> it's clear that the text of the memo is unabashedly sexist
Just to be sure, I looked up the definitions:
sexism: "prejudice, stereotyping, or discrimination, typically against women, on the basis of sex"
sterotype: "a widely held but fixed and oversimplified image or idea of a particular type of person or thing"
Do these seem like reasonable definitions to you? If so, I wonder if you can take a moment to clearly connect points in the memo to these definitions?
The primary cause of the gender gap is tech is the lack of a gender-balanced candidate pool for tech jobs. If you're a hiring manager posting developer jobs and 80% of the applicants are men, is it sexist that you end up hiring mostly men?
The real sexism problems are happening much earlier in life than when people start looking for jobs. If you want gender balance in tech jobs, we need to get more women into tech-focused college degrees, which means we need to get more girls interested in tech in primary school, which means we need to encourage teaching and parenting in early development that leads to an interest in tech later... etc. But wait, prenatal hormone exposure predicts toy choices in young children [1], so it's not that simple. This is exactly what Damore was trying to get at.
I think we need to split the gender problem in tech into a few different categories and tackle each independently rather than throwing everything in the "tech is sexist" bucket and looking for magic umbrella solutions. At a minimum, there are problems with getting girls interested in tech, keeping girls on an education path that leads to a tech career, eliminating subconscious bias in hiring practices, moving startups away from bro culture, and retaining women in tech when work-life balance becomes more important. All of these are important and require different solutions.
Whether these differences are entirely do to their parents or society steering them toward traditional 20th century gender roles, or are due to prenatal hormones, or some mix of these, or something else entirely, they are real and are there long before the kids are even thinking of a real career.
If we want to get more girls interested in tech (so that they will grow up to become women interested in tech), maybe we should try to find ways to make tech more useful for and relevant to "girl interests".
I remember a story maybe a year or two ago about someone starting a "get girls to code" program that was based on that idea. It was organized around things like jewelry making and fashion, and how programming could be used to help with those areas--in other words, it was organized around things that a large fraction of ordinary American pre-teen/young teen girls like to spend their spare time doing.
It, of course, went down under a hail of criticism that it was trying to force girls into the outmoded gender stereotypes of the oppressive patriarchy or something like that.
In light of that, we're left with an awkward situation. Should we force kids to play with certain toys and do certain activities even if they're not interested just so we can get to gender balance in lucrative fields? Maybe. Parents certainly do that sort of thing already with piano lessons and language classes. But if you don't think that's a good way to go, then you have to be open to the possibility that, left to their own choices, fewer girls will be interested in things that lead to a tech career than their male counterparts. Certainly it should be better than the (at best) 70/30 split we see now, but targeting 50/50 is not realistic.
Being a geek at one point was like that, then it became cool.
Anyway point is, even if a parent raises their kid(s) gender-neutral or even pushes them towards STEM or whatever (for whatever reason), there's still peer pressure - but also support! - to either continue or move away from it.
In my personal experience, I got support from other kids that had computers at home (for example). I know my sister didn't have that, so while she'd use the computer at home, their friends had no interest in it. (she ended up doing biology, works at a hospital now)
[1] http://slatestarcodex.com/2017/08/07/contra-grant-on-exagger...
And stating that does not make me sexist. If you believe it does, then you are not using reason to arrive at that conclusion. It is a logical fallacy.
If we take a look at the recent spate of articles covering sexism and harassment in the workplace at companies in the field, it is clear that there is a problem. If someone were at the point in their lives where they were choosing a field in which to place their career, they may very well choose one where their gender would be less of an issue. That causes a gender gap.
It's clear as day to everyone that there is a problem. It is not clear that the problem is sexism. In my view, the problem is economic inequality which is ratcheting social pressures up to a fever pitch. Many people see their quality of life slipping away and the intellectual class fighting for their chance to tighten the screws. Social entropy is increasing dramatically and the social contract is in dire peril.
This is something I haven't read before regarding this debate, I think it makes a lot of sense - if the economic consequences weren't so significant, people on both sides would likely be far less passionate about this topic.
I am not so sure about that. I would not be at all surprised if racial resentment increases during times of economic turmoil. My understanding is that during tough economic times industries like alcohol/gambling preform far better then the market as a whole. I would not be surprised at all if scapegoating of "outgroups" (both black and white) incresses during economic tough times. See Nazi Germany circa 1930s.
It seems to me like quite a strong statement. Let's say you are doing something using strategy X. I come over and point out, maybe the strategy X is not quite working and you should rather try strategy Y, for these reasons. Would you call this "working against your efforts"?
