News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by bunderbunder on Saturday August 12, 2017 @08:27PM (#15000837)
It seems to me like more of this fragmentation will make streaming less like cable.

I don't care much for Disney content. Now that Disney's leaving, that frees up Netflix resources to (hopefully) get more of the content that I want. Realistically I'm not fond of Netflix's offerings of late, so I don't have high hopes. It's like basic cable these days; very shallow coverage of a lot of different things, so my interest tends to evaporate quickly. But the more that more focused Netflix alternatives pop up, the more I can find things that do suit my interests.

In summary, yes, please do "ruin" streaming for the author. It'll make streaming all the better for me.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by Retric on Saturday August 12, 2017 @08:54PM (#15000922)
The problem is there is going to be a minimum monthly fee of around 10$ to keep the lights on. So, fragmentation just increases prices without any net benefit for the consumer.

The real killer IMO is most young adults just don't watch much TV in any form. If your watching ~10 hours a month then paying for more than one streaming service is just a waste. Don't forget it's the median viewer that's important not the average of 0, 1, 2, 3, 100.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by smelendez on Sunday August 13, 2017 @01:48AM (#15001702)
> The real killer IMO is most young adults just don't watch much TV in any form.

It's interesting, I'm 32 so on the upper end of millennial. We're supposed to be the multitasking, multiple screen generation.

But I'll visit older relatives, say 55+, and they'll have the TV on constantly and just talk over it. I find it so distracting and honestly stressful, like when you're on a conference call, your boss is Slacking you and your friend's texting about their fight with their SO last night.

My friends my age all say the same. For most "young adults," you're either silently watching TV, or you're doing something else.

My best guess is that TV has gotten louder and faster paced, but older viewers have hung on to their habits. I bet I could easily have a conversation during Cheers or '90s Law and Order, but not today's shows.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by epmaybe on Sunday August 13, 2017 @01:09PM (#15003766)
I'm a young adult and I watch way more TV than I'm comfortable divulging to my friends. Easily more than three hours a day on average.

At the same time, I'm usually not paying much attention as I'm either doing work or studying while it is on in the background

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by whoiskevin on Sunday August 13, 2017 @07:34AM (#15002506)
Humans can't multitask regardless of their generation
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by tertius on Sunday August 13, 2017 @08:07AM (#15002580)
He/she means, rapid task switching.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by wybiral on Saturday August 12, 2017 @09:04PM (#15000948)
Plus I don't want to manage subscriptions in a bunch of different places. For instance, on Amazon I can add/remove things like HBO and Showtime and have it all in one place.

As much as I like Twin Peaks, I'm not sure I would have signed up for Showtime to watch it weekly unless it were right there with the rest of my content.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by scarface74 on Saturday August 12, 2017 @09:18PM (#15000994)
Except for Sling, I manage all of my subscriptions through iTunes -- Netflix, Hulu, Starz (during the summer), CBS All Access, and PluralSight (yeah it's still video content). I can still use the subscriptions on any device, including my Rokus.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by wybiral on Saturday August 12, 2017 @09:29PM (#15001017)
Exactly. I'm not going to go to Disney or Showtime and subscribe on everyone's platform to watch the one or two shows I would watch. But if it's a reasonably priced addition to whatever streaming service I regularly use... I'm more likely to.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by bunderbunder on Sunday August 13, 2017 @08:49AM (#15002701)
As a consumer, I do feel I'm seeing a net benefit without any price increases - or at least a benefit commensurate with the price increase. I watch one alternative streaming service for a while, then, when another that interests me more comes along, I switch to that one and cancel the old one. So the amount of content available to me is "eventually better" at a price that's currently pretty stable.

You're right, though, part of this is that I don't watch much TV in any form. It's probably less than 2 hours a week. So it really doesn't make much sense for me to subscribe to more than one service at a time. Not that that means we've canceled the Netflix subscription, but it's becoming a perennial discussion topic around our house of late.

Let me turn it around, on you, though: What makes you think that having a really good library of streaming content available on a single service at Netflix's prices is even financially tenable? The last time Netflix had a really great selection was when their prime service was still renting DVDs, so I certainly don't think they've been able to demonstrate that it's possible. And if they can't, who can? As more of a long tail consumer, the One Streaming Service to Rule Them All future looks pretty bleak to me - cheap, sure, but also crappy. You get what you pay for.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by Retric on Sunday August 13, 2017 @12:56PM (#15003695)
My theory is it's just a question of getting the financials right. A streaming service that's passes along ~80% of it's revenue based on what individual people watch and some weighting so more recent content gets a higher multiple seems like the long term winner.

The idea is if someone watches 2 hours a month then whatever they watch gets high value. But, if someone watches 200 hours a month then everyone gets far less. And the net benifit is both niche content for picky viewers and bulk content for people that want background noise are both viable.

