News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by Kenji on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:31PM (#14779084)
> We can all be members of the intellectual elite, and then, only then, will a phrase "America's right to know" and, indeed, any true concept of democracy, have any meaning

Come on. We cannot all be members of the intellectual elite. And I'm not being facetious because of a few mentally disabled people. Half the population has an IQ below 100. Let that sink in for a moment. There are (more or less) innate IQ differences and some people excel at intellectual tasks while others do not and actually cannot as a matter of the body they possess. Just ask any school teacher: There are bright kids who get things easily and quickly get ahead and others who cannot progress even if they put in all the hard work and hours they can.

This entire piece seems like Asimov is salty because not everyone is an intellectual. Well, too bad, there are people who enjoy a simple life without the sorrows that come with being an intellectual.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by bostik on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:37PM (#14779436)
> Half the population has an IQ below 100

I'm going to quote a junior high school mate, because what he said nearly 25 years ago still rings true. For background: Finland has mandatory conscription military service. Every year you get an honest cross-cut of the entire population.

The sentence you used highlights a real fact, but it leaves it without context. What I'm going to say next is guaranteed to be both insensitive and politically incorrect, but I believe it has to be said.

As my mate said: If you think about the "average" person, with an IQ of 100, you should also realise just how dumb that person appears to you. Sit down and take a deep breath. Half the population is, by definition, dumber than that.

While in the military service, I learned this the hard way. I saw enough people who had trouble tying their showlaces, let alone the ability to hold a constructive argument. And like everyboby else in the military, everyone of them was given an assault rifle and live ammunition within 96 hours of starting their service. That gives a whole new meaning to fear.

The only thing separating some these individuals from Gomer Pyle[0] was the lack of psychosis. (When I became a medic, I met those too. We had to provide them with hard prescription drugs to keep them subdued and maintain a suicide watch to make sure they could be escorted safely out the next day.)

I can say with honesty that the military service recalibrated my view of humanity. And it's not pretty.

0: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0093058/

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by noobermin on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:56PM (#14779537)
I get it, military service is a particularly exceptional service because of the sampling is wide and all that, but it's not like anyone over the age of 20 hasn't met all sorts of people in general. Also, I get what you're saying, but every time I hear these sorts of things, alarm sirens in my head off and a refrain "confirmation bias" is blasted on repeat.

The whole "half of people dumber than the median" doesn't really bother me as much as it does other people, especially since IQ often isn't what I care about when evaluating a person.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by zo1 on Saturday July 15, 2017 @08:49PM (#14779903)
>"The whole "half of people dumber than the median" doesn't really bother me as much as it does other people, especially since IQ often isn't what I care about when evaluating a person."

It should, because criminal behavior is correlated with IQ:

http://law.jrank.org/pages/1365/Intelligence-Crime-Explainin...

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by ZeroGravitas on Saturday July 15, 2017 @09:41PM (#14780063)
That might be due to some some high IQ folk deciding it was more profitable for them to delay removing lead from paint and gasoline.

The brain damage they caused with lead not only lowers IQ but increases compulsiveness and correlates with crime when the exposed child reaches the peak years for criminal behaviour.

The question then arises whether the criminality is the fault of the poisoner or the poisoned.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by copperx on Saturday July 15, 2017 @07:17PM (#14779644)
> IQ often isn't what I care about when evaluating a person

It does become important if you're hiring, looking for a friend or romantic partner, or if you're going to be under that person's authority.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by Turing_Machine on Saturday July 15, 2017 @10:27PM (#14780176)
So you'd prefer Ted Bundy or Ted Kaczynski as a romantic partner? :-)

While it may be important to you to have an intellectual match as a romantic partner, there are many other factors involved for most people. Empathy is very important to many, along with, yes, physical attractiveness and financial security.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by projektir on Saturday July 15, 2017 @08:02PM (#14779777)
You don't ask your dates to take an IQ test, do you?
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by kleer001 on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:48PM (#14779187)
Why the down votes? It's correct. There's tons of dumb people. We can't all be elite. That's not how variation in a species works. Intelligence leans heavily on biology so it's got to be varied. Not everyone wins the lottery. Right?

Asimov was from New York, he's f-n salty. He'd probably quickly admit it then laugh and compose a limerick about it and slap you on the ass.

