Now if you want a system used by 0.01% of the global population then that's a very different problem, but far less useful.
PS: USD actually operate on a 3 tiered system that works well (Fed, Banks, cash) but doing the same thing in a *coin seems like just giving up.
https://medium.com/@jonaldfyookball/mathematical-proof-that-...
This is unsupported. LN is a research project, not a production-ready payment system. It has plenty of limitations (trustlessness is a huge limitation), and the topology of the network doesn’t match that of a real economy (routes to fellow consumers are practically useless, since everyone wants to pay merchants). There’s plenty of work left before LN can scale properly, if it ever manages to (again, trustlessness for both senders and receivers is setting the bar as high as it can possibly go).
Scalability is secondondary for LN, trustlessness is primary. Due to this choice I predict difficulty in scaling sufficiently.
Also, everything is done via two-way payment channels in LN, which means that you need to lock X BTC in a channel in order to send it, which becomes very capital intensive for nodes close to merchants who need to lock millions of dollars worth of bitcoins to cover merchants’ monthly turnover (this is in addition to the BTC locked up by other nodes who participate in the transfer but are not directly connected to merchants). If you want to send 0.1 BTC through 10 nodes, each of these 10 nodes must have locked up 0.1 BTC on the blockchain, and you’ll pay blockchain fees if just a single channel/node in your path doesn’t have at least as much as you need to send.
A proper payment network needs two different types of nodes: senders and receivers. Using a single type of node for both doesn’t make much sense, since merchants and consumers have completely different needs. Senders need to be able to send relatively small amounts relatively frequently (a consumer making a few purchases per day), while receivers (merchants) need to redeem relatively large amounts (e.g. one week’s worth of payments) relatively rarely for bitcoins (on the blockchain).
What have you found that is cheaper to proof-of-work that works on a global system?[1]
[1] "Nothing is Cheaper than Proof of Work" http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pow-cheapest/
Maybe there's a happy medium where trustworthiness of central authorities is appropriately distributed, but common operations are quicker and less wasteful.
Heck, everywhere you look there's a solution to the trust problem; it's fundamental to human interactions.
- There are courts. If you try to screw me, I can drag you into one. Nothing's perfect and there's probably a minimum amount I'd not bother Judge Judy for, but it's a solution a LOT of people rely on. And I can tack all sorts of things on to this like warranties and insurances.
- Brands. Look, we burn all this money on getting sports stars to pose for pictures. And there's reviews of our product in papers. If we did something stupid, you'd know. Again, it ain't perfect.
- Escrow. Don't trust me? Trust this guy.
What has been will be again,
what has been done will be done again;
there is nothing new under the sun.I’m working on this. It’s an implementation of a protocol called Stroem, which uses payment channels to transfer bitcoins from consumers to so-called issuers, who issue payments in exchange which consumers then send to merchants. Then merchants collect these off-chain payments from issuers, and redeem them into bitcoins on the blockchain when they wish.
This system compromises with the security of the payment receivers only (the merchants). Everything is trustlessness for the payment sender/consumer, while merchants need to trust issuers. But, if desired, the merchant-issuer trust can be reduced to almost nothing by the merchant redeeming very often (at the cost of higher fees).
And, importantly, the open nature of the protocol will ensure competition between issuers, since anyone can join the network.
Centralized authority isn't cheaper. It trades proof of work for violence or denial of liberty.
Correct or not, your point is orthogonal to the issue mentioned.
Cryptocurrency is backed entirely by free market incentives. You can fight the market if you want, but you will lose.
What do you mean by this, exactly? Bitcoin miners look more than willing to earn money on brute forcing hard problems.
The point of proof-of-work is that it shouldn’t matter what anyone thinks about it. It’s basically impossible to ban (anyone can do a SHA256 calculation), and the difficulty automatically adjusts. In addition to this, the block reward — currently 12.5 BTC per block — halves every ~4 years, so less and less electricity will be consumed until only transaction fees provide capital for proof-of-work[1].
[1] http://www.bitcoinnotbombs.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/37...