AFAIK, he didn't sabotage anything, he just disagreed and wrote it up. You don't have to read it, you don't have to switch to strategy Y, you don't have to do anything, you can just not care at all.
And this memo certainly works against both of those goals.
Well.. if I genuinely want to help you, and you misstate your goals, for whatever reasons, you are only hurting yourself. Here Google probably lost a decent engineer.
This sometimes happens in authoritarian organizations, where people who genuinely want to follow the orders from the top will misunderstand the indirect meaning, causing more harm for the organization (and sometimes it can be exploited). Actually, I believe that's why authoritarian organizations are less effective than democratic ones.
Gender imbalances exist in many professions (teaching, nursing, social work, counselling). I'm not sure sexism is sufficient to explain all of these.
Does sexism exist in tech? Sure, but I'm not sure it's any more pronounced than any other field. I also don't think females are always the victims. Should we try and right moral wrongs where we see them? Yes, I think we should.
It's really easy to highlight bad behavior as a cause of a "problem" that might not even be a problem. In other words, if we can focus our attention on eliminating sexism where we see it, the gender gap becomes a non-issue (even if it persists).
To put it another way, I believe we would need to make real and measurable progress on sexism as the cause of the gender gap before we start looking for other reasons or, as Damore would have it, deciding the status quo is as good as it gets.
There is actually another way to move past sexism as the primary cause - show that sexism is comparable in other fields with a much smaller gender gap. If Engineering has 2 "sexism units", Medicine has 2.3 and Law 1.5 for instance, that might imply that sexism isn't the cause of Engineering's gender gap - because otherwise we'd expect similar gaps in Law and Medicine.
Scenario 1:
Hiring policy : Best candidate for the job irrespective of race, religion, color, gender, sexual orientation, political affiliation.
A good Engineer who happens to be a woman: I work for Google. :)
Society: How awesome!!! You go, girl!!!
Scenario 2: Hiring policy : We are trying to have more gender diverse workforce.
A good Engineer who happens to be a woman: I work for Google. :/
Society: Nice! (Did she make it at Google because of gender diversity program?)
It was Google's announcement that declared their efforts to create a gender diverse workforce, created inferiority complex in the minds of the female engineers whether they got the job because they deserve it, or because they were women.It was Google's announcement for gender diverse workforce that created hostile work environment for women because now everyone, including other women, doubt if an engineer, who happens to be woman, made it because of the diversity program.
Google fired the whistle-blower. They shot the messenger.
Your sentence doesn't make sense to me. Is it a goal for Google to believe gender gaps are caused by sexism? Although after the firing of Damore it sounds almost plausible, deciding that your goal is to believe in something is still a rather sad endeavour.
The employers are not supposed to discriminate based on gender, race, religion, sexual orientation.
An externally enforced gender diversity is discrimination.
If a company has 100 programming jobs, decides to keep 50 for one specific gender, the company has created discriminatory hiring practice. It has discriminated based on gender.
Damore challenged this discrimination and got sacked. I think he can easily make a legal case for discrimination. If Google had said that they wanted 50/50 gender based representation at the level above Damore's title, then he clearly has a standing. Any male who was denied employment at Google has a standing to know if he was denied because of gender quotas.
Damore's argument is to not take gender into account in hiring practices at all. "Diversity" policies are, at the base of their argument, asking for discriminatory hiring practices.
There is no "diversity" law or mandate. If Google can define a diversity goal for some chosen slicing of the population into groups, may be based on race, may be based on gender, may be based on sexual orientation, may be based on height, and then goes on to seek equality of representation between those groups, then would it OK if some other company define equality based on if you are right handed or left handed? What if someone claims that all major religions should be equally represented in the workforce?
Is the 50/50 split based on gender mean that the company is done with being "diverse"? Which new grouping would then stake claim at equality?
Does Google believe in gender fluidity or do they believe in being cis-gendered? What if male engineers claim to be a female at the time of hiring, claiming gender fluidity, is Google going to get into business of keeping someone honest about what their gender is?
Treat everyone as individual, based on the individuals abilities and choices. Assuming "diversity" goals to ensure equality of outcome by some arbitrary definition of a "group" is by definition discrimination. Individuals, not "group" based on race, religion or gender.
Should Disney be forced to make movies with equal prince and princess lead roles? How about equal number of movies across all religions? Equal number of movies across all races?
