News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by netcan on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @09:47AM (#14702330)
In other news, the parliament took a vote affirming previous decisions that TV shows should be funnier.

..I guess that was trite. The EU parliament is in a constitutional limbo state. It doesn’t have real power or a predefined legislative jurisdiction, so voters don’t take it seriously. They elect quirky, fring-ey members they wouldn’t elect to their own national parties.

I’m in favour of durable products, but I don’t see how this is en route to policies that affect this.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by illys on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @10:18AM (#14702561)
You probably do not live in Europe (or maybe you just like trolling?).

First I am a voter and I do take the EU parliament seriously. I also consider what the groups and candidates voted in the past before giving them my vote - especially on topics like world trade giant agreements (TTIP, TATFA, CETA... - yes they also vote on that and it is very meaningful for our future).

You may also read some documentation on the powers and functions of the EU Parliament: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Parliament#Powers_and...

You may also just read the news:

-> UK just voted to get out of EU to escape EU funding and regulations - so probably those regulations do exist at a significant extend.

-> A recent example: the GSM roaming (a former giant cash machine against consumers) just got extinguished within EU countries by EU regulation.

So probably - yes - they can set rules on repairability and durability.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by taway_1212 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:04AM (#14702929)
> A recent example: the GSM roaming (a former giant cash machine against consumers) just got extinguished within EU countries by EU regulation.

Wasn't that the European Commission (and not Parliament) though? They seem to be significantly more powerful.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by vidarh on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:29AM (#14703158)
EU law needs to be proposed by the Commission (though the Maastricht Treaty gives Parliament powers to request that the Commission should put forward proposals on their behalf), and then normally approved and/or amended by both Parliament and the Council, with drawn out conciliation procedures if one or the other changes the proposals too much.

The complexity stems from the legal status where the EU is in some respects a confederation of sovereign states, where the governments of the member states need to represent their respective nations, and in some respects a union of people. The gradual shift of power towards the Parliament represents attempts to shift it towards the latter, while the Commission and Council represents the treat realities where delegating more power to Parliament would require constitutional changes in a number of member states to cede the sovereignty (currently this is worked around by having the treaties bind the respective governments to take make the required decision - it's exploiting the wide latitude most governments have in exercising treating rights and obligations.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by taway_1212 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @03:26PM (#14705400)
Thanks for the writeup! This gives some insight into how convoluted the system is and hence why people don't trust it.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by peoplewindow on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:05AM (#14702939)
How is he trolling by stating the facts? You might wish it were different but the EU Parliament doesn't have any real power. It can call for things all it likes, but it can't make law, which raises the question of why it calls itself a Parliament. The single purpose of a Parliament is to make law, after all.

The wiki page you link to does say that.

Voters have been figuring it out. Turnout for EP elections has been falling steadily since the institution was first created:

http://www.ukpolitical.info/european-parliament-election-tur...

From 62% to around 40% on average. People don't bother voting because the EP can't/won't actually do much except cheerlead for the EU itself and demand it does more.

This sort of story appears from time to time. The EP calls for this, it calls for that. Nobody pays much attention because these "calls" don't matter. The EU's laws can only be changed by the Commission, and EU law is made entirely in secret (unlike every other legislature in the world save North Korea). So there's little point trying to get involved or care what they do - EU law just "appears" fully formed and gets implemented without debate.

https://euobserver.com/institutional/136630

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by yorwba on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:48AM (#14703381)
> You might wish it were different but the EU Parliament doesn't have any real power.

The EP can't initiate new law, but they can still vote on law proposed by the Commission, which does give them a certain amount of power. Your second link mentions MEPs doing back-room deals with the Commission and European diplomats, which they certainly couldn't do if they were entirely powerless.

I'm also skeptical on your claim that North Korea is the only other legislature where this secret law-making happens. Other autocracies aside, in any system with political parties, proposed legislation will most likely be circulated within the party for some time; then discussed informally with leaders of other parties that might be necessary for a majority, before it is first presented at a public hearing.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by gpderetta on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @12:55PM (#14704062)
They can also extensively amend laws and have the right to ask the commission to submit a proposal, and as far as I understand, the commission routinely obliges.