Furthermore, the miners are here for the direct mining rewards. I think the future transaction fees approach will be significantly less attractive, so I'll be very interested to see how that change plays out once the era of rewarded mining is over.
Visa, MasterCard, AmEX, &c along with each individual bank, not to mention the intermediaries and gateways all of them use also consume a tremendous amount of power. It's not as if our current system uses a negligible amount of power, not to mention the number of steps and entities a transaction needs in order to be finalized.
Our current system does in fact use a negligible amount of power. Each $2 latte you put on a credit card uses an amount of electricity so infinitesimal that it can only be measured in the aggregate.
The percentage of the power used to generate a single bitcoin block for a single transaction can power an average US household for (approximately) an entire week.
To put it in perspective: If the bitcoin network scaled up to the size of the VISA network it would require 100% of all energy used for all purposes planet-wide, from transportation, manufacturing, agriculture, etc. Everything you could possibly want to buy with bitcoin would be unavailable, as 100% of all human activity would go to powering the miners.
Bitcoin network scaling has to do with transactions per second, and it is a protocol problem, and an storage problem, but it is independent of the hash capacity of the system.
We can theoretically improve the Bitcoin network capacity to handle 100x the number of transactions, while having the same hash rate.
In fact, if hash rate were halved each month, and the protocol unchanged, Bitcoin network transaction capacity would still be the same after Bitcoin difficulty is auto adjusted.
Hash rate and transaction capacity are orthogonal issues.
Those costs specifically end up being reified in the fee those processors charge to their customers, so we can determine an upper limit to how much is spent on energy in that way.
We don't really know the relationship between transaction rate and electrical usage in a mature BTC system, because mining is mainly used to prevent double-spends and the minimum required mining rate to support a given transaction rate is a game-theoretical concern and not a technical one. We can only really observe what has happened so far in the Bitcoin ecosystem.
Otherwise there will be a point where it is cost effective to attack the network.
Bitcoin is designed to be wasteful.
"I'm working on these hashes. You know I'm not taking a shortcut, because there's not yet a known way to do that with this secure hash. And because you know I'm doing the work, you should reward me with some coins."
Alternatives have been considered, like proof-of-stake.
If you raise the block size to put more transactions into a single block, you will end up with a normal banking system because nobody can carry the whole blockchain with them to pay and has to trust providers that manage wallets.
The person I replied to compalined about "wasting" power to run the bitcoin network. It's only a valid comparison when compared against current usage, as our current system also "wastes" power to run the current system.
> PoW incentivizes miners to use as much power as possible because that is a necessary requirement for increasing hash output.
It also incentives them to get the most performance per Watt. I'm just saying it's meaningless to complain that bitcoin uses power, it only matters how it compares to the current system.
No, even if "the current system" was an apt comparison, there is still a fundamental difference between PoW and everything else. The power consumed in the process of facilitating a bank or any type of business is incidental to the useful work being performed. Power is burned so there are lights for people to see, power is burned so computers can perform calculations so that employees can get their jobs done faster, power is burned so that people can go back home after their shift is over; all this is incidental, the power is expended to make the business process more efficient, but the business could still run (though much less efficiently) without spending power on lights, computers and transportation. On the other hand, PoW is literally a waste of work because the nature of the work itself does not matter, the only thing that matters is that the unbounded cost of wasting energy keeps everyone honest.
> I'm just saying it's meaningless to complain that bitcoin uses power, it only matters how it compares to the current system.
The comparison is meaningless because "the current system" continues to exist regardless of any developments in bitcoin, if anything ubiquitous bitcoin would almost certainly increase the power impact of the finance industry.
But is it more or less than the equivalent amount of power it would take for Bitcoin (or something like it) to scale to Visa, MC, AMEX, etc. global levels?
That's a lot of energy going into a system that can commit a new block of transactions once every 10 minutes on average. It solves a problem in an interesting way, but it's nowhere near quick enough or efficient enough to solve 99% of engineering problems. That's why only 1% of engineers are working on it.