Because it's a private organization making a free choice, a choice which you can ignore.
One of the value propositions of these lists is some sort of vetting, so it's their prerogative to drop stocks that don't meet their requirements.
I agree that a company like SNAP doesn't need to be in the S&P since it's pretty much a tech gamble. It's either gonna grow into a juggernaut or it's gonna fizzle. We'll find out soon enough.
The beauty of index funds is that they're so diverse if you had a SNAP in it that plummeted it'd barely impact your portfolio. This is the whole point of index fund diversification.
Okay. I wouldn't either. What does your comment have to do with what I wrote?
> That's not really traditional stock ownership at that point, as the corporation is no longer ultimately run by or held accountable to investors. It's something else.
I agree. Once again, your comment has nothing to do with what I wrote. Did you reply to the wrong comment by any chance?
I'm just pointing out why S&P index is important and why it is more than a list?
It's still just a list and the reason it exists is to indicate some level of vetting. That's the reason that it's used by those funds.
Being excluded from the list just means you don't meet certain requirements but it doesn't block anyone from purchasing your stock.
I admit I have very mixed feelings about these kind of structures. On the one hand it feels like cheating, on the other hand I totally get why this is necessary to protect the company. Still, it basically means that investors don't really own part of the company anymore; they just have a right to its dividends, but need blind trust in how the real owners of the company decide to run it. It enables more autocratically run companies without any accountability to shareholders, because those aren't real shares anymore.
The "free market reaction" is that if these capital structures suck, active investors don't buy them or short them, and the stock price goes down. That is, if shareholder control was actually valuable, it'd command enough of a premium to discourage SNAP's behavior.