Please show me where I am wrong on this. I would like to have correct view on this issue.
What if women actually deserved 80% of the jobs, by skill and temperament? Then the 50% goal is way under reality.
I'd like to see passive processes produce an equitable result too. But in the mean time, the car is pulling to the left, so I steer slightly right to compensate. Its a reasonable short-term response. Lesser of evils.
You are not hiring "women" as a group. You are hiring an individual to feel in a role, gender should not be looked at, at all. I would prefer if google conducts all interview in written format without disclosing name, hiding gender, or where the voice is scrambled so that you can't make out the gender of the interviewee.
If you claim that you know that a group based on gender deserved certain representation (80%), you are the one discriminating based on gender. What's your opinion about representation of Samoans in Google ranks? What % should they get? You have no way to back up your 80% claim.
>I'd like to see passive processes produce an equitable result too.
This is the problem. I don't think it is achievable, or worthy, to seek equitable results. Results can vary based on many factors, picking one aspect of an individual, their gender, and then asking to make it equal across the group equal to that aspect of the individual, is only going to give advantage to certain individuals of that group, individuals who may not be as handicapped by the group identity as you think. E.g. does a multi-millionaire African American lawyer's son deserve a seat at Medical school based on his race? Do the individual women who qualify at Google really represent the disadvantaged representatives of groups based on "gender"? Is Dianne Green who heads Google Cloud part of this disadvantaged group?
Equity in access to opportunity is what I can definitely agree. Let's strive to make education needed to qualify for a job at Google available at fingertips of as many kids as we can across the entire globe.
>But in the mean time, the car is pulling to the left, so I steer slightly right to compensate.
The corporate america and its leaders with their fiefdoms already exercise high control over the fate of the individual employees to work there. What if you are wrong and you over correct the car and crash it?
Do not discriminate at all. Define job requirements for what makes a good candidate for the job and then hire for those skills and abilities, no matter what race, gender or religion.
I fear that this argument is 'arguing toward a goal'. No real attempt to understand the situation is present. Instead, whatever supports a viewpoint is thrown into a paragraph. Cherry picking, straw men and fud result.
Discrimination is a problem; trying to counter it with goals is a praiseworthy attempt. Consider: to do nothing now means we're ok with the existing bias. Why is that, do you think? Because 'idealism'? I think its more insidious: Its 'ok' for men to have all the jobs now, because that's normal and right. Its scary to change.
> I fear that this argument is 'arguing toward a goal'. No real attempt to understand the situation is present.
> Discrimination is a problem
Do you see even the slightest bit of contradiction there?
We are talking about this, my friend, I hold no ill will towards you nor do I accuse you of any wrongdoing. If I had said something with "you", it was about the argument on the table.
>I claim no special knowledge. I think that's true of both of us.
Agreed.
>I speculate, what if the existing bias is actually excluding 80% of the women. A reasonable response is, "Yeah that would be awful, we should do something about it in that case".
The speculation is that the bias exists, and is based on gender, is significant to skew decision making, and is widespread i.e. held by majority, strong enough to warrant an active adjustment. Now, we are not talking about Saudi Arabia or Somalia, we are talking about the most liberal place in the USA i.e. California. The same google employees that support Democrats in droves, wanted first woman president, and call themselves progressives, and rally for immigrant and refugee rights and environment protection.
There are two things being assumed:
One: that there is bias that holds every woman inferior to any man. This assumption needs to be proven. That is insulting, ridiculous claim against the educated human beings that work at Google, many with wives, daughters, sisters, who call themselves liberal progressives, who would stand up for equality for all.
Two: that the demographic of google employment is because of this bias and nothing else, or at least significantly because of this bias. This assumption needs to be proven.
If you can't prove these two assumptions, you can't act as if the injustice has happened and needs to be corrected at once.
Who else would you let make same argument? For what issue would you allow them to draw same conclusions, based on as much proof, and demand similar action?
How about hijab wearing women vs. non-hijab wearing woman? Need equal or demographically equal representation? How about for-vaccination and anti-vaccination, need equal representation? How about evolution-deniers, need equal representation?
Equality for all doesn't mean 13% black, 80% white and 7% Hispanic, 33% Christian, 8% Jew, 20% Atheist, 45% woman, 40% man, 10% Trans, 10% LGBT, 60% straigt, 20% asexual. You would have put a job Ad for Muslim Gay Woman that is Hispanic. That is quota system.
Equality means it doesn't matter whether your name is Jen, Jose, Jerry or Jasmine, you are selected because of what you bring to the table for the job.
