News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by emmp on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @07:37PM (#15086208)
Why not? As long as its vegan margarine. Its clean of at least a subset of ethical concerns that many foods are not. Clean is a very overloaded word though so I certainly see where you're coming from, but it works just fine for me.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by fish_fan on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @09:51PM (#15087002)
Well, butter is a well-defined substance; there's a reason why "I can't believe it's not butter" isn't called "better butter".

Furthermore margarine is associated with health risks that butter is not; clean is just disingenuous.

Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by nkoren on Thursday August 24, 2017 @03:16AM (#15088244)
Fair enough, but margarine is not a good analogy to in-vitro meat. It's a substance that has very little molecular resemblance to butter. In-vitro meat, however, is meat. It's not a different substance -- it's just produced in a different way.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by overcast on Thursday August 24, 2017 @08:48AM (#15089626)
Yes, but margarine isn't butter, this lab grown meat is actually the same product. You're comparing a substitute, to a replacement.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by maxerickson on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @07:45PM (#15086260)
It would probably be illegal to market a product that wasn't butter as "Clean Butter", because there are rules about labeling things as butter.

So I won't be surprised if the animal products industry lobbies for rules about what can be called meat (or if such rules already exist).

Of course such labeling concerns don't apply to an internet discussion, but they do indicate that people care about what's in a name.

Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by yellowapple on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @09:08PM (#15086810)
Usually, though, lab-grown meat is actually meat. It's possible that it'd have to be labeled "synthetic" or "lab-grown" (similar to how synthetic diamonds are named), but claiming that meat is not meat is nonsensical.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by maxerickson on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @09:17PM (#15086854)
Well what's the definition of meat?

A typical simple one is "animal flesh". Cells grown in a vat aren't flesh, they are a tissue culture.

Note that I'm not particularly animated by the issue, I just don't agree that it is as simple as "claiming that meat is not meat".

Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by FeepingCreature on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @10:59PM (#15087296)
This seems like a particular definition of "flesh" that's not particularly germane to meatness. Lab meat is made of the exact same animal cells that regular meat is, the tissue just happens to never have inhabited an animal. When we eat meat, we don't value the fact that the cells we're eating were once part of an animal, we mostly value the taste.

It seems to me that this isn't a necessarily property of meat but a contingent one caused by the fact that meat used to only be possible to produce from animal flesh.

Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by coldtea on Thursday August 24, 2017 @07:41AM (#15089241)
>When we eat meat, we don't value the fact that the cells we're eating were once part of an animal, we mostly value the taste

You'd be surprised. We even have different names and preferences for different age stages of the animal, different varieties of the animal (regional etc), etc.

Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by jonathanpoulter on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:25AM (#15089868)
Those distinctions exist because of the perceived impact on the tastes and textures of meat. Not because of anything such as ethical preferences to old/young animals.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by maxerickson on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @11:09PM (#15087337)
I'm pretty sure it is not a particular definition.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by mmisu on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @11:46PM (#15087442)
Diamonds are pretty simple from a chemical point of view, atoms of Carbon linked together in a particular structure. You can't compare something as complex as creating animal meat with creating synthetic diamonds.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by jhbadger on Thursday August 24, 2017 @07:51AM (#15089291)
Absolutely -- some dairy producing states like Wisconsin have forced makers of soy and almond milk to stop calling them "milk" so I'm almost positive that meat producing states would do the same.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by theBobBob on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:56AM (#15090122)
I'm always annoyed (admittedly only slightly) when they are referred to as milk. Nothing wrong with soy milk, but milk it is not.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by upvotinglurker on Thursday August 24, 2017 @01:05PM (#15091881)
FWIW I've seen medieval recipes containing almond milk (referred to as milk or equivalent period word), so calling such substances milk is not a newfangled idea.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by mmisu on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @10:35PM (#15087184)
> Of course such labeling concerns don't apply to an internet discussion, but they do indicate that people care about what's in a name.

Calling something clean meat, based purely on arbitrary ethical grounds, implies that what other people eat and call meat is somehow unclean. It is a value judgement on the others.

Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by ggreer on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @11:04PM (#15087319)
I assumed "clean" referred to the fact that lab-grown tissue would have a much lower risk of disease. Animals have digestive tracts full of bacteria, and farms aren't exactly pristine. Every year in the US, meat-borne pathogens kill thousands and sicken millions.[1]

1. https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/5/5/99-0502_article

Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by mmisu on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @11:40PM (#15087426)
> I assumed "clean" referred to the fact that lab-grown tissue would have a much lower risk of disease. Animals have digestive tracts full of bacteria, and farms aren't exactly pristine. Every year in the US, meat-borne pathogens kill thousands and sicken millions.

