News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by quotemstr on Saturday June 17, 2017 @12:39AM (#14574297)
I don't think our legal system should allow car manufacturers to impose these kinds of restrictions on cars fully owned by their operators. If I have the title on my vehicle, I should be able to use it in any legal capacity. This restriction is an attack on the fundamental ideas of ownership and property.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by djloche on Saturday June 17, 2017 @12:55AM (#14574340)
the question is one of responsibility in the case of accident. is it the owner of the car? or the driver? what happens when there is no driver? well, my guess is that TSLA the manufacturer of the auto-driving software is going to be liable in place of the driver, and as such, they have every right to say, nope, no using our auto-pilot for commercial activity unless it is on our own network where we can self-regulate to make sure we are liable for as few of problems as possible.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by draugadrotten on Saturday June 17, 2017 @03:09AM (#14574687)
When Tesla say you can't drive passengers commercially it is probably because of liability concerns. Insurance for taxis are much higher than insurance for personal vehicles.

Volvo CEO said already in 2015 that Volvo will accept full liability whenever one of its cars is in autonomous mode.

http://fortune.com/2015/10/07/volvo-liability-self-driving-c...

Re:Tesla Autopilot by bubblethink on Saturday June 17, 2017 @07:06AM (#14575310)
>what happens when there is no driver? well, my guess is that TSLA the manufacturer of the auto-driving software is going to be liable in place of the driver, and as such, they have every right to say, nope, no using our auto-pilot for commercial activity unless it is on our own network

Why does this argument hold true only for self-driving cars, and not current cars ? As such, self-driving cars are just a point in continuous evolution. Current cars are already quite different from what they were a few decades ago. Why is now a good time to draw a line ? Every change in this eveolution goes through government approval. If it is approved, it should be safe enough for everyone.

Re:Tesla Autopilot by grkvlt on Sunday June 18, 2017 @12:11AM (#14578932)
It sort of does hold for current cars. Generally a driver (in most cases, a human) must obtain a further license or some form of government permission/authorization to drive a vehicle for commercial purposes like a taxi or other passenger carrying service. This seems to be simply pointing out that the same restriction will apply to the software-based driver in a Tesla...?
Re:Tesla Autopilot by bubblethink on Sunday June 18, 2017 @04:05PM (#14582605)
There is no legislation about ride sharing/taxi with self driving cars. So whether or not an extra authorization is needed by the owner of the car is a different issue. Here Tesla is asking you to not engage in ride sharing unless Tesla gets a cut. i.e., Even if the government and insurance companies allow you to do so, Tesla won't unless you hand over your cut to them. Is there more to it than that ? Tesla is getting approval to make a car road legal. An insurance company may underwrite insurance for various purposes including taxi. Why do I need tesla's permissions to combine a road legal car for taxi purposes ?
Re:Tesla Autopilot by grkvlt on Tuesday June 20, 2017 @08:57PM (#14599818)
Because Tesla is assuming responsibility (that is, guaranteeing fitness for purpose, and all the ramifications that come with that) for the car being able to drive you under the same circumstances as any other private person driving. They would be taking on much more (legal, insurance, etc.) risk if they were to allow the car to drive as a passenger carrying, fare accepting, commercial entity, therefore it seems fair that they require you to use their managed system to (I assume) mitigate and/or manage that risk. I would guess that it would also be possible, eventually, to license the autopilot software for your own arbitrary commercial use.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by djloche on Monday June 19, 2017 @12:39PM (#14588260)
The line is "software provided by the manufacturer is driving" vs "person is driving".

When you cede control of the steering, braking, acceleration, and even watching the road to software, you are no longer driving.

Re:Tesla Autopilot by bubblethink on Wednesday June 21, 2017 @01:41AM (#14600967)
This has been happening slowly in a lot of areas already. We went from manual transmission to automatic transmission without much fanfare. Even with the current self-driving trend, it is happening pretty slowly with various assisted technologies. I doubt things will change overnight.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by castratikron on Saturday June 17, 2017 @12:57AM (#14574344)
How is this any different than Microsoft restricting Home versions of Office for non-business use? They've been getting away with that for decades now.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by wilhil on Saturday June 17, 2017 @03:48AM (#14574787)
Because when you buy software, you know you are renting it - you technically can reverse engineer/decompile, copy, clone, resell - but you know you shouldn't.

If I buy a car and want to take the engine out, or a light and resell it - I would be very stupid, but, it is my property and I should be able to.

If Tesla want to lend instead of sell you something - fine, just be honest!

Re:Tesla Autopilot by pxndx on Saturday June 17, 2017 @03:56AM (#14574811)
Why is there a difference between sowtware and the car? Didn't you also pay for the software?
Re:Tesla Autopilot by quotemstr on Saturday June 17, 2017 @04:06AM (#14574839)
A functioning commercial regulatory apparatus would not allow vendors to call the practice of providing encumbered software licenses in exchange for money by the term "selling software". That we put to with this practice, which basically lives on consumer confusion, is a bug.