Right now there are similar calculations, but it's very indirect which makes fragmentation seem like a better deal for content creators.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by ghaff on Sunday August 13, 2017 @12:59PM (#15003710)
One likely future is more a la carte purchasing, whether to rent or own. We're well on the way to that with movies. No all-you-can-eat subscription service has even a mediocre selection. And, having effectively driven everyone else in the space out of business, Netflix' long tail DVD catalog is degrading as they apparently don't replace disks that are lost/damaged.

I agree with the broader point though. I don't watch a lot of TV which means there's a definite limit to how many subscription services I'll get. Maybe that means I don't watch a show here or there I might have been inclined to but that's OK.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by SubiculumCode on Saturday August 12, 2017 @11:15PM (#15001306)
The min price is about $10 because there isnt that much competition yet. I suspect if the author's fragmentation comes true, it will go down for single studi/channel offerings.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by emsy on Saturday August 12, 2017 @11:23PM (#15001324)
There won't be competition for exclusive content like Disney, AMC, HBO etc. except piracy which is still a lot easier for a lot of people, and if fragmentation continues, it will be Even more so.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by ImaCake on Sunday August 13, 2017 @12:32AM (#15001495)
I think piracy is the real competitor here. Unless they stop torrents they wont succeed here.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by dorfsmay on Sunday August 13, 2017 @04:44AM (#15002124)
Make it easier than piracy, done!

Today you cannot pay for a recent movie unless you go to a cinema (which I personally find an anachronism). To pay for older content, you need to find who is streaming it, pay a subscription with them, then find in what country they streaming it, pay for some fancy VPN service, setup the fancy VPN, restart your device and now watch it.

Or, you can pirate it and watch it!

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by tertius on Sunday August 13, 2017 @08:08AM (#15002586)
Piracy will always be easiest. Much like most unethical things.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by dingo_bat on Sunday August 13, 2017 @08:39AM (#15002666)
I think services like Spotify or Google play music are already much easier than pirating songs. Why do you think a similar state cannot be achieved for TV shows or movies?
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by tertius on Sunday August 13, 2017 @03:25PM (#15004462)
Unless you're in a country where the licensing disagrees. Or a label chooses not to sell a catalog to you.

Music does work a little differently. You pay per play, vs. TV you're paying for a catalog.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by pdpi on Sunday August 13, 2017 @11:44AM (#15003335)
Steam is a great counter-example. As is spotify.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by tertius on Sunday August 13, 2017 @03:27PM (#15004466)
Steam is a great example, licensing seems to be pretty universal most of the times allowing games in most countries. Music is a little harder and TV/movies are a lot harder.

The music business is much more on board than TV/Movies. But TV/Movies still have a lot of leverage.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by kyriakos on Sunday August 13, 2017 @01:08AM (#15001614)
Piracy will always be competition because of availability and not price. A lot of people who can afford to pay pirate cause the content they want is not available to them legally. Unless we somehow switch to a global content platform piracy is here to stay. And it's not just torrents, you can now pay for illegal services that behave like Netflix with polished UIs and get access to a larger catalog without geographical restrictions.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by SubiculumCode on Sunday August 13, 2017 @12:52PM (#15003667)
No there would not be competition for the same disney movie. But there is a lot of competing content out there that will lower prices.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by cwyers on Sunday August 13, 2017 @01:29AM (#15001668)
You don't need to have your own streaming service to charge for your stuff. Hulu, Amazon and VRV all have the ability to add packages to their basic offering.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by Animats on Sunday August 13, 2017 @01:39AM (#15001688)
It seems to me like more of this fragmentation will make streaming less like cable.

It looks like disintermediation, which is what the Internet was supposed to do. Direct from the studio to the consumer. But the reason probably comes from a bad deal.

One would think the NFL would run their own network. Major League Baseball does. But ESPN (owned by Disney) way overpaid for rights to show NFL games, for which viewership is declining. ESPN subscribers are down 13 million from the peak. They bought NFL rights near the top, so the NFL has a great deal for a few years. ESPN had to downsize substantially because of that mistake.[1]

On top of that, ESPN also apparently made a bad deal to broadcast NBA games. The phrase "sports rights bubble" is used.

This activity at Disney may be trying to dig out of the ESPN hole.

[1] https://www.outkickthecoverage.com/espn-cutting-nearly-100-m...

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by techsupporter on Sunday August 13, 2017 @03:40AM (#15001963)
> One would think the NFL would run their own network.

Doesn't the NFL have NFL Network, RedZone, and NFL Sunday Ticket?

I think Major League Baseball wound up on the better end of the deal because they decided to not try to chase the dollars that the National Football League was racking up. They realized early on that they have (actual) thousands of events so if they go for the margin instead of the lump sum, awesome. It's why, even with the absurd blackout rules, MLB games are the most widely available...it doesn't pay for it to be any other way.

Now that Bud Selig is gone, I really think MLB is finally going to crack the in-market-but-not-on-cable streaming niche. The signs have been there for a couple of years, what with "follow a single team" MLB.tv packages and "watch your team anywhere, with a cable subscription." Several teams now allow buying in-market streaming through the team's web site...it just takes the willingness to do it and I think MLB Advanced Media is twisting some arms.

