There's also a second argument at play: If China can make a product for $10 cheaper, legitimate shipping included, because they're allowed to abuse their workers and pay them much less, do we trust pure capitalism to properly prioritize the values of the American people? This really is the case of, say, Apple's electronics plants in China.
But there are some digital goods where we do not give this same treatment (namely digital material involving really bad child maltreatment). Regardless of the legality of where the material is produced, owning it in the US is illegal because it couldn't legally be produced in the US and funding such illegal action elsewhere is considered morally wrong enough to ban.
Simply put, I think the core idea should be applied to all financial transactions. If one is buying a good or service that would be illegal in the US due to harm to another human, it should be illegal to buy or own in the US, even if where it is produced is legal. The law should prevent a person from harming another human by shopping around and finding wherever has the least legal protections.
If we applied this to foreign transactions, foreign countries could easily use the same grounds to block goods and services coming from the US.
We've always benefited from Chinese labor abuses, and whether an American intermediary is involved doesn't change that.
The problem is that no one on those villages are interested in paying some small price to receive a thing from America.
Fast forward to 2017, yes, now the agreement seems unfair because the deliver of goods changed a lot. Perhaps should be reviewed. But I wouldn't say it just worked on theory back then, neither will I say that now it is unidirectional in practice (because you still can make it go in any direction).
And the main point isn't just that things made in China are cheaper. It's that China has so much freight going to all parts of the world that putting one container full of envelops with a single button inside doesn't cost a thing, so they win in on how much it costs to take an envelop from a post office inside China and deliver it to a USA / Europe / South America port.
It costs about US 1,900 to take a container from Shangai to New York (source: https://www.searates.com ). That is cheap.
Shipping a container from Shanghai to NY is not the issue, it is that China pays less for shipping along the same route in the US and other western countries. They are paying less than others, on top of the fact that mail is largely unidirectional - so they're kind of cheating twice. If the shoe was on the other foot they'd be on top of it because they have more intelligent leadership than Western nations.
But who decides the values of the American people then? Should the govt's approach be "We know this product was made by kids, so it is banned", or "We are educating you that this product involved child labor, it is upto you to use your values now"?
I think the second approach will cause trivial change, at best.
Vegans and various religious people make different purchasing decisions because of values they actually find important enough to change their lifestyles for.
I don't agree, because there's nothing consensual about the situation...
I took a quick look at what people are sending their SOs in prison to spend at the commissary to buy things like deodorant and snacks (http://www.prisontalk.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-682271....). The numbers ranged from lower ($40) to several hundred a month. Assuming $100, they'd have to work over 11 hour days.
The problem is however, even in cases when you can produce something as cheaply in the US as in China, a Chinese seller can still beat you on price because they pay less for shipping.
And that seems dumb.
I'm not convinced at the moment that it's the shipping alone that is causing the issue with the US sellers, especially given the limitations of the cheap shipping agreement (under 4.4 lbs I believe it said).
A small domestic package just costs more than one shipped from China. So yes, it's possible they can instead compete on delivery time, and they do.
But all else being equal, it seems dumb that they can't be given access to the same pricing as Chinese sellers if they conform to the same rules (drop off at shipping hubs, labeling standards etc).
http://thydzik.com/how-do-chinesehong-kong-sellers-make-mone...
Anything else I consider too risky. In particular, I never order consumer electronics from China (unless I explicitly go for a particular Chinese brand). The crap quality is not worth the price savings.
For stuff like resistors, capacitors, some microcontrollers, power supplies, etc., the Chinese sellers are pretty reliable.
I wouldn't necessarily expect local-to-local shipping always to be cheaper. But I'd expect there to be at least one option where you can bring a pre-labelled package to a shipping hub and get it sent at the same or lower cost.
Take that subsidy away. If the intermediate seller can still survive, then he is still providing some economic benefit.
The surplus comes from the fact that US buyers don't have to pay a percentage to the intermediary, so they can spend it on other things, like going out to a local restaurant more often.
A contrived example...
A person has $X that they spend every week at the local town restaurant. They see they can buy a cool new widget from a Chinese vendor (from the article) for $Y. Over the course of the next few weeks, said person spends a little less at the restaurant so as to save up $Y, ultimately purchasing the widget once enough money is saved.
In this example the person is contributing less to the local economy.
I guess the question then is: do we have a way of predicting which way it will go?
Though I don't see introducing/enforcing waste as a right way to ensure more money goes to the national economy.
My experience with this isn't quite how you're describing. The Chinese vendors are sort of having their cake and eating it too. They'll often, for example, not be honest about the the shipping time, their return policies, product details, ability to answer product questions, and so forth. Even if the selling platform does something about it, another Chinese seller pops up to replace any that are booted out.
So, for the end consumer, they don't get a true view into what the consequences are of buying from the lowest bidder.
It's difficult for a US supplier to get their value proposition out there on platforms like Amazon, as there is one product listing and multiple sellers. There's no spot to show why your offering that's priced higher is worth it. Better support, return policies, fast shipping, product knowledge, etc.
