If we didn't have a taboo around theft and unprovoked aggression, the only thing protecting us from regular muggings would be the police. I have a feeling that wouldn't work very well.
https://www.facebook.com/brenebrown/videos/1778878652127236/
(For background...she's done about 20 years of research on shame and did a couple wildly viral TED talks.)
Far-eastern countries like China/Japan/Korea and honor-based cultures like the Middle East tend to be much more shame-based. It's not unheard of in America to go to prison, do their time, get out, and start a huge company (IBM, for one). Or to go bankrupt 4 times, sexually assault women, have this all highlighted on national TV, and still end up president. This would be unheard of in a culture like China, where you basically need a squeaky-clean public image (what you do in private is a different story) to get anywhere.
You mean Bill Clinton? I think you're misinterpreting societal shame. Far east countries, as you call them, do have heavy shame and saving-face issues, but society as a whole recognizes that shame. In America, the shame is never-ending, and it's used as a weapon. It becomes less about a societal tool to punish bad behavior, than as a sick and twisted mechanism for one person, totally unrelated, to exact some harmful retribution.
My other point is that when it's just one person, totally unrelated, trying to exact some harmful retribution on a person, that's not shame, that's vengeance. Shaming requires enough of a consensus that you can convince a person, in their own head, that they're a bad person. And this is easier to do with some people than others: I remember being bullied extensively as a teenager until I was convinced that I was worthless as a person, while now, in my 30s, I'd just think "Wow, those were some really fucked up kids that I never want to see again in my life."
But in terms of actual objective consequences to these shaming episodes, in American society - they're pretty light, as long as the victim has enough inner strength to shrug it off and just find new people. Clinton and Trump both became president. Mel Gibson and John Downey Jr. are still making movies. Brendan Eich, another prominent case of an Internet shaming mob, ended up founding Brave and raising $40M via ICO. Andrew Torba got blacklisted by YC and virtually every Silicon Valley company, but Gab is the darling of the Breitbart crowd. Like I said in another comment, no matter how offensive your views, you can always find another American who shares them.
What happened with me resigning from Mozilla was something other than a shaming incident. Anyone aware of California Law, corporate governance, and Mozilla's CEO history who was paying attention should be able to figure it out.
I'm also wondering why HN is having dozens of articles hit the frontpage defending white supremacists. I distinctly remember a general agreement of get-a-job when Occupy Wall Street was forced off the streets by police.
And I don't know what that has to do with OWS or the feeling that they should get jobs.
Some people conflate defending the free speech rights of white supremacists as being pro-white supremacist.
I may be misinterpreting him for sure! That's part of why I asked.