News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:USPS loses millions each year on local delivery of mail f... by tyingq on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @09:01AM (#14653661)
>To me it just seems like an unsustainable business model

My experience with this isn't quite how you're describing. The Chinese vendors are sort of having their cake and eating it too. They'll often, for example, not be honest about the the shipping time, their return policies, product details, ability to answer product questions, and so forth. Even if the selling platform does something about it, another Chinese seller pops up to replace any that are booted out.

So, for the end consumer, they don't get a true view into what the consequences are of buying from the lowest bidder.

It's difficult for a US supplier to get their value proposition out there on platforms like Amazon, as there is one product listing and multiple sellers. There's no spot to show why your offering that's priced higher is worth it. Better support, return policies, fast shipping, product knowledge, etc.

Re:USPS loses millions each year on local delivery of mail f... by csydas on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @10:20AM (#14654327)
I think this is slightly different than what the article (and by extension my comment) were discussing.

For some products and items, the difference between the chinese produced items and the actual items is a world of difference (e.g., electronics batteries, power adapters), but that isn't really the business that the article was talking about the cut into - the issue was resellers who would buy up a warehouse stock from chinese producers and sell it at mark-up; with modern postal agreements and websites, there really isn't a need for this particular service.

It's not a matter of meeting shipping times or any other value propositions, it's "do we need someone to resell a toy boat at twice the price when we can buy the same stock directly"

Re:USPS loses millions each year on local delivery of mail f... by tyingq on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @10:24AM (#14654358)
>It's not a matter of meeting shipping times or any other value propositions, it's "do we need someone to resell a toy boat at twice the price when we can buy the same stock directly

That may not apply to toy boats, but it does apply to some things. Take USB to serial adapters, for example. In that case, a middle man does add value. A good middle man ensures that you get what was advertised...for example, the chipset is what the product listing says it is. They also provide better documentation, support, the ability to return the item without high shipping costs, etc, than the direct-from-china seller.

So, yes, it's slightly different...taking into account that in some cases the middleman adds value.

Also, it does still apply if you don't like the idea that the Amazon listing said shipping would be a week and it ends up being a month. That's not just the overseas shipping time either...it's the cultural difference with the Chinese sellers. "Sorry for the delay, it is Chinese New Year, and we're all off on vacation for 2 weeks, and we just don't work , note that in the listing, etc".

Or, it matters if you want to return the toy boat. Your cost to ship it back to China might exceed the total cost of the item you paid.

If these tradeoffs were known before hand, I get your point. Typically, though, they are deliberately not disclosed.

Re:USPS loses millions each year on local delivery of mail f... by BeetleB on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @11:18AM (#14654853)
>A good middle man ensures that you get what was advertised...for example, the chipset is what the product listing says it is. They also provide better documentation, support, the ability to return the item without high shipping costs, etc, than the direct-from-china seller.

On eBay, from a customer's perspective, there's no difference between a US seller and a Chinese one. We have the same way of "punishing" them. I cannot punish a US based seller any more than a Chinese one.

>If these tradeoffs were known before hand, I get your point. Typically, though, they are deliberately not disclosed.

Frankly, the stuff I've bought on eBay from Chinese sellers is so cheap that I don't really care to return them. They fall into the price range of "I don't give a damn". In the US an item may be $30. From the Chinese, $7. It's worth the gamble.

(And it really is worth the gamble. I've not been disappointed once).

Re:USPS loses millions each year on local delivery of mail f... by tyingq on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @11:33AM (#14654977)
>cannot punish a US based seller any more than a Chinese one.

You can, in that eBay has less ability to deal with Chinese sellers coming back with fake or borrowed credentials.

I do concede that eBay and their seller centric reviews deal with this better than Amazon and their product/not-seller centric review model.

Re:USPS loses millions each year on local delivery of mail f... by BeetleB on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @11:14AM (#14654824)
>They'll often, for example, not be honest about the the shipping time, their return policies, product details, ability to answer product questions, and so forth.

Not been my experience for shipping time. They usually claim such a large shipping window that it is always delivered within that window.

As for lower quality service, I'm not sure I see the problem. The consumer wants to pay a lower amount, and he gets what he is paying for. There's nothing fundamentally wrong or unethical about it. The same principle will hold in the US too. And frankly, I've had plenty of poor service on eBay from US based sellers.

Re:USPS loses millions each year on local delivery of mail f... by tyingq on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @11:31AM (#14654959)
I agree that it's fine if the tradeoffs are clearly disclosed.

I interact with Chinese sellers a lot. Both as a middleman, and for personal purchases. Hundreds of purchases over years. I see a lot of deception, deliberate as well as unintentional.

Re:USPS loses millions each year on local delivery of mail f... by komali2 on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @09:03AM (#14653674)
I don't see how what you said couldn't equally apply to American sellers.
Re:USPS loses millions each year on local delivery of mail f... by tyingq on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @09:07AM (#14653717)
It could, yes, but it's not been my experience. I suspect part of it is that Amazon is a bit better about blocking US sellers that perform badly, blacklisting the tax id, address, bank accounts, etc, such that bad US sellers can't come back, or create a new entity shedding a history of bad reviews. I don't think they have that same ability for Chinese sellers.
Re:USPS loses millions each year on local delivery of mail f... by JohnTHaller on Wednesday June 28, 2017 @09:20AM (#14653799)
Chinese sellers seem to pop up again with a new fake name overnight on Amazon. And they polute the Amazon inventory with fake goods. To make matters worse, Amazon blocks most reviews that point out receiving fake products.