Also we need dumb people. We need people happy to swim in the shallow end of the pool of ideas. And we need to help them, take care of them, love them like any human. Give them opportunities to do important work. We certainly shouldn't let them have governmental or military powers.

Now, we can shift the average intelligence to the right by a standard deviation, but that requires some real gumption. And only a rare group of people is that brave.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by paulpauper on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:15PM (#14779309)
It's all relative. If everyone had an IQ of 150, the elites would be those with IQs of 180
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by noobermin on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:59PM (#14779553)
And IQ is renormalized as the population becomes more and more educated and society in general progresses. Every time people bring out their complaints like this, I often feel like people don't have a sense of their place and society's place in time, especially compared to the past.
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by vinceguidry on Saturday July 15, 2017 @07:02PM (#14779568)
You're assuming that IQ is what makes people elite.
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by kleer001 on Saturday July 15, 2017 @09:13PM (#14779992)
"Intellectual elite", pay attention boy! Pedantry is only for school.
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by booleandilemma on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:37PM (#14779429)
It takes all kinds to make a world.
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by lossolo on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:00PM (#14779238)
You know that you could be perceived as dumb to a lot smarter people than you, right?

"But don't worry, "we need dumb people" too. You will get help, we will take care of you and love you like any human. Give you opportunities to do important work. But know one thing, we certainly shouldn't let you have governmental or military powers, you are just too dumb for it."

That kind of reasoning is dangerous. Dictatorships are built on "I am smarter than those people, they are just dumb. I know better what's good for them than they do. They can't be allowed to make any decisions, direct or indirect (through voting)".

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by wildmusings on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:16PM (#14779312)
I don't think you're being fair to the person you're replying to. We should want to be led by people more intelligent than most. And not just more intelligent, but more honest, honorable, and courageous than most. That shouldn't be controversial.

I don't agree with the OP's paternalism, but I do think that men need to be led to achieve the greatest that each is individually capable of. And to be a great leader requires one to be extraordinary. There is not a Napolean or Alexander sleeping inside each of us. And that's just fine. We are nonetheless equal before God, or for secular ears: equal in dignity and moral worth.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by lossolo on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:47PM (#14779500)
> but I do think that men need to be led to achieve the greatest that each is individually capable of. And to be a great leader requires one to be extraordinary. There is not a Napolean or Alexander sleeping inside each of us. And that's just fine. We are nonetheless equal before God, or for secular ears: equal in dignity and moral worth.

I fully agree but this doesn't make what I wrote less true.

> We should want to be led by people more intelligent than most. And not just more intelligent, but more honest, honorable, and courageous than most. That shouldn't be controversial.

I don't deny that. But we (most of western civilization) live in democracy, Sarah Palin is democratically elected official and by many she is not seen as the brightest person. Donald Trump is the most powerful man in the world, is he "not just more intelligent, but more honest, honorable, and courageous than most." ? In my opinion he is not, but I didn't vote for him, I am not even an us citizen, but this was people choice.

Writing that we should not allow someone to be part of government because we perceive them as dumb ourselves is dangerous, let the people decide, say your opinion in that matter, show candidate faults, but let the people decide.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by wildmusings on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:55PM (#14779534)
>Writing that we should not allow someone to be part of government because we perceive them as dumb ourselves is dangerous, let the people decide, say your opinion in that matter, show candidate faults, but let the people decide.

I don't think I follow. You, I, and everyone else in this conversation are part of "the public" as much as the next guy.

And insofar as our political system forces us to vote for less than ideal people in order to advance or protect important principles--and I think lots of people of all political persuasions felt like this in 2016--it is unfortunate.

For Trump in particular, you may argue that he lacks in intelligence, and I would disagree but see where you're coming from, but he certainly has plenty of courage. That's what Republican primary voters saw in him.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by lossolo on Saturday July 15, 2017 @07:20PM (#14779661)
> You, I, and everyone else in this conversation are part of "the public" as much as the next guy.

I don't really know how should I interpret what you wrote in context of my answer, can you elaborate what you mean by that? Especially how you think this connects to what I wrote? Because analogy to this would be saying that sun shines while discussing about weather without more context. Which doesn't bring anything new to this discussion.

> And insofar as our political system forces us to vote for less than ideal people in order to advance or protect important principles--and I think lots of people of all political persuasions felt like this in 2016--it is unfortunate.

