...or in case of tablets that come in 2x/4x the dose and you need to cut them in half/four pieces, the precision of your cut and amount of tablet dust that is lost.
It's a lot of guess work.
For many drugs a 2% difference is probably unnoticeable. Why are Ibuprofen pills 200mg? Because it's a nice round number that happens to work for many people. If I have a headache I often break the 200mg pill and only take half of it. It still does the job fine for me with fewer side effects.
So if a 110lb wife gets the same dosage as a 200lb husband, how on earth would even a 20% difference in dosage amount make a big difference?
2% can only be done in fantasyland, like in a hospital you and the medicine are both closely weighed and administered.
How do you know that your doctor didn't take your weight into consideration when selecting the dose for a prescription medicine?
OTC drugs are often generally provided at a dose that should be safe for most adults, but may be significantly different in effectiveness based on weight.
Why is this a "surely"? On a scale of 100%, 2% is 2% because it's not hugely significant.
Disclaimer: this is conjecture.