So, while it might not have the jure initiative power, it does de facto.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by peoplewindow on Thursday July 06, 2017 @04:13AM (#14708863)
The Commission frequently obliges because the EP is stuffed full of wildly unrepresentative EU fans whose proposals are usually of the form, "Please Commission, award yourself more power". This article being a good case in point - they're asking the EU Commission to regulate more at the EU level.

If the EP had made any serious attempt to prevent Brexit, for example by proposing to the Commission to let member states have more control over immigration, they'd simply have been ignored and thus they never both making proposals that they know would get rejected.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by netcan on Thursday July 06, 2017 @06:06AM (#14709233)
I live in Ireland, and I didn't intend to troll though I should have probably written that differently. I was reacting mostly to the language of the recommendations. Though, I also think we have a serious polity problem. I think many Europeans people treated recent EU parliamentary elections as an opportunity for protest or half-serious voting. I think this creates a negative feedback between disempowered parliament and an electorate that doesn't take it seriously or want to give it more power.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by etix on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @09:52AM (#14702365)
Extending the minimum warranty can help to make more durable products.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by jrimbault on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @10:28AM (#14702649)
The EU already made mandatory 24 months warranty for all products sold in Europe.

I think this has been beneficial not only to European citizens but also to the US where there isn't a minimum warranty by default. Businesses who sell products on both sides of the Atlantic seem to have mirrored the imposed warranty of the EU in the US.

I am in favor of extending the minimum warranty.

PS: isn't there also some regulation that a business should provide pieces for repair for a period of 10 years? I seem to recall something like that.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by ferongr on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @02:19PM (#14704888)
The EU directive might say that but countries codify that into law differently. For example, here in Greece, there is actually no law stating warranties should be two years. It only says that the warranty should be "reasonable depending on the expected lifetime of the product".
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by ovi256 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:10AM (#14702991)
Don't forget that the 24 month warranty is one of the stated reasons for justifying the sale price difference for the same product between the US and the EU.

If it's increased, manufacturers will just increase their EU prices so that their costs will be covered.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by jrimbault on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @11:22AM (#14703103)
The price difference seems mostly due to advertised prices.

In the US they advertise the price excluding tax, in the EU we advertise the price including tax.

When counting taxes, there isn't a big difference.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by runeks on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @12:16PM (#14703673)
I don't want to have to pay more for durable products. Please let me choose whether I want to buy extended warranty -- many manufacturers already offer it, but I'm not interested it in.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by ksk on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @03:24PM (#14705385)
But extended warranty is just insurance, nothing to do with the product being durable or not.

I don't buy the argument that costs will skyrocket. Most manufacturers, won't give a lot of thought to making their products more durable while keeping the costs down, unless pressured, either by consumers, or the government. They're more focused on making money (rightfully so). The incentive to keep making money because their products break often causing people to re-buy, must be removed IMHO.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by simion314 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @12:28PM (#14703807)
I know that most people change their phones often but there are products that are expensive like washing machine, gas heaters that should be designed from the start to last 5 years or more. If 2 companies build washing machines and they need to increase the warranty time, the one that can do that with less price increase would sell more, the one that planned them to break down faster would lose and have to make a new dessign.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by runeks on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @01:56PM (#14704693)
Why don't you just pay for the 5 year warranty if you want it, instead of wanting to make it mandatory that everyone pay?
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by ksk on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @03:26PM (#14705402)
The warranty doesn't make the product durable. Its just allows you to re-buy the same non-durable product using resources from a shared pool.

This is about addressing the fundamental problem.

Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by simion314 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @04:58PM (#14706038)
Would you buy a car if the seller gives 1 month warranty? My opinion is that expensive products should have longer warranty by default. For cheaper products current 2 years is fine.
Re:EU Parliament calls for longer lifetime for products by simion314 on Wednesday July 05, 2017 @10:25AM (#14702631)
Maybe the fact that the people in the EU parliament are not in the focus of the electoral people is a good thing, they will not put a big effort into the political "game", back at home the guys don't usually vote on topics on what they personal believe is best but have to vote on how the party decide is best for themselves to get a good score at the next elections.