>I speculate
A kid who loves programming, wants to work for google, has taken college education that is needed, has spent countless hours of his own to learn new things, he gets rejected because Google wants to up the women count. That kid never realizes what happened to him as he walks out of the interview. That is wrong. I am not willing to do that because of a speculation.
Let me say this about Damore's claims... he asked for diversity of ideas. I disagree. Google is not in the business of having equal number of conservatives and progressives within its ranks. It has nothing to do with the job of programming gmail or youtube. Workplaces are last hangouts for people where they come together, outside of their individual bubble. We do not need to politicize the workplace. Don't Ask Don't Tell, for political inclinations, at workplace.
I particularly liked your earlier statement: "Does Google believe in gender fluidity or do they believe in being cis-gendered? What if male engineers claim to be a female at the time of hiring, claiming gender fluidity, is Google going to get into business of keeping someone honest about what their gender is?"
To me, that wonderfully illustrates the absurdity of this debate in particular (and most public disagreements in today's day and age for that matter), because who are we to assume that google employees with penises are actually males? And performing a survey to determine how each employee identifies themselves gender wise would be incredibly disrespectful and intrusive, would it not? (And if someone disagrees that it is disrespectful to ask that question, who are you to say what is and is not disrespectful?)
Western society is going through an "adolescent" stage at the moment, and it's just going to take time (my guess is a few decades) to work through it, that's my take on it.
Absurdly biased statistics need to be 'proven' or they can be ignored? Remember when Yahoo had far more women than men in executive positions? That sure got slammed as discriminatory, instantly, without any demand for 'more proof'. Why, do we think? Why is the response so overwhelmingly in favor of men having jobs?
Demanding more proof (besides the decades of evidence of women fleeing workplaces because of stress; women getting paid less for the same job; women overlooked for promotion despite reviews etc) is just more excuse-making. To make us feel better about the situation; to make it ok to do nothing; to explain how we're really not the bad guy even though we're fine with half of us getting a raw deal.
That's how this feels, wheeling and dealing. Jockeying for power.
Show me the outrage over equal representation at the national cemetery.
Show me the outrage over equal representation in the lumber industry.
How about Alaska crab fishing jobs?
How about windmill installation and maintenance?
How about garbage pickup?
Someone has it and you don't. You want it and you will say whatever it takes to get it. It's just mere words. Sexist, misogynist, just air through mouth. Throw it and see if they give you something.
If liberal Google, people educated in best institutions we had to offer throughout the world, is sexist then humanity has no hope.
>Demanding more proof (besides the decades of evidence of women fleeing workplaces because of stress; women getting paid less for the same job; women overlooked for promotion despite reviews etc) is just more excuse-making.
You are not asking to fix any of this. You are asking for hiring bar to be lowered for women so that they make up 50% of the workforce. Those are two different things.
Show me a sexist and his sexist actions and I would gladly fight that person along with you. This collective shaming is as unjust as sexism, and more insulting.
Let's show door to that male college kid, because some bosses at Google had been sexist in their past hiring practices. The bosses, who enjoy full Google employment.
Why are you punishing the kid for crimes of the Google boss who is still gainfully employed?
This is where group think, collectivism, identity politics has gone wrong. This is why people have left the political left.
For example, you can widen the diversity of your applicant pool by reaching out to the groups you want to increase. If a company makes sure to have a booth at the major Society of Women Engineers job fairs, is that discrimination? Men are only being hurt in that there are more people applying for the same positions.
As another option, one could argue that there is a societal imbalance in the development of the talent pool, and attempt to correct that. If a company puts effort into encouraging women to go into engineering and, as an outcome, their pool of qualified applicants is more diverse, is that employment discrimination?
What I'm saying is that a company can put effort into expanding the diversity of their employee base in ways other than strict quotas and hiring discrimination, and without lowering the standard of the employees they hire. Is that really so bad?
That's how Caltech got from about 15% female undergraduates when I was there (early '80s) to 44% female nowadays.
They treated qualified high school girls the way schools with big highly rated athletics programs treat star high school athletes. They would identify prospects, and then put a lot of effort into convincing them they wanted to come to Caltech.
For boys you only got more than lukewarm recruitment attention if you looked like you might be the next Arthur Rubin or Peter Shor.
The girls that did apply were judged using the same standards that were used for the boys, so they didn't have any advantage or disadvantage in actually getting admitted (except possibly in the case of ties...not sure how they handled those).