We could say that "If only people were more knowledgeable, they’d have better politics." Everyone has a different view of “better politics,” but this is a fairly common sentiment. If dumb people vote for dumb people it's not their fault, it's our fault, elites, because we didn't convince them not to, we knew better didn't we? After all they are just dumb people, what do they know? Is that what you are arguing?

So what did you do to stop dumb people from voting on other dumb people? What did OP do? It's our responsibility.

Ask yourself why people voted for Trump and not those smart, liberal elites? They voted for them before, what changed? Those are all important questions. Political perturbations across western world in last year had their reasons. Why suddenly everyone on world economic forum in Davos say that costs from globalization are higher than benefits for western world? That they have political and social costs. Why most "free trade" advocates suddenly say that they were maybe wrong ? Why Larry Summers says that "the basic responsibility of government is to maximise the welfare of citizens, not to pursue some abstract concept of the global good" now ? Maybe those "dumb" people were right after all and maybe we were wrong? Did you consider that for a second?

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by mistermann on Sunday July 16, 2017 @02:04AM (#14780735)
> Why suddenly everyone on world economic forum in Davos say that costs from globalization are higher than benefits for western world? That they have political and social costs. Why most "free trade" advocates suddenly say that they were maybe wrong ? Why Larry Summers says that "the basic responsibility of government is to maximise the welfare of citizens, not to pursue some abstract concept of the global good" now ?

Where are you reading this, I haven't heard anything like this at all? As far as I know, it's business as usual is it not?

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by wildmusings on Saturday July 15, 2017 @10:25PM (#14780171)
I voted for Trump actually.
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by mcphage on Saturday July 15, 2017 @10:47PM (#14780220)
> he certainly has plenty of courage

For someone with plenty of courage, he sure is afraid of a lot of people.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by mistermann on Sunday July 16, 2017 @02:01AM (#14780725)
Other people like Sam Harris who have both courage and intelligence (whether you agree with him or not) are legitimately afraid of the same people, but unlike Trump have solid reasoning behind their beliefs.

Besides, Trump isn't "afraid" of anyone, he just knows playing on people's fear works.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by mcphage on Sunday July 16, 2017 @10:42AM (#14782157)
> Besides, Trump isn't "afraid" of anyone

I see no evidence for that.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by mistermann on Monday July 17, 2017 @10:00AM (#14788532)
He's a compulsive liar, you can see evidence of both sides of almost any issue.
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by dragontamer on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:39PM (#14779135)
> Half the population has an IQ below 100.

Not surprising, since the very definition of "IQ 100" is average.

As far as most researchers go, it turns out that the "IQ 100" has gotten harder and harder every year for nearly the past 100 years. In effect, a person with "IQ 100" back in 1930s would only have an IQ score of ~70 today.

Yes, the _average_ person of the 1930s would be considered borderline retarded (defined as below IQ 70) by today's much higher standards.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect

------------------

The average person is far, far more intelligent today than decades past. There are numerous theories why this is happening (better nutrition? Better technology? Maybe better schooling and teaching?) But regardless, we as a society are significantly improving our "IQ scores" decade after decade.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by pdonis on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:51PM (#14779201)
> The average person is far, far more intelligent today than decades past.

That's not the only possible explanation of the Flynn effect. An obvious alternative hypothesis (which is mentioned in the Wikipedia article) is that people have gotten much more experienced at taking standardized tests, without having actually increased in general intelligence at all.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by noobermin on Saturday July 15, 2017 @07:05PM (#14779581)
Which sort of casts doubt on the value of the IQ measure in general, don't you think?

Don't forget, Richard Feynman scored a 125 in high school, and by the Flynn effect, he'd be considered even dumber today. Let that sink in.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by pdonis on Saturday July 15, 2017 @11:19PM (#14780300)
> Which sort of casts doubt on the value of the IQ measure in general, don't you think?

Yes.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by pizza on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:42PM (#14779146)
What evidence is there of intelligence following a Gaussian distribution, anyway?
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by dragontamer on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:42PM (#14779152)
None.

Its an assumption of the IQ Test. The test itself assumes a Gaussian distribution.

IQ Test was a quick-and-dirty testing methodology made in the dark ages of psychology. It turned out to be a decent measurement of general intelligence, but its theoretical fundamentals are... kind of shoddy. I mean, its better than a lot of early 1900s psychology... but its still from an age when psychology was more folk-science than real science.

