News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by anindha on Saturday July 01, 2017 @12:00AM (#14675305)
I have seen questionable material come from him [1]:

Examples: "Money Shot" with kitten spreadings its legs and "Great Products...Get you LAID".

[1] https://www.slideshare.net/dmc500hats/how-to-pitch-a-vc-or-a...

edit: link directly to slides and deleted nested comment.

Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by mhluongo on Saturday July 01, 2017 @01:55AM (#14675620)
Did he come up with "paid, laid, or made"? I've heard it from sales people and thought it predated McClure.

The kitten and "money shot" is absolutely unnecessary, but I get the coarse language for "paid, made, laid"- the idea is that compelling products and services target base desires.

Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by anindha on Saturday July 01, 2017 @02:11AM (#14675663)
I think the most compelling products deliver utility. Even if targeting base desires is your product design strategy doesn't mean it needs to be in a template for future founders to follow.

Your argument is similar to the argument for having swimsuit models in tabloid newspapers. NYT is a better product.

Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by coldtea on Saturday July 01, 2017 @07:45AM (#14676676)
>Your argument is similar to the argument for having swimsuit models in tabloid newspapers. NYT is a better product.

Not if "sells more" is a measure of product betterness.

(Besides swimsuit models never harmed anybody -- the NYT helped sell war with huge human toll with BS government-fed info).

Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by TeMPOraL on Saturday July 01, 2017 @03:08AM (#14675821)
> I think the most compelling products deliver utility.

> Your argument is similar to the argument for having swimsuit models in tabloid newspapers. NYT is a better product.

The argument is right, because better (as in NYT vs. tabloids, or as in better in worse-is-better) products don't win on market. If you can target base desires, you'll beat products delivering utility.

Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by mhluongo on Saturday July 01, 2017 @02:35AM (#14675728)
I'm not claiming he's right. I'm just responding that it's a useful idea, and that the language makes sense to reinforce the idea.

Edit: aside, it's interesting (and frustrating) that comments on HN are often assumed to be arguments. Here for a discussion, not to defend a thesis.

Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by Alex3917 on Saturday July 01, 2017 @11:25AM (#14677485)
> Even if targeting base desires is your product design strategy doesn't mean it needs to be in a template for future founders to follow.

Call me old school, but I still think that JWZ post "Groupware Bad" is one of the most important in the history of blogging.

Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by gexla on Saturday July 01, 2017 @04:47AM (#14676122)
Let's say we're talking about Chris Rock. There's a difference between him cracking jokes on a public stage and him directing these same sorts of jokes to a potential hire in a private conversation.
Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by cylinder on Saturday July 01, 2017 @10:36AM (#14677262)
I don't really understand what you're trying to say.
Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by westoncb on Saturday July 01, 2017 @03:14AM (#14675833)
I haven't looked into McClure's offenses beyond what the article talks about, but those slides seem totally innocent to me (it's a joke targeted at VCs more than anything else), which just makes him seem less guilty in this context ('cause why not just use real evidence then?). No comment on his actual guilt.

This quote from the linked article (from Chris Sacca) seems apt:

Over the last week, I have spoken with friends, friends of friends, heard from people from my past including stories of how I’d behaved, and read incredibly thoughtful and courageous essays. I’ve learned that it’s often the less obvious, yet pervasive and questionable, everyday behaviors of men in our industry that collectively make it inhospitable for women.

There is definitely a pervasive issue here in software culture as it relates to women, and maybe singling out and punishing individuals is the only way to combat it—but my first inclination when making moral judgements is to consider intent. When I see those slides above, I see the work of someone whose 'filter' and sensitivity to not offending people is lower than average. I do not see immoral activity, however.

I will gladly look at more info. on McClure's offenses if anyone wants to share—and I'm perfectly aware he may not be an instance of what I'm about to mention here—but, we recognize there is a systemic issue with gender equality in software which needs to be fixed, but is there maybe a better strategy than punishing individuals who get caught displaying symptoms of the admitted, systemic issue? (or do we retract the claim that there's a systemic issue? —cause those things are at odds: is it the fault of the culture these people are a part of, or have they personally done something egregious? We could mistakenly go too far in either direction, but maybe our aim will be better if that part of the issue is at least considered...)

Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by skywhopper on Saturday July 01, 2017 @11:59AM (#14677626)
Obviously that slide deck was not the offense in question for Mr McClure. However, I'm surprised you think the slide deck is appropriate. Here's a good tip: sexual jokes and references are just not appropriate for a business context. And they become even more inappropriate the greater the gender imbalance is. When there's one or two women in a room of fifty men, and you give a presentation mentioning the supposed universal desire of getting laid, money shots, and showing a guy cuddling up with two adoring women, all of whom are partially undressed, that is creating an extraordinarily uncomfortable environment for those women. Combine that with near-constant "flirting" and come-ons those women experience from the men with more money and more power who surround them and can control their future in the industry and who often react very badly to any suggestion that they are being too aggressive or misinterpreting the women's behavior, and it feels like real menace, not harmless jokes.
Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by westoncb on Saturday July 01, 2017 @02:21PM (#14678230)
That's a good point, and I agree that depending on the gender ratios present, it could be a very uncomfortable situation for minority female attendees. Also, the money shot and guy cuddling with two girls are pretty iffy.

At the same time, however, you are only addressing my first sentence, and my question remains about how to best deal with this: even granting the above, I'm still left with the impression that this guy is largely socially tone deaf and non-malicious, and a product of his culture: so is it possible to make corrections without 'treating the symptom' (i.e. punishing individuals who happen to display symptoms of a systemic issue)—or maybe that's the only way we can get at it?

Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by ethbro on Saturday July 01, 2017 @03:47PM (#14678619)
I'll comment more on racism in the south, but in my opinion the best formulation of the problem is: "there are systemic, bad cultural norms".

If you look at it this way, then punishing every incidence is critical if you want to change attitude towards them (albeit in a contextually-adjusted severe manner, of course).

But for people just "following how things are done", the disincentive is chance_of_being_caught * punishment_for_being_caught.

If only the second term in that equation changes as a result of the current push, then I feel like it just creates more inequality and doesn't change the underlying problem as much.

So yes, punishment for all to some degree that's more than a wrist slap.

Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by coldtea on Saturday July 01, 2017 @07:47AM (#14676680)
>I haven't looked into McClure's offenses beyond what the article talks about, but those slides seem totally innocent to me

Not in a puritan country. People have lost their jobs for making a "dongle -> dick" joke speaking to their friend at a conference because someone overheard...

Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by oliv__ on Saturday July 01, 2017 @02:50PM (#14678377)
Those slides are of pretty poor taste...
Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by moonman272 on Saturday July 01, 2017 @11:45AM (#14677563)
Starting at the beginning of that slide deck, it really seems to be mocking the culture
Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by borski on Saturday July 01, 2017 @02:12AM (#14675665)
To be fair, the second slide directly says it is guaranteed to offend.
Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by cylinder on Saturday July 01, 2017 @10:37AM (#14677268)
"heh, this is guaranteed to offend, but if you go out to dinner with me you'll definitely get this job!"
Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by borski on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:18PM (#14679360)
Conflating two things here. Saying something exaggerated and offensive, specifically for effect and attention, is not the same thing as a power play for sex.
Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by skywhopper on Saturday July 01, 2017 @12:01PM (#14677633)
That doesn't make it appropriate. If anything it's evidence that its author knew very well it was _not_ appropriate.
Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by borski on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:19PM (#14679369)
Never said it did. He was clearly attempting to use it for shock and attention.
Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by askmike on Saturday July 01, 2017 @07:11AM (#14676568)
Is that supposed to excuse it?
Re:McClure steps back at 500Startups after internal sexual m... by borski on Saturday July 01, 2017 @06:20PM (#14679381)
Nope, just stating the fact that he specifically knew he was using it for shock and attention.