Reviewing a paper is mostly charity and gets you nothing in return, except the fact that when you submit a paper, someone will do the same. It does not help in the Green Card process at all, or boosts your academic credentials.
Regarding overworked professors, they are allowed to delegate reviews internally to students to ease the time they have to spend.
What about PhDs? You've never seen PhDs review papers in CS? It happens for prestigious conferences too.
Also your pointing fingers at foreigners is quite disturbing. Why you think they caused the problem? Do you have any evidence? I don't think in any academic workplace you can say this without unfavorable consequence.
Your last line is one of the most frustrating parts of academia. Not being able to criticize misaligned incentives simply because it involves foreigners is crazy.
I don't know why you summarize my lines this way. I basically want to know whether he can offer some evidence to support that idea.
I have never heard of this. No-one knows if you review a paper, it has no bearing on your job security or your visa status, this post is baffling
s/broke/broken/
(unless you meant bankrupt, then broke is fine).
> Foreign Postdocs studying in the United States are desperate for a Green Card. They peer review as many papers as they can as quickly as they can to prove something or other for the purposes of a securing a Green Card. Some of these foreign postdocs do a good job, many do not. Also, overworked professors don't always take the time to carefully read a paper and don't care. The result is that a lot papers make it through peer review that shouldn't.
Well, it's unfortunate that you seem to have experienced the worst review processes. It is also unfortunate that you automatically assume that it's _foreign_ postdocs that are doing the shoddy work. Maybe you had bad luck, or maybe you're oversimplifying for the sake of argument, dunno, but that does not jive very well with what I've seen, all the way up from being a student author, student reviewer, reviewer, PC member, journal reviewer, and Program Chair of a conference.
At least in CS, the number of reviews done by postdocs is not a large percentage. Most PCs are composed of academic and industry researchers, primarily professors and professionals, and increasingly reviewers are no longer allowed to use sub-reviewers without attribution. The number of postdoc PC members is low; and for good reason. Postdocs typically last less than two years, and during this period they are more focused on publishing their own research as a last push to improve their academic standing before finding a job. I get the impression that it's known that postdocs are too busy to do a good job at reviewing.
> I'd rather have my paper peer reviewed live on the internet by allowing people to comment on it beneath a PDF link...
I guess you never had a Boaty McBoatface moment. I think open review without experts would be disastrous, as the nitty gritty fine details that absolutely have to be right should be vetted carefully by experts, rather than spending forever in a shouting match with the loudest voices in the crowd. Can you imagine peer review by YouTube comments? shudder
Don't know about that, but the inbred cloned mouse business seems to have quality control issues.
I've seen first hand how the peer review system works in the United States. Foreign Postdocs studying in the United States are desperate for a Green Card. They peer review as many papers as they can as quickly as they can to prove something or other for the purposes of a securing a Green Card. Some of these foreign postdocs do a good job, many do not. Also, overworked professors don't always take the time to carefully read a paper and don't care. The result is that a lot papers make it through peer review that shouldn't.
I'd rather have my paper peer reviewed live on the internet by allowing people to comment on it beneath a PDF link than to suffer through another drawn out peer review process. People who care have a text-box where they say what they want, and if no one cares then it indicates I need to do research on something else!