Fortunately, the IQ Test actually seems to measure something... and due to its age there are a large number of results that span over a century. And the test has been relatively standard throughout the time (with exception of its increasing difficulty, as our population has grown smarter on the average)

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by zo1 on Saturday July 15, 2017 @08:59PM (#14779945)
What evidence is there of height following a normal distribution? Weight? Size of rocks in a riverbed?

The normal distribution simply implies that there is some sort of "average" or middle area, and that the further you go from it both sides (smaller/larger, faster/slower, etc), it becomes harder and harder to find instances of that measurement.

It's just the way it is, and I'm probably not smart enough to explain it to you in a concise-enough way, but that's the gist of it from my understanding.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by pizza on Sunday July 16, 2017 @07:30PM (#14784662)
The thing about the normal distribution is that it's the distribution with the least information content. It has really little to do with real-world complex processes, and fitting real world phenomena to one typically ends in frustration and wildly incorrect estimates of likelihoods of samples. Intelligence (as measured through some test) being representative of a process that has minimal conditional structure underlying it seems pretty fishy to me.

I'd expect intelligence to be more of an asymmetric distribution, with the vast majority of people being above the threshold of, say, catatonia; most people being under "genius" level, and a blip for geniuses that have really changed humanity's capabilities as being pretty far to the upper bounds, but with incredible impact on the group. Something like a "6 sigma" intelligence on a normal distribution would probably show up a lot more often on the skew distribution I have in mind.

Although, this might be measuring something like E[f(intelligence)] where f is a convex impact-measuring function of intelligence

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by Kenji on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:43PM (#14779155)
> Not surprising, since the very definition of "IQ 100" is average.

Average is not enough. If you have 10 people who have an IQ of 80 and one with an IQ of 300, that'd also average to 100. What matters here is the (roughly) gaussian distribution, too.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by dragontamer on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:45PM (#14779173)
The IQ Test assumes a Gaussian distribution by definition.

One-standard deviation above and below is defined as 85 to 115. Two standard deviations (which includes 95% of the population) is between 70 and 130.

----------

Your proposition that someone has an IQ Score of 13+ Sigma above the average only demonstrates your lack of understanding of the IQ test. There's literally no one that's that high. The IQ Test I think only measures like +/- 4 sigma or so... 40 to 160.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by paulpauper on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:20PM (#14779336)
Technically, tests can be devised to extrapolate IQs to the 200+ range . One such test is reading age and talking age. If someone attains a cognitive milestone at such an early age that is only achievable by one in a billion people, the person has a 1/billion rarity IQ or IQ of 200 (assuming a SD of 15).
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by vacri on Saturday July 15, 2017 @08:26PM (#14779846)
That's not 'technically' at all. It's an approximation.

The actual IQ test is multivariate and takes several hours to administer, and needs to be given by a trained professional. Hitting a single milestone super-early just means that you've hit a milestone super-early, not that your general intelligence is super-high.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by watwut on Sunday July 16, 2017 @02:28AM (#14780810)
Early reading is result of good memory at early age. That is about it.

In general, the speed of brain development and how intelligent you will be in the end are not closely related.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by Kenji on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:17PM (#14779320)
It was an example with simple numbers. My goodness, I forgot how pedantic people are here. If someone does not understand that average is not median, then I'm not going to talk about standard deviation...
[dead]
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by Kenji on Saturday July 15, 2017 @07:03PM (#14779576)
At this point, you are literally trolling me.
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by ucarion on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:34PM (#14779102)
In that sentence, Asimov refers to the popular conception of the elite -- a very low standard -- and not some elite that is defined as the top 1% of society by some measure.

On this popular conception of the elite, almost anyone can be a member. All you really need to do is regularly read a news publication.

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by paulpauper on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:24PM (#14779361)
yeah just reading the news will make you better-informed than 95% of the population probably
Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by middleclick on Saturday July 15, 2017 @05:34PM (#14779105)
Since IQ was mentioned, another Asimov essay on the topic:

"What Is Intelligence, Anyway?"

http://talentdevelop.com/articles/WIIA.html

Re:America's Cult of Ignorance (1980) [pdf] by PhasmaFelis on Saturday July 15, 2017 @06:05PM (#14779260)
Asimov is not demanding that everyone be a brilliant professor. He is demanding that people educate themselves to the best of their personal ability, rather than expilictly despising anyone who attempts to do that.