News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by RationPhantoms on Thursday August 24, 2017 @08:52AM (#15089661)
And let's quantify the waste of resources by storing vast buckets of useless data people put on the internet. Snapchat, Instagram, Facebook, Google Plus. What about the PoP's the house the IP transit traffic? How about the thousands of advertisement/Spam companies that just add to the noise? Telemarketers and their like (legal and not).

Surely there is a better argument to be made here. Speculative "mining" on consumer purchased hardware is hardly near the top of global wasted resources.

Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by jondubois on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:17AM (#15090268)
Yes, pretty much everything in our current economy is extremely inefficient. In terms of waste, cryptocurrencies are peanuts.

- Facebook ad spending is a waste; do companies actually get a ROI on all the money they give to Facebook? They don't actually know! In the grand scheme of things it's a complete waste. If Facebook didn't exist, then companies wouldn't be forced to pay it money just to stay relevant; they could focus their funds on actually improving their products instead. Not to mention the enormous amount of otherwise productive human hours that Facebook is responsible for wasting every day. That's not even counting all the other social networks.

- Gambling; $240 billion per year; the money does nothing for society. The amount of money spent on gambling every year is MORE than the total market capitalization of all cryptocurrencies added up together. So even if you think that buying a cryptocurrency is gambling, your odds are much better (and improve as you do more research). If people stopped gambling on horses and lottery and started gambling with cryptocurrencies instead, the total market cap for cryptocurrencies would be much higher than it is now.

- Sports; the sport industry makes $75 billion per year. Yes it's entertainment. So is trading cryptocurrencies.

- Tobacco industry makes $35 billion in PROFITS per year. Doesn't add anything positive to society. I think that if you were to add up all fees (profits) ever charged for transferring cryptocurrencies, you wouldn't get anything close to $35 billion.

Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by eridius on Thursday August 24, 2017 @01:46PM (#15092307)
> In terms of waste, cryptocurrencies are peanuts.

I don't have a link for you, but just yesterday I read a headline saying bitcoin mining accounts for 5% of the UK's energy expenditure. That's not peanuts.

Now, even if that headline is wrong, here's a site that offers a Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index Chart (https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption) and they say that bitcoin accounts for 0.08% of the world's electricity consumption. That seems absurdly high.

Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by Mahn on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:30AM (#15090376)
> Facebook ad spending is a waste; do companies actually get a ROI on all the money they give to Facebook?

Yes they do, and yes they know. Facebook is very effective at reaching qualified leads, it's not "likes" or "engagement" what advertisers are buying.

Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by jondubois on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:43AM (#15090466)
Maybe for a small subset of the total advertising spend, but for the big players, they can't always be sure which part of their revenue can be attributed to Facebook and which part can be attributed to other sources or which part can be attributed to their sheer scale (everyone knows about Coca Cola, but that won't stop the company from spending big on advertising). Companies like Procter and Gamble started scaling back their Facebook ad spend; they had no idea what their FB ROI was until they actually started scaling back and they realized that it was essentially $0.
Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by bira on Thursday August 24, 2017 @12:44PM (#15091672)
If they can't measure their ROI, big or small the players, it's their fault, not Facebook. It's not that hard to deploy direct marketing campaigns and monitor conversions. It's actually the ABC of online marketing.
Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by Mahn on Thursday August 24, 2017 @12:36PM (#15091575)
I don't think that lead generation ad spending on facebook represents a small subset of the total advertising spend on there. Sure, there are always going to be monolithic companies that market poorly on facebook, but from my experience this is not the norm, and a lot of companies and startups are marketing on facebook without blindly throwing money at it.
Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by DKnoll on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:24AM (#15090329)
Jon, all I need to do to check if any internet ad campaign is effective is check analytics. Facebook Ads can be very effective.

Gambling pays for many social services through (heavy) taxation and government-run lotteries.

Sports promote fitness.

Cigarettes make me look cool (kidding).

Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by neilwilson on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:36AM (#15090414)
"Gambling pays for many social services through (heavy) taxation and government-run lotteries."

It doesn't. That's the myth that keeps you supporting the system.

The truth is the other way around. https://medium.com/modern-money-matters/the-magic-money-tree...

Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by DKnoll on Thursday August 24, 2017 @11:31AM (#15090902)
That article is nonsensical.

Also which system are we referring to, there are an infinite number.

Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by sjm on Thursday August 24, 2017 @08:59AM (#15089705)
So your argument is because it's not the "top of globally wasted resources", we should ignore the waste? It's a large enough industry that GPU stock and prices are hugely affected by it, and its much more conventionally wasteful than the services you're trying to compare it to. Plus if the goal of cryptocurrency is to become more mainstream, this is a super important argument to make against it in its current form.
Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by dozzie on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:10AM (#15089761)
> So your argument is because it's not the "top of globally wasted resources", we should ignore the waste?

Sometimes this argumentation is totally valid. For example, it's utterly stupid reasoning when one uses less water at home "to save fresh water and environment", because households use half of the fresh water used by industry, and agriculture uses twice as much as the two combined. Whatever inconvenience the person trying to save the environment this way puts themselves into, the effect is capped at about 10% of total fresh water consumption. It's an effort applied in the wrong place.

Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by chenglou on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:57AM (#15090126)
Saving water or such is a mentality and you might not be able to measure it through a simple people * saving/person. If everyone's wasteful there'd be way less incentive to nudge industries into changing. Where would the change be coming from?

More philosophically speaking, if there's an equation of life with all the variables and we apply it here by taking all the "saved effort thanks to not promoting water consciousness in regular households" and dumping it into whichever area we'd think is ideally efficient, it wouldn't be _too_ surprising if holistically, the result comes out less favorable of this approach vs just telling regular folks to save water. For example, consider that it might take tenfold the effort to convince an agricultural company CEO to change approach; if ninefold the effort doesn't reach the activation energy to convince such person then you're better off telling nine people to stop the waste.

In general, I have the feeling that many decisions can wrongly be made to look stupid if we recalculate it using the select few variables we care about.

Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by dozzie on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:15AM (#15090254)
> If everyone's wasteful there'd be way less incentive to nudge industries into changing.

Ah yes, "let's show them not to be wasteful". Ever heard of the activities of making industries not to use child labour or improve working conditions of factory workers? If they didn't work, why do you think this one would?

> Where would the change be coming from?

Certainly not from social movements. They rarely have enough power to make a single company change, much less a whole industry.

Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by Cerium on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:13AM (#15090237)
Saving water can still be a false mentality. For example, my wife's hometown has poor water infrastructure. On vacation days everyone is home and nobody saves since the source is plenty. By noon the infrastructure is overloaded and gives out until evening. If people were more frugal everyone could have water all day.
Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by volkk on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:03AM (#15089724)
I could be completely wrong (I don't fully immerse myself in cryptocurrency) but isn't mining coins way more heavily intensive on a CPU and overall power consumption than simply passively storing a lot of personal data?

I remember a couple of friends wanting to buy some powerful machines to mine bitcoins a few years ago, and they had to actually calculate their electricity bill to make sure they weren't losing money. That's quite a ways from storing Instagram pics.

Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by seqastian on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:39AM (#15089991)
The argument is not about individual intensity, but about absolute numbers. Millions of people on facebook/google/twitter compared to few crypto miners.
Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by volkk on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:59AM (#15090136)
I would hesitate to use the word "few."

Imagine the power consumption in a place like this: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/qkvxk3/chinas-big...

Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by KekDemaga on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:12AM (#15090234)
Instagram et all provides humans with a great deal of value compared to bitcoin though. Rather than hashing random things they allow communication and entertainment.
Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by adamnemecek on Thursday August 24, 2017 @10:16AM (#15090264)
Don't project your preferences on others.
Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by root_axis on Thursday August 24, 2017 @11:00AM (#15090626)
The energy spent to facilitate these services are incidental to the work being performed; the total energy spent is a function of the task being accomplished. "Proof of work", on the other hand, is wasteful by design, which is obvious when you consider that "the work" itself is not useful, all that's useful is the assumption that the cost of wasting energy is too great to be worth it for a malicious actor. That isn't to say that POW cryptocurrencies themselves are useless, but they are certainly wasteful. An aversion to waste is literally the security mechanism.
Re:Don't mine Bitcoin, mine Altcoins by beepboopbeep on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:23AM (#15089842)
Why isn't the current argument valuable unto it self? We don't need to equate it to anything in order to measure it's worth (or lack there of). It's a valid statement that can be discussed. If you want to do the same for other data, go for it, but in another conversation.