Re:What I believe II
by mistermann on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @03:05PM
(#15021304)
As you probably already know, where you are going wrong is due to that saying "you can't use logic to change the mind of someone who has arrived at a position by means other than logic". I think at it's core, this is just an old fashioned "us vs them" battle, so in that sense all the "rules" go out the door, not unlike a democratic election. Similar to how Donald Trump won the election based on emotions and story telling rather than facts, this argument will be won on emotions and story telling, not facts.
I particularly liked your earlier statement: "Does Google believe in gender fluidity or do they believe in being cis-gendered? What if male engineers claim to be a female at the time of hiring, claiming gender fluidity, is Google going to get into business of keeping someone honest about what their gender is?"
To me, that wonderfully illustrates the absurdity of this debate in particular (and most public disagreements in today's day and age for that matter), because who are we to assume that google employees with penises are actually males? And performing a survey to determine how each employee identifies themselves gender wise would be incredibly disrespectful and intrusive, would it not? (And if someone disagrees that it is disrespectful to ask that question, who are you to say what is and is not disrespectful?)
Western society is going through an "adolescent" stage at the moment, and it's just going to take time (my guess is a few decades) to work through it, that's my take on it.
I particularly liked your earlier statement: "Does Google believe in gender fluidity or do they believe in being cis-gendered? What if male engineers claim to be a female at the time of hiring, claiming gender fluidity, is Google going to get into business of keeping someone honest about what their gender is?"
To me, that wonderfully illustrates the absurdity of this debate in particular (and most public disagreements in today's day and age for that matter), because who are we to assume that google employees with penises are actually males? And performing a survey to determine how each employee identifies themselves gender wise would be incredibly disrespectful and intrusive, would it not? (And if someone disagrees that it is disrespectful to ask that question, who are you to say what is and is not disrespectful?)
Western society is going through an "adolescent" stage at the moment, and it's just going to take time (my guess is a few decades) to work through it, that's my take on it.