OK, let's check the numbers.

According to the CDC https://www.cdc.gov/foodborneburden/attribution/attribution-... from 1998 - 2008 from the total of foodborn illnesses 46% were linked to plant based, 22% to meat and poultry, 20% to dairy and eggs and 6% to fish products. From the total number of deaths 23% were linked to plant based products, 29% to meat and poultry (19% to poultry).

You can see a more detailed graphic here https://www.cdc.gov/foodborneburden/attribution-image.html#f...

Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by ggreer on Thursday August 24, 2017 @12:47AM (#15087655)
A couple of points:

1. The percentages you cite aren’t useful on their own, as one also needs to know how often each kind of food is consumed. Only then would we know the relative risk of eating each kind of food.

2. Most food plants are grown outdoors (often near livestock) and many aren’t cooked before eating. Cultured meat is grown in sterile environments and is typically cooked. These differences mean that it will almost certainly have a lower disease risk than any natural food.

Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by mmisu on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:29AM (#15089901)
So, I should accept your millions of sick people generality supported with a CDC link as a useful information. Why wouldn't you accept the cold hard numbers given by the same organization ?

> Cultured meat is grown in sterile environments and is typically cooked. These differences mean that it will almost certainly have a lower disease risk than any natural food.

Maybe, or maybe we'll discover in 10 years that eating lab grown meat gives you some form of cancer. Until it is used on a large scale for a number of years (as in decades) we have no idea what the effect of consuming lab grown meat has on ones health.

Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by ggreer on Thursday August 24, 2017 @12:15PM (#15091354)
> Maybe, or maybe we'll discover in 10 years that eating lab grown meat gives you some form of cancer. Until it is used on a large scale for a number of years (as in decades) we have no idea what the effect of consuming lab grown meat has on ones health.

We can know it's safe without a long track record of use because of biology, chemistry, and physics. Cultured meat is the same muscle cells with the same DNA. If it caused cancer but animal meat didn't, that would tell us something new about biology, chemistry, and/or physics.

Your fear-mongering postulates unknown mechanisms of action that science would almost certainly have discovered by now. That's not just unscientific, it's anti-scientific. It's on the same level as, "What if cell phones cause cancer?" or "What if vaping is worse than smoking?"

Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by mncharity on Thursday August 24, 2017 @01:04PM (#15091877)
When some folks wondered "how could you possibly persuade people to pay more for hydroponic vegetables?", my first thought was "get your vegetables, now with fewer bacterial brain cysts!" Vat meat vs incompletely cooked meat, is similar to hydroponic vs incompletely washed vegetables in this. I've no idea what the current state of research is on cysts vis autoimmune diseases.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by dasil003 on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @08:11PM (#15086460)
The ethics might work, but the metabolization might not.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by mmisu on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @07:50PM (#15086309)
Calling meat grown in a lab clean meat is just a marketing gimmick that could potentially make people believe they eat natural grown meat.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by KGIII on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @10:19PM (#15087129)
It does confuse me, as a term. Pretty much every bit of meat that I eat was harvested and processed by myself or my neighbor. Given that we are going to be the folks eating it, it's pretty clean.

I clean my fish, deer, moose, beef critter, fowl, etc... I clean them very well. (They are delicious.)

Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by coldtea on Thursday August 24, 2017 @07:43AM (#15089249)
>Pretty much every bit of meat that I eat was harvested and processed by myself or my neighbor

You do understand that you are the very definition of an outlier, right?

So it would OK if the term only confused you, since you are supposed to be confused, given that you do these things differently than 99.99% of the population.

But I think the term is confusing in general, not just to people who "kill and clean their own meat".

Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by KGIII on Thursday August 24, 2017 @01:19PM (#15092030)
That's certainly true, but I suspect I'd have been just as confused even before I moved here. Today, I know my meat is pretty clean. Back then, I'd have assumed it was clean because it hadn't made me sick.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by lawless123 on Thursday August 24, 2017 @07:05AM (#15089099)
by clean they mean its not made from cows farting into the atmosphere
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ... by mmisu on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:22AM (#15089832)
What about cold rice? By cold I mean it was grown in my lab, no fart was released in the process. Would you buy cold rice from me ?