News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by 43224gg252 on Thursday August 03, 2017 @05:02PM (#14923860)
Of course they did. Anyone on the internet about a year - 2 years ago remembers every time you mentioned monsanto they would send shills in to defend them and call you a tin-foil hat conspiracy theorist.
Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by themgt on Thursday August 03, 2017 @05:27PM (#14924053)
It's been really frustrating trying to have any nuanced stance on GMOs with proponents doing the "durr all modern crops are genetically modified by human selection" and such. Like no shit, it is still possible to acknowledge that and believe that there are legitimate concerns about intellectual property, or with modifying a crop to be resistant to a carcinogenic poison farmers are going to dump all over it.

A lot of the pro-GMO people seem to argue in really bad faith if they're not paid shills.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by bllguo on Thursday August 03, 2017 @05:40PM (#14924147)
I'd probably blame the fanatic GMO opponents first, who can typically be refuted by the simple arguments you mock.

Unfortunately nuance and middle ground are hard to come by online. And it doesn't help when you dismiss all GMO proponents as paid shills.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by Laforet on Thursday August 03, 2017 @06:49PM (#14924683)
The organic food industry is just as, if not more guilty of astroturfing, but in any case it's impossible to have a nuanced conversation with those whose level of argument never goes beyond "baa baa monsanto evil GM poison" It's quite telling that most of them have never even heard about Sygenta.

>modifying a crop to be resistant to a carcinogenic poison farmers are going to dump all over it

This is purely speculation at this point. I recognise the ecological harms of massive monoculture enabled by GM but again, opponents seems fixated on unproven health effects and miss the bigger picture.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by batiste on Wednesday August 09, 2017 @06:45AM (#14967276)
> the ecological harms of massive monoculture enabled by GM

What is "monoculture" and why is it GM that enabled it? Didn't monoculture exist before GM? Could you describe to me a field where non-monoculture is used.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by vbuwivbiu on Thursday August 03, 2017 @06:32PM (#14924569)
Exactly this. Every thread on GM quickly polarizes into useless for and against sides, when we need to be selective about it.

And I've never bought the characterization of breeding/selection as a form of GM. Breeding is selection of a pathetically tiny set of modifications, but GM is on a whole other level. With GM we can write arbitrary binary strings of code into any organism. That's simply not comparable with breeding -- the space of realizable phenotypes is orders of magnitude larger with GM.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by Laforet on Thursday August 03, 2017 @07:02PM (#14924777)
Modern breeding involves actively mutating known species with DNA-altering chemical mutagen and ionising radiation. Think fuzzing vs. static code analysis, which one would you do first when it comes to debugging?

>Breeding is selection of a pathetically tiny set of modifications, but GM is on a whole other level.

The truth is probably closer to the opposite of this: most GM species in the pipeline are rather unimaginative ones improving one phenotype at a time, and the vast majority of them focus on pest or herbicide resistance. There is a couple of near commercial crops aimed at improving nutritional content such as golden rice and high-lysine corn, but they are more exceptions than the rule.

The kind of totally disruptive GM e.g. introduce C3 photosynthesis in C4 plants, has not left the drawing board yet for a good reason.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by vbuwivbiu on Friday August 04, 2017 @04:34AM (#14927237)
Your argument is that GM is less powerful than breeding because people have been "unimaginative" with it ?

OK if you wanted to create, say, a fluorescent horse, which technique would you use:

* GM

* breeding with radiation and chemical mutagens

You have one month.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by Laforet on Friday August 04, 2017 @05:55AM (#14927492)
Neither technique will work in the timeframe you specified because gestation time for horses are almost a year long.

On the other hand, one can slowly breed for desirable traits such as speed, endurance or disease resistance in horses, good luck doing that with GM.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by vbuwivbiu on Friday August 04, 2017 @06:40AM (#14927675)
The point wasn't how long it would take for the organism to gestate, it was how long it would take for the trait to be introduced into the organism.

We can do that precisely for fluorescence and many other traits with GM today, but good luck trying to breed a fluorescent horse, it could take millions of years if at all.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by Laforet on Friday August 04, 2017 @07:49AM (#14927975)
There is no reliable or efficient vector to introduce fluoresence to somatic cells in a horse-sized animal, so no, 1 month is still way too short. You seem to have a highly romanticised idea about the capability of GM but it is misguided.

Besides, GFP fluoresence is the proverbial low hanging fruit as it is robustly expressed in many cell types but has very little practical value. Inserting useful traits via GM is often no short cut because they are rarely determined by a single gene.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by vbuwivbiu on Friday August 04, 2017 @10:30AM (#14928901)
the point isn't about actually growing an adult fluorescent horse, it's about proving the principle in an embryo - which takes days. It's already been done with mice, but I agree it's a simple example.

