Your argument is similar to the argument for having swimsuit models in tabloid newspapers. NYT is a better product.
Not if "sells more" is a measure of product betterness.
(Besides swimsuit models never harmed anybody -- the NYT helped sell war with huge human toll with BS government-fed info).
> Your argument is similar to the argument for having swimsuit models in tabloid newspapers. NYT is a better product.
The argument is right, because better (as in NYT vs. tabloids, or as in better in worse-is-better) products don't win on market. If you can target base desires, you'll beat products delivering utility.
Edit: aside, it's interesting (and frustrating) that comments on HN are often assumed to be arguments. Here for a discussion, not to defend a thesis.
Call me old school, but I still think that JWZ post "Groupware Bad" is one of the most important in the history of blogging.
The kitten and "money shot" is absolutely unnecessary, but I get the coarse language for "paid, made, laid"- the idea is that compelling products and services target base desires.