I disagree with this conception of the problem. As the other downvoted comment links the general consensus is that minimum wage hikes of small/medium magnitude are going to have zero/small effect on employment numbers. People like Card/Krueger because there's a lot of good reasoning in it and it's one of the earliest really good studies that showed the effect it did. But they quote it because the effect that it shows agrees with our scientific consensus. This UW study not only goes against consensus but also to an extreme degree:
The UW report nonetheless finds an unprecedented impact of wage increases on jobs, ten times higher than the average in 942 published minimum wage and non-minimum wage estimates, and triple that of minimum wage critic David Neumark. [0]
The UW study also tries to sell it itself (or has been accepted by laymen) as a more definitive study because it doesn't limit itself to one industry. And while it's true that it's pursuing a larger scope the sampling problems in their methodology have made it almost useless. If you refer back to the pdf in the previous citation and you can read about them. So I think people's skepticism about this study is actually pretty well placed.
[0] http://irle.berkeley.edu/files/2017/Reich-letter-to-Robert-F...
The tl;dr from that section is nicely concise:
> The most comprehensive summary that can be made about the minimum wage literature is that while the evidence is sometimes contradictory, small minimum wage increases seem to either have no employment effects or at least quite small employment effects in the short run. Estimates of long-run impacts, or the impact of large minimum wage increases are presently unknown.
Seattle is notable because it was (I believe) the largest MW increase in US history. The research has broadly agreed that with large changes, we don't have evidence predicting what'll happen, which is why this study is of such critical political importance to both sides - if it shows that the MW is a net gain, then the MW proponents get to say "see? no large changes, $15 MW nationwide now!". If it shows a net loss, the MW opponents get to say "see? You can't go past the inflection point without moving backwards, put the brakes on this push".
Card/Kreuger was notable because it was the first robust result that contradicted the consensus at the time. The paper contributed substantially to our understanding of labor economics, and it would have been a major mistake to discount it because it conflicted with the widely-held beliefs at the time. To dismiss the UW study because it contradicts some contemporary research would be just as much a mistake.
So, minimum wage increases, worker's comp changes, tax increases, etc. today may indeed spur job losses where that may not have been true before. We are in a brave new world.
Further, if you say that old studies aren't reliable because it's a brave new world, the predictions you make due to some numbers are also unreliable.
My only "prediction" is that, as has been the case since the beginning of recorded history, business owners will always try to reduce their expenses as much as possible, and that capabilities of technology will continue to increase as time goes on. I'd say those are fairly safe assumptions. With those basic and reasonable assumptions in place, minimum wage increases today will cost minimum wage jobs.
I don't need to say that, fewer jobs being lost should have still have had an impact and those studies didn't find one. There are other periods in history where the leaps forward did have something like this level of impact, and jobs didn't disappear then either.
>With those basic and reasonable assumptions in place, minimum wage increases today will cost minimum wage jobs.
Your reasonable assumptions include this same process happening throughout history. It has had the same result throughout history, yet you're predicting that this result will somehow change.
There are certainly people in any economy whose labor is not worth the total cost to an employer, for any given price. For an obvious extreme, consider a minimum wage of $1000/hour: this would not magically make everyone rich; instead, it would create a giant black market for labor. Intuition says that $1000/hr is obviously the wrong number. But what really is the justification for saying that $5 or $10 or $15 per hour is the right number? If the goal of such a policy is to help the lower class earn more, then minimum wage seems like a very indirect and blunt instrument by which to effect it.
So minimum wages do create pressure to stay productive enough to keep employed, which is entirely intensional.
Think about it: it's not just the work, it's the quality of the housing and the food, and everything else. Sure, someone could "work" for $1/hour but they could never live on that in a rich country. There is a bottom on labor productivity below which labor is not viable for the minimum standard of living for the country.
Pushing up the min wage forces productivity improvements as well as standard of living increases. Otherwise, we would have something like India, supporting a wider variety of living standards; I.e. We wouldn't be a developed country anymore.
Below that level of employability, social services are supposed to take over, but this being America....
The evidence in this study shows precisely the opposite.
And some of us just use math. If a company is barely profitable already, being required to pay more for labor probably won't work too well.
This is especially true of manual jobs that could be outsourced or automated for only slightly more than employees are currently paid.
This is a great point. McDonald's and Walmart could paradoxically become more profitable after a minimum wage increase. How? By closing their least profitable stores. Perhaps those stores were just barely making a profit and the increase pushed them into the red. By closing these stores they increase their profitability despite recording a decrease in profit.
