Stratfor's famous analysis of the geopolitics of the US[1] makes clear that this was due to the phenomenal and unprecedented geographical conditions the US enjoyed, not merely "a dividend of free market agriculture".

> The most distinctive and important feature of North America is the river network in the middle third of the continent...

> The network consists of six distinct river systems: the Missouri, Arkansas, Red, Ohio, Tennessee and, of course, the Mississippi. The unified nature of this system greatly enhances the region's usefulness and potential economic and political power. First, shipping goods via water is an order of magnitude cheaper than shipping them via land. The specific ratio varies greatly based on technological era and local topography, but in the petroleum age in the United States, the cost of transport via water is roughly 10 to 30 times cheaper than overland. This simple fact makes countries with robust maritime transport options extremely capital-rich when compared to countries limited to land-only options. This factor is the primary reason why the major economic powers of the past half-millennia have been Japan, Germany, France, the United Kingdom and the United States.

> Second, the watershed of the Greater Mississippi Basin largely overlays North America's arable lands. Normally, agricultural areas as large as the American Midwest are underutilized as the cost of shipping their output to more densely populated regions cuts deeply into the economics of agriculture. The Eurasian steppe is an excellent example. Even in modern times Russian and Kazakh crops occasionally rot before they can reach market. Massive artificial transport networks must be constructed and maintained in order for the land to reach its full potential. Not so in the case of the Greater Mississippi Basin. The vast bulk of the prime agricultural lands are within 200 kilometers of a stretch of navigable river. Road and rail are still used for collection, but nearly omnipresent river ports allow for the entirety of the basin's farmers to easily and cheaply ship their products to markets not just in North America but all over the world.

> Third, the river network's unity greatly eases the issue of political integration. All of the peoples of the basin are part of the same economic system, ensuring constant contact and common interests. Regional proclivities obviously still arise, but this is not Northern Europe, where a variety of separate river systems have given rise to multiple national identities.

> It is worth briefly explaining why Stratfor fixates on navigable rivers as opposed to coastlines. First, navigable rivers by definition service twice the land area of a coastline (rivers have two banks, coasts only one). Second, rivers are not subject to tidal forces, greatly easing the construction and maintenance of supporting infrastructure. Third, storm surges often accompany oceanic storms, which force the evacuation of oceanic ports. None of this eliminates the usefulness of coastal ports, but in terms of the capacity to generate capital, coastal regions are a poor second compared to lands with navigable rivers.

Rather than risk copy pasting the entire thing, I'd simply urge you to read it, it's highly interesting if you want to go beyond ideological thinking (free market vs. soviets).

[1]: https://worldview.stratfor.com/article/geopolitics-united-st...

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:24AM (#15161555)
That doesn't explain the success of Japan, which has few natural resources.

Nor does it explain the collapse of Ukrainian agriculture under farm collectivization, the resurgence under the NEP, and the collapse again under collectivization.

Nor does it explain the repeated and uniform failure of collective agriculture to feed the population.

It does not explain the very different arcs of the free market northern and slave based southern economies from 1800 to 1865. See Cabot's "The Civil War" for a description.

Nor does it explain the general impoverishment of the South American economy.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by sooheon on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:23PM (#15162241)
Human made societies are very complex systems, that is why good analyses on economics or politics must be specific, or risk saying nothing at all. I linked to a geopolitical analysis on the development of the US, and rather than judge it on its merits, you scramble for counter examples all throughout history, against some perceived ideological thesis. Just read it (or don't), and let it add to you knowledge (or not). Don't expect one strategic analysis to explain... everything.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:44PM (#15162402)
It's pretty hard to do controlled experiments in economics, so what I do is look for common characteristics among successful economies. Free markets are consistently there, the other things mentioned - rivers, natural resources, etc. - are not.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by SamReidHughes on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:16PM (#15162923)
This is because their technology came pre-invented elsewhere. You grow faster when you start with 1920's technology instead of 1800's.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by mixmastamyk on Sunday September 03, 2017 @01:27AM (#15159838)
But was not sustainable.
[dead]
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @02:11AM (#15159946)
Do you mean during WW2 when US industry massively helped the USSR? That was under Stalin.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by rev_bird on Sunday September 03, 2017 @03:22AM (#15160114)
The murder thing gets brought up a lot, and it seems nonsensical to me for two reasons: First off, Russian communism gets blamed for millions of deaths, while American capitalism has never killed anyone. How many thousands of Americans die every year from lack of medical care? How many workers had their lives shortened (or ended) by unsafe working conditions? How many of those workers were children? How many millions will die of famine caused by runaway climate change that capitalists had no incentive to address? I'm not demanding answers, I just wanted to point out that if we're keeping score, we should consider both sides.

The other part that I can never square up in my head, particularly as it relates to the Holodomor and gulags and whatnot, is that those things don't seem particularly related to communism itself -- the starvation of the Ukrainians is a travesty, but one that was enabled by an authoritarian government, not a communist one. Unimaginably terrible things happened in the USSR, but was that because of communism, or because of the communist rulers?

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by pfisch on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:06AM (#15160237)
Historically most attempts to engineer society through force of law have had disastrous side effects, and have led to some of the most deadly atrocities in history. Communism is all about engineering society.

The Great Leap forward is probably the most intense example of this. The Five Year Plans of the USSR are another. The one child policy, prohibition, the war on drugs.

All of these policies go against human nature and while they are all at least somewhat effective at achieving their aims, they all have had massive terrible side effects. We are just not very good at predicting the outcomes when we try to engineer society and we should be very careful about its application, and probably we should attempt to not do it when possible. The natural state of man is capitalism, it predates recorded history.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by EGreg on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:57AM (#15161203)
The problem is that the natural state leads to a lot of death as well.

Monogamy is not a natural state either by the way. Because after a war, there were far more women than men.

Technology has caused unprecedented peace among man. It is technology, far more than capitalism, that has enabled plenty and endef slavery and feudalism.

You think people couldn't own things before the 1800s? People owned tons of things. The ideology of free-market capitalism says that every era of human history that was miserable was that way because they didn't have free-market capitalism. But free-market capitalism as you conceive of it only became possible after a certain technological prosperity had been achieved. And it still doesn't exist today. The USA is more socialist than some other less prosperous countries.

Look for example at Africa. There were never any large empires there and as a result the tribes engaged in endless fighting against one another. As a result the technological (and military) capabilities of the peoples fell behind and they were easily conquered by Europeans later. This would have happened whether they had capitalism or socialism, the political units (of unified language or religion, no fighting between inside the polity etc.) were just too small for any meaningful growth to take place and knowledge to be disseminated.

If the natural state of man is capitalism and it predates recorded history, then it sure takes a long time to achieve anything. All the populaton explosion has happened in the last 200 years.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by vixen99 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:27AM (#15160303)
Poverty is the natural state of mankind. How many more millions would exist in dire misery were it not for the development of wealth creation in the West.

You might want to look at Robert Conquest's The Great Terror - "Exact numbers may never be known with complete certainty, but the total of deaths caused by the whole range of Soviet regime's terrors can hardly be lower than some fifteen million."

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @04:47AM (#15160367)
Check out the book "The Black Book of Communism" by Courtois if you think the grim harvest of communism is restricted to the USSR.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by musage on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:53AM (#15159756)
That's kinda like me saying how to comfort a child is not part of the C++ standard, and you replying someone used an app written with it to comfort their child when they had to work overseas. Nothing in the C++ standard says they couldn't also have used it to send them hateful messages, or a drone. That's the point.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by kobeya on Saturday September 02, 2017 @11:57PM (#15159611)
> Capitalism only works in optimizing those things it measures in the first place. Progress of society does not even enter into it, at all. If 300 million people had nothing and screamed in pain all day, and one person had it it all and multiplied it by X, the GDP would be multiplied by X. So what kind of measure is that?

A utilitarian would say that is a equal outcome to everyone having equal measures of happiness.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by arthur_pryor on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:16AM (#15159664)
> A utilitarian would say that is a equal outcome to everyone having equal measures of happiness.

lots of people (myself included) would strongly posit that utilitarianism is a thoroughly incomplete foundation for a moral framework.

to be clear, i think it's absurd and callous to treat those outcomes as equal for anything other than a back of the envelope calculation or a thought experiment.

if you're going to put forward a philosophy 101 idea, at least do the philosophy 101 level work of trying to defend a controversial point of view against charitable objections.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by kobeya on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:19AM (#15159672)
My point is that you cannot replace GDP with a better metric of societal "goodness" without objectivity defining "good", and that is an unsolved problem.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by musage on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:48AM (#15159743)
What makes the GDP "better" than any other "objective" measurement then? Why not take number of citizens multiplied with how many corners their furniture has in total?

There is no easy metric for societal goodness, likely not even a complicated "objective" one. Capitalism is like a blind man demanding a painting make a sound for it to exist. Since it can only measure numbers, it doesn't even attempt to answer the question of societal goodness or any other interesting ones. That is beyond its scope, and that's that's why you shouldn't mix up things like "GDP" and "progress of society".

You might say capitalism is a combustion engine, without anything additional it just eats energy and spins. The idea was, or rather is now claimed to have been, that since consumers are informed and aren't going to buy things that harm them, we'll end up with progress. Instead too many too powerful corporations are playing their clients like a piano and subvert governments, often enough in concert, and produce plenty of harm (and, to be fair, also good) that doesn't even get to enter the equation, because it's not a number or a contract etc.

Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates by qq66 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:27AM (#15159694)
No, because actual measured happiness shows strongly decreasing marginal utility of money.