It wouldn't shock me to see several teams with owned regional sports networks, like the Mariners (Root Sports Northwest), Orioles (MASN), or Red Sox (NESN), come out and allow purchasing standalone access to their channels next season. The money is there for the taking...

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by jpindar on Sunday August 13, 2017 @02:44PM (#15004263)
I believe the parent was talking about the NFL selling its content directly to viewers* which they refuse to do despite fans begging them to PLEASE TAKE OUR MONEY!

*In the US. NFL games are more easily available outside of the US than in.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by ajmurmann on Saturday August 12, 2017 @08:35PM (#15000870)
Couldn't agree more. I'd like to see this go even further and have nothing bundled. I much rather pay straight up for the shows I'm watching than get some bundle. Many shows are about $20 on Amazon or Play which is totally reasonable; you end up owning it and only pay for what you want. That's the model I like best. Unlikely to get everyone on that boat though.

EDIT: typos

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by LeoPanthera on Saturday August 12, 2017 @08:50PM (#15000910)
Can you download the video files for the shows you buy, DRM-free?

If not, you don't "own" them at all.

The encryption on DVD and blu-ray discs is easily broken, so that's still a reasonable way to "own" your favorite shows. As far as I know, 4K blu-ray hasn't been cracked yet, so avoid those.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by rdtsc on Saturday August 12, 2017 @11:42PM (#15001359)
I've heard it here on HN that some buy the show then just pirate it when they watch it. Just because pirated content has a uniform interface, and a better overall user experience.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by CaptSpify on Sunday August 13, 2017 @12:38AM (#15001517)
I hear that too, and I mostly agree with doing it, but I kind of feel it's a problem: It tells amazon "Oh, sure, your system is fine, I don't mind paying for DRM!" when in reality we shouldn't encourage DRM.

I wish I could go to the studio/artist/creator directly and say "Hey, I would like to pirate your content, here's some money", but outside of Patreon or the like, there's usually not an option to do that.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by dageshi on Sunday August 13, 2017 @11:26AM (#15003267)
I've no doubt if amazon could just sell the raw file they would. It's rights holders who demand DRM and if amazon refuses itunes or someone else will happily step in and provide it.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by jpindar on Sunday August 13, 2017 @02:46PM (#15004277)
And in fact Amazon does sell music like that, as downloadable mp3s.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by kyriakos on Sunday August 13, 2017 @01:10AM (#15001621)
I actually do that, I have legal access to Game of Thrones on cable but I still pirate it cause I want to watch it on the go on my laptop.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by seanp2k2 on Sunday August 13, 2017 @03:46AM (#15001989)
Putting the GO in HBO GO. Their naming scheme between HBO NOW and GO is also awful, and they even have separate apps.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by kyriakos on Sunday August 13, 2017 @07:12AM (#15002450)
I am not living in the US so not even HBO Go is an option for me
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by askvictor on Sunday August 13, 2017 @04:31AM (#15002093)
Mostly I'm only going to watch it once, so I'm happy with a rental model; cheaper as well. And not to different to a streaming approach, but only choosing and paying for what you actually want.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by hamandcheese on Saturday August 12, 2017 @08:47PM (#15000902)
Hasn't that model existed for a while now?
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by ajmurmann on Saturday August 12, 2017 @09:28PM (#15001013)
Yes, but lots of content cannot be accessed that way. Especially not live sports events.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by ekianjo on Saturday August 12, 2017 @09:29PM (#15001014)
you never own anything you buy online these days. its only a license to watch stuff that can be taken from you at any time.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by candiodari on Saturday August 12, 2017 @11:44PM (#15001365)
... but so far no event has made that really clear to the masses. That's coming, of course.

Although I must say I have an Apple account and made the mistake of switching countries (dialog box on iPad). Half the shows disappeared. No refund, no way to get them back.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by ekianjo on Saturday August 12, 2017 @11:50PM (#15001385)
Well there was Amazon removing some books once from Kindle accounts, and I think there were already several cases on Steam where a couple of games stopped being available as well. There is no reason why this kind of behavior would end anytime soon, and not spread further. After all, all the EULAs make it very clear the user has no rights at all when it comes to what they purchased. I'd really like stores to remove the term "buy" and replace it by "buy a license" to make it very clear that you never own anything. And on top of that, you can never resell what you buy, so it's definitely NOT ownership in any way.
Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by libeclipse on Sunday August 13, 2017 @12:06PM (#15003420)
Pfft, allow that.

I don't want to subscribe to 20 different streaming services because what I want is scattered across them.

This is why piracy is so rampant: god damned convenience.

Re:Don’t ruin streaming by turning it into cable by ngold on Sunday August 13, 2017 @03:53AM (#15002003)
If you remember the days when cable first came out it was a mess as well. Every company like MGM with Epix is dumping their library behind a paywall waiting for the great consolidation to come and buy licenses to all the libraries or just buy the library outright.