Even in non-franchised businesses, if the cost of a location exceeds its revenue, then that location is no longer profitable, and therefore could very well be shut down or at the very least downsized.
Either way, people lose their jobs.
You seem very concerned about these low wage workers. That's quite admirable of you.
I'm well aware of the microeconomics argument. It is basically ceteris paribus except that all things aren't equal. You're leaving out a lot of the beneficial aspects of a MW such as more money spent by the wage earners. You're also ignoring a tremendous amount of empirical experience with MWs around the world.
In particular, Red States with low MWs, basically at the Federal minimum, aren't economic miracles.
------
Every minimum wage increase is different!
Even the staunchest free market economist wouldn't claim that a hypothetical minimum wage increase from $.10/hr to $.50/hr in Seattle would increase unemployment. And even the staunchest socialist economist would not claim that a minimum wage increase from $8/hr to $800/hr wouldn't increase unemployment.
Similarly, how can you compare an increase from $5-6 in New jersey in 2005 to one from $11 to $13 in Seattle in 2017? You can't just make blanket statements about this stuff.
The question is not "Are minimum wage increases good in general?" the question is "Given the potential tradeoffs, is this specific minimum wage increase good?"
That still isn't the right question because it's a false dichotomy.
At any interesting wage, a minimum wage increase will increase unemployment. An increase from $.10/hr to $.50/hr does nothing because approximately zero people make less than $.50/hr to begin with. Once you get into wages that people are actually paid, with high probability there will be some jobs that can't be justified at a higher wage.
Imposing a minimum wage is taking from the people at the very bottom (who become unemployed) in order to give to the people at the almost-but-not-quite bottom. Which is why the whole exercise is folly.
It doesn't matter whether the higher wages outweigh the increase in unemployment in any particular scenario because there is a third option -- increase income without imposing the entire cost on employers who hire people at the bottom.
The simplest way to do that is a UBI. The UBI supplements everyone's wages, which brings up the lowest paid workers to the minimum, and is paid for from general taxes, which minimizes the economic damage by spreading out the burden (and having the rich pay their proportionate share).
This is not obvious. Increasing the income of the almost-bottom could act as a stimulus which drives down unemployment. It is possible that this effect is greater than the unemployment caused by the minimum wage directly.
Having said that, I agree that the UBI is a generally better way of accomplishing this.
You're essentially arguing the butterfly effect. It could also be the exact opposite, if the employees use the money to pay down debts when the employers would have spent it on new consumption. Or various completely arbitrary outcomes that are always possible whenever making any change to a complex system.
But the real flaw in the stimulus theory is that it assumes the conclusion. If the net loss from people losing their jobs to begin with is more than the net wage gain to the people who kept their jobs to begin with then there is no extra money to create a stimulus to recover from that situation. If it isn't then you didn't need the stimulus effect to come out ahead regardless. (Though you're still even better off with a UBI.)
If a company pays 65% of their employees the minimum and wages go up 5% the company doesn't fire most of its workers it grudgingly pays more.
In a lot of cases the existing low wage is actually below market now and subsidized by benefits like food stamps.
It depends on what the company's alternatives are. Many companies have only 5% margins to begin with. And most people who suggest minimum wage increases argue for more than just 5%.
> In a lot of cases the existing low wage is actually below market now and subsidized by benefits like food stamps.
That is one of the problems a UBI fixes. Since the money isn't contingent on employment, employers can't pay less against the leverage that without a job the employee would lose their food assistance.
But it doesn't always hold in small markets or markets with little variety. Consider towns where there are only a few important employers.
I still agree that imposing the costs on the employers is arbitrary.
Obviously the question then becomes how much the UBI should be, but at least it gets us away from the folly of a minimum wage.
After a 1 minute google, bam, figure 1, a cluster at 0.[0]
[0] http://cepr.net/documents/publications/min-wage-2013-02.pdf
Bear in mind there is a matter of degree.
> The weight of that evidence points to little or no employment response to modest increases in the minimum wage.
What will define "modest"?
In argentina, minimum wage is almost median real income. 40% of workers work under the table. Id be extremely surprised that lower minimum wage wouldn't increase formal employment tremendously.
I'm of the opinion that far too many people on both sides of the issue argue their positions from ideology rather than empiricism, to our collective detriment.
The headline is right - one alarming study isn't the final word, nor should it be. But we seem to be rather quick to let one study confirming our biases to be "the final word" when it confirms our priors, and rather quick to dismiss it as "just one study" when it contradicts them. Neither position is intellectually honest, and if we truly want to help the most vulnerable, we have to do it in ways that are backed by the evidence.