For some products and items, the difference between the chinese produced items and the actual items is a world of difference (e.g., electronics batteries, power adapters), but that isn't really the business that the article was talking about the cut into - the issue was resellers who would buy up a warehouse stock from chinese producers and sell it at mark-up; with modern postal agreements and websites, there really isn't a need for this particular service.
It's not a matter of meeting shipping times or any other value propositions, it's "do we need someone to resell a toy boat at twice the price when we can buy the same stock directly"
That may not apply to toy boats, but it does apply to some things. Take USB to serial adapters, for example. In that case, a middle man does add value. A good middle man ensures that you get what was advertised...for example, the chipset is what the product listing says it is. They also provide better documentation, support, the ability to return the item without high shipping costs, etc, than the direct-from-china seller.
So, yes, it's slightly different...taking into account that in some cases the middleman adds value.
Also, it does still apply if you don't like the idea that the Amazon listing said shipping would be a week and it ends up being a month. That's not just the overseas shipping time either...it's the cultural difference with the Chinese sellers. "Sorry for the delay, it is Chinese New Year, and we're all off on vacation for 2 weeks, and we just don't work , note that in the listing, etc".
Or, it matters if you want to return the toy boat. Your cost to ship it back to China might exceed the total cost of the item you paid.
If these tradeoffs were known before hand, I get your point. Typically, though, they are deliberately not disclosed.
On eBay, from a customer's perspective, there's no difference between a US seller and a Chinese one. We have the same way of "punishing" them. I cannot punish a US based seller any more than a Chinese one.
>If these tradeoffs were known before hand, I get your point. Typically, though, they are deliberately not disclosed.
Frankly, the stuff I've bought on eBay from Chinese sellers is so cheap that I don't really care to return them. They fall into the price range of "I don't give a damn". In the US an item may be $30. From the Chinese, $7. It's worth the gamble.
(And it really is worth the gamble. I've not been disappointed once).
You can, in that eBay has less ability to deal with Chinese sellers coming back with fake or borrowed credentials.
I do concede that eBay and their seller centric reviews deal with this better than Amazon and their product/not-seller centric review model.
Not been my experience for shipping time. They usually claim such a large shipping window that it is always delivered within that window.
As for lower quality service, I'm not sure I see the problem. The consumer wants to pay a lower amount, and he gets what he is paying for. There's nothing fundamentally wrong or unethical about it. The same principle will hold in the US too. And frankly, I've had plenty of poor service on eBay from US based sellers.
I interact with Chinese sellers a lot. Both as a middleman, and for personal purchases. Hundreds of purchases over years. I see a lot of deception, deliberate as well as unintentional.
Subsidizing businesses abroad seems less desirable, especially if it costs us millions of dollars a year. That should just be part of the price of the good, whether or not it goes through a US intermediary. Instead we have this weird system where purchases directly from China are subsidized by taxes, but domestic purchases are "full price".
The internet has allowed a new generation of middlemen to rise, providing the service at a lower cost.
eBay and Amazon are middlemen.
Note that whether or not middlemen add value is not under their control. Local resellers add much less value than they used to now that global e-commerce works. Recording labels added value until the Internet came, and now they don't.
The Father Niemoller of the modern age.
My experience is that way over 95% of items are as described, arrive safely, and perfectly functional. The odd item that is broken in transit (or never arrives) I simply choose not to care about.
I don't need a warranty on a connector, an Arduino clone, or a tube of solder...
I wouldn't try that with consumer electronics though. Anything that's actually assembled to be sold cheap will likely be close to unusable. I can name plenty of examples of crap electronics I ordered from China or saw personally on Chinese markets when I was in Shenzhen. I stick to big western brands in this market simply to avoid completely useless crap.
(One exception from my "components only" rule are USB cables. I bought a bunch when I was in Shenzhen, and I actually tested them physically before buying; I discovered that if you pick a random USB cable there, there's like 70% chance it won't be able to give you more than ~750mA from a 2A charger...)
It's literally better than 95% (probably more like 99%) good stuff and I'm willing to eat the small amount of slippage/breakage/fraud/poor design.
In a parallel comment I described my negative experience with USB cables, which I tested on-site to find some that actually work for charging a cell phone. I also sourced USB chargers from China and have two burn out on me. Random Bluetooth headset from Aliexpress managed to completely mess up Android on my phone (how that was possible is beyond me, but I guess crappy Bluetooth 2.x firmware).
So, anecdata to anecdata, I don't share your confidence in any kind of electronic products. I stick to sourcing components now.
I understand the seller's frustration - their means of supporting themselves has been taken away, but I'm not sure I buy the argument that we need the intermediary just to "add to the economy". To me it just seems like an unsustainable business model that was destined to die once global communication became much easier, not just because of the various treaties and agreements of postal services.
The moment that chinese sellers could get a site available to a global audience, the need for an intermediary vanished; before you essentially paid for the connection; an extra $18 on a remote controlled toy boat was paying for access to the seller's inventory, supplied by his Chinese connections.
Now, there's no need for that connection or that warehouse - the visibility for any foreign seller is much greater, even to the point that it probably would still be valuable even without the USPS trade deal.
It's unfortunate, but this just seems like a model that was destined to die.