It's a lot like our allowing people to sell patent medicines as "supplements". In both cases, we let people distort the meaning of regular words for commercial gain.

Re:Tesla Autopilot by thanksgiving on Saturday June 17, 2017 @11:47AM (#14576361)
Copyright is a very stupid concept. Just because we benefit from it doesn't mean that we should support it until the end of time. Perhaps we should start taking about getting rid of copyright.

Now, I'm not saying we get rid of all laws. End of copyright will not allow me to put a maliciously crafted copy of Microsoft Windows or Google chrome online in order to deceive users into thinking they are genuine. I still may not misrepresent when I copy things. In fact, I think these laws need strengthening which we can if we ditch copyright.

Re:Tesla Autopilot by z92 on Saturday June 17, 2017 @04:11AM (#14574856)
He said the payment was more like a rent than gaining full ownership, as in a car.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by atupem on Saturday June 17, 2017 @04:32AM (#14574907)
In this case the software you're renting is the self driving capability.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by mtgx on Saturday June 17, 2017 @04:15AM (#14574863)
Vehicle makers are already starting to make that argument, that because they own the software, you can't do anything to the car without their permission:

https://www.wired.com/2015/04/dmca-ownership-john-deere/

Re:Tesla Autopilot by smitherfield on Saturday June 17, 2017 @01:18AM (#14574410)
Well, for one, a car is a physical object; you can't near-instantaneously create an arbitrary number of exact duplicates of your car.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by kyberias on Saturday June 17, 2017 @01:50AM (#14574491)
Why would that - whether it's physical or not - determine what kind of licenses you can attach to the product?
Re:Tesla Autopilot by smitherfield on Saturday June 17, 2017 @02:35AM (#14574601)
When you buy a car, the title is signed over to you, and you become its owner. Microsoft Office is information that Microsoft agrees to share with you subject to certain restrictions on your use of it. To actually purchase Microsoft Office the intellectual property, as opposed to a license for it, would cost you about 9 orders of magnitude more.

They're also restricting their customers' actions in meatspace (you can't drive people around in exchange for money) while the Office restrictions (you can't create business-related files) are IP-related.

A more accurate analogy would be if Microsoft banned you from using a Surface for business purposes (or for business purposes while running Windows, but it's impossible to install a different OS).

IANAL so I don't know if Tesla is on solid legal ground (I would guess that probably they are), but I think there's certainly a clear philosophical distinction.

Re:Tesla Autopilot by ErikHuisman on Saturday June 17, 2017 @04:15AM (#14574865)
tesla is restricting the autopilot software not the car itself
Re:Tesla Autopilot by falcolas on Saturday June 17, 2017 @10:17AM (#14575982)
Given that the car can not operate at all without the software enabled (and not just Autopilot, as Tesla has demonstrated with salvage title cars), this is a distinction without a difference.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by georgemcbay on Saturday June 17, 2017 @01:01AM (#14574356)
Well it isn't currently clear that they do. Tesla can write whatever they want into the car version of a EULA, but it doesn't mean there is legal merit to any of it.

Assuming Tesla eventually "catches" someone using a Tesla for ride sharing profit outside of their network they could remotely disable the car, at which point they will surely be sued and the courts will decide.

And they will very likely decide against Tesla, IMO. The immediate reaction to this statement is bound to cause people who work purely in the software realm to protest, but to most courts software is still a very nebulous thing. Disabling someone's car (after selling it to them outright) because they did something with it that you didn't like is EASY to understand, anathema to the entire history of car ownership and I really don't think it'll fly.

Re:Tesla Autopilot by barrkel on Saturday June 17, 2017 @04:32AM (#14574908)
If a court rules against the person who has the risk from controlling the risk, they will get themselves out of that situation. That will either mean changing the law, changing to a lease model and ceasing sales, or stop selling self driving at all.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by MarkMc on Saturday June 17, 2017 @02:19AM (#14574561)
Tesla: We can't place restrictions on fully owned vehicles? OK, from now on we don't sell cars - we rent them for 50 years. Now can we place restrictions?
Re:Tesla Autopilot by goodplay on Saturday June 17, 2017 @02:58AM (#14574656)
I personally find this to be better and more honest. If we as customers don't own something, companies shouldn't use words like "your" and "ownership" to mislead people.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by quotemstr on Saturday June 17, 2017 @03:55AM (#14574807)
+1. Even if there's no difference in practice, at least a long lease signifies unusual restrictions. Makers of big heavy pieces of industrial equipment also sometimes offer only long leases and never sales.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by ant6n on