Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ...
by yellowapple on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @09:08PM
(#15086810)
Usually, though, lab-grown meat is actually meat. It's possible that it'd have to be labeled "synthetic" or "lab-grown" (similar to how synthetic diamonds are named), but claiming that meat is not meat is nonsensical.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ...
by maxerickson on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @09:17PM
(#15086854)
Well what's the definition of meat?
A typical simple one is "animal flesh". Cells grown in a vat aren't flesh, they are a tissue culture.
Note that I'm not particularly animated by the issue, I just don't agree that it is as simple as "claiming that meat is not meat".
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ...
by FeepingCreature on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @10:59PM
(#15087296)
This seems like a particular definition of "flesh" that's not particularly germane to meatness. Lab meat is made of the exact same animal cells that regular meat is, the tissue just happens to never have inhabited an animal. When we eat meat, we don't value the fact that the cells we're eating were once part of an animal, we mostly value the taste.
It seems to me that this isn't a necessarily property of meat but a contingent one caused by the fact that meat used to only be possible to produce from animal flesh.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ...
by coldtea on Thursday August 24, 2017 @07:41AM
(#15089241)
>When we eat meat, we don't value the fact that the cells we're eating were once part of an animal, we mostly value the taste
You'd be surprised. We even have different names and preferences for different age stages of the animal, different varieties of the animal (regional etc), etc.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ...
by jonathanpoulter on Thursday August 24, 2017 @09:25AM
(#15089868)
Those distinctions exist because of the perceived impact on the tastes and textures of meat. Not because of anything such as ethical preferences to old/young animals.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ...
by maxerickson on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @11:09PM
(#15087337)
I'm pretty sure it is not a particular definition.
Re:Billionaires and big ag are joining venture investors to ...
by mmisu on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @11:46PM
(#15087442)
Diamonds are pretty simple from a chemical point of view, atoms of Carbon linked together in a particular structure. You can't compare something as complex as creating animal meat with creating synthetic diamonds.