Shouldn't motivation count? Shouldn't liking something, wanting something count? Would you do a good job if you don't like your job, think it was sold to you? Or, would you do a good job because you can't wait to go to job every morning?
Isn't what you say exactly what Damore's claim is? It's not like Caltech was rejecting women, but that women were not chasing education at Caltech. It was their decision, their choice to not go to Caltech. They were making choices on their own that had impact on how numbers at Caltech panned out. It's good to advertise to new potential candidates to join the college.
Has anyone spoken to women who joined Caltech only because of the hard sell that they did, later to drop out and do something else?
Why can't we trust women to make the decision about their career?
Amazon hired someone from car manufacturing to build the data centers. https://www.wired.com/2013/02/james-hamilton-amazon/ I can get behind that completely, it makes sense. Google wanting more of certain gender doesn't make sense to me.
There are a variety of reasons someone interested in a career in math, science, or engineering might not consider Caltech.
1. They might not have heard of it. Among top science institutions, Caltech is one of the smaller ones. It makes quite a few more than its proportional share of discoveries, but in total number quite a few others are in the news more.
Also, Caltech is generally only in the news for science and engineering. Some of the larger schools, such as Harvard, are also in the news for business, medicine, history, and other fields, which further raises awareness of them.
2. Caltech has a relatively small undergraduate class. It's about 1/5th the size of MIT, 1/30th the size of UC Berkeley, 1/7th the size of Stanford, 1/7th the size Harvard.
This means it is much less likely that they will know someone who is at Caltech or who went to Caltech. There might have been no prior students from their high school who went there, and so the guidance counsellors might not know much about it and recognize students who would be a great fit.
3. They might think they won't be able to handle the load. Caltech is either the hardest science school in the US, or it is #2 just behind MIT. This can easily scare away people who would actually do fine there.
Thank you for taking time to reply in detail.
Nobody would object to a company seeking candidates by turning over every rock out there. More power to you. The objection is using gender as a criteria in hiring decisions.
>one could argue that there is a societal imbalance in the development of the talent pool, and attempt to correct that.
But, it doesn't. It actually incentivizes keeping the imbalance because it guarantees advantage in outcome based on that imbalance in development of the talent pool.
One shouldn't "attempt" something that affects lives in this significant way. You better be 100% sure about it. If there is doubt then fall back to individuality, not "group" think.
>What I'm saying is that a company can put effort into expanding the diversity of their employee base in ways other than strict quotas and hiring discrimination, and without lowering the standard of the employees they hire. Is that really so bad?
You haven't given an example of "expanding diversity" without "quotas". When you say you want to "expand", by definition you are not happy with existing representations and want to change it to another higher % point. That higher % is what I call quota.
Let's imagine 70/30 split between women and men at Google. You would like it to be 50/50. You would like it to be 50/50 in five years. That means hiring has to be lopsided for next five years, may be 10/90 in favor of women to get to 50/50 in 5 years. Don't you think it is discriminatory to the male engineering students who are graduating in next 5 years? Should Google fire existing male employees to keep it fair to the students who are graduating in next 5 years?
I don't believe that's why James Damore was fired. He was fired for a much more obvious reason: he was working against their efforts to have a more gender diverse workforce and he embarrassed the company in a very public way.
"First, let me say that we strongly support the right of Googlers to express themselves, and much of what was in that memo is fair to debate, regardless of whether a vast majority of Googlers disagree with it."[0]
Google admits that there are some things in the memo that are debatable, even though Google disagrees with Damore.
"It is contrary to our basic values and our Code of Conduct, which expects ‘each Googler to do their utmost to create a workplace culture that is free of harassment, intimidation, bias and unlawful discrimination"[0]
And that is why he was fired: deliberately working against Google's workplace culture goals. There may be room to argue about what Damore may have meant, in his heart, when he wrote the memo. However, since the memo is a physical artifact that we may all inspect, it's clear that the text of the memo is unabashedly sexist. He clearly states that he believes the gender gap at Google is not caused by sexism and that's at clear odds with Google's goals.
"We need to stop assuming that gender gaps imply sexism."[1]
As if it needs to be said, that is clearly not the case. The primary cause of the gender gap is very much sexism and it's a real problem that needs to be dealt with. While we may disagree on which steps will be most effective, there's no benefit to denying the problem exists.
[0]: https://techcrunch.com/2017/08/07/google-fires-memo-author/
[1]: https://medium.com/@Cernovich/full-james-damore-memo-uncenso...