Your point about multiple genes is a very good one but we have a good understanding of how some gene networks work already and the rest will follow.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by Laforet on Friday August 04, 2017 @11:09AM (#14929229)
The problem with embyros is that they can be inject with any DNA for a trasient positive result but these may well be discarded or inactivated during development. The recently debuked STAP cells used injected embyros as evidence and it turned out to be either a fluke or outright fraud. To prove the concept you really need a stable F1 generation to illustrate that the trait can be passed down in the germline.

I'd say that our ability to interact with the genome is still rather crude, else we'd have already cured cancer by now - we already have a pretty good understanding of the cellular biology of cancer but it only helps us so much.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by nixonpjoshua1 on Thursday August 03, 2017 @11:07PM (#14926036)
I agree that the polarization is useless. However what you said about selective breeding vs GM is just wrong. Selective breeding introduces numerous mutations, including ones often not even related to the desired traits. In contrast human directed genetic modification often changes a single gene, the state of the art in research universities for specific modifications is only in the tens of genes. You can only say they are not comparable in the sense that selective breeding introduces far more changes than GM and also in the sense that with GM we know what changed where in selective breeding we do not necessarily know how the change was produced or what the extent of it was.

Also I understand that this is a computer centered site but thinking of DNA as binary is a often used but terrible analogy. Living organisms were designed through complete randomness, try refactoring that. If you wanted to turn teosinte into corn without any random mutations and selection I think that would be far beyond our abilities for 100 years at least.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by vbuwivbiu on Friday August 04, 2017 @04:28AM (#14927222)
Sorry but I didn't compare evolution with computer programming - it's very different to human code, but it is code and it is a computation.

In evolution there's no design, which implies prediction and a model of function. But evolution is far from "completely random". In fact evolution goes to great lengths to correct mutations and only allows mutation in certain carefully controlled sequences of the genome where variation is potentially useful. There are sequences in our genomes that are identical to those of yeast, having been faithfully copied, and error-corrected, for billions of years.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by legulere on Friday August 04, 2017 @01:46AM (#14926600)
> In contrast human directed genetic modification often changes a single gene

Even CRISPR-CAS9 is not perfect and introduces a lot of unwanted genetic changes when used. Further the big advantage of GM compared with selective breeding is that you can inject Transgenes. This makes them totally incomparable.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by vbuwivbiu on Friday August 04, 2017 @05:02AM (#14927322)
give it a chance - it's early days, and there are many other techniques and more in the works
Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by colordrops on Thursday August 03, 2017 @07:26PM (#14924954)
yes, it's absurd that they bucket artificial selection and gene transfer into the same category.
Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by tstactplsignore on Thursday August 03, 2017 @11:34PM (#14926136)
Guess I and most of the people in my department are "those people"!

Isn't your comment self-defeating? You have legitimate concerns about corporate abuse of IP law and a specific crop product- not with the scientific field of genetic modification. So why do you insist on villifying the term GMO instead of using accurate language to describe what you're talking about? From the other perspective, I cannot begin to understand how you are the one not acting in bad faith.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by driverdan on Friday August 04, 2017 @12:22AM (#14926290)
It's been really frustrating trying to have any scientific stance on GMOs with opponents doing the "durr all GMOs are bad and are going to kill us" and such. Like no shit, it is still possible to acknowledge gaps in research and believe that there are legitimate concerns about intellectual property, or with not modifying a crop to increase its nutritional content to save starving people.

A lot of the anti-GMO people seem to argue in really bad faith if they're not paid shills.

See, I can create straw man arguments too.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by kfriede on Thursday August 03, 2017 @05:08PM (#14923898)
To be fair, I think a good portion of those 'shills' were organic (no pun intended). To this day, a lot of the popular "anti-monsanto", "anti-gmo" groups (e.g. David Avocado Wolfe) are pretty nutjob and have a large community of people who dislike them.
Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by wu-ikkyu on Thursday August 03, 2017 @05:40PM (#14924152)
>lot of the popular "anti-monsanto", "anti-gmo" groups (e.g. David Avocado Wolfe) are pretty nutjob

It's worth noting that having such groups is a commonly used counter intelligence tactic: create a loud and incoherent pseudo-strawman opposition to distract from those who are actually asking legitimate questions.

An effective astroturf campaign calls for both pro-x and anti-x shills.

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by imcoconut on Thursday August 03, 2017 @07:14PM (#14924874)
Wow, i never considered this but it makes sense and i imagine is very effective.

Do you know of any well documented cases of this (though by its nature, any case of this is probably not well documented)?

Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by wu-ikkyu on Thursday August 03, 2017 @09:20PM (#14925603)
Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by nerpderp83 on Thursday August 03, 2017 @06:11PM (#14924413)
If anyone was in a place to make a Strawman, it would be Monsanto.
Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by Laforet on Thursday August 03, 2017 @07:05PM (#14924802)
Sometime it feels like Monsanto is the strawman for the entire biotech industry.
Re:Monsanto leaks suggest it tried to ‘kill’ cancer research... by eip on Thursday August 03, 2017 @06:47PM (#14924671)
> create a loud and incoherent pseudo-strawman opposition to distract from those who are actually asking legitimate questions.

See flat earth as an obvious example of this.