Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates
by sooheon on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:23PM
(#15162241)
Human made societies are very complex systems, that is why good analyses on economics or politics must be specific, or risk saying nothing at all. I linked to a geopolitical analysis on the development of the US, and rather than judge it on its merits, you scramble for counter examples all throughout history, against some perceived ideological thesis. Just read it (or don't), and let it add to you knowledge (or not). Don't expect one strategic analysis to explain... everything.
Re:Wealth: redistribution and interest rates
by WalterBright on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:44PM
(#15162402)
It's pretty hard to do controlled experiments in economics, so what I do is look for common characteristics among successful economies. Free markets are consistently there, the other things mentioned - rivers, natural resources, etc. - are not.
Nor does it explain the collapse of Ukrainian agriculture under farm collectivization, the resurgence under the NEP, and the collapse again under collectivization.
Nor does it explain the repeated and uniform failure of collective agriculture to feed the population.
It does not explain the very different arcs of the free market northern and slave based southern economies from 1800 to 1865. See Cabot's "The Civil War" for a description.
Nor does it explain the general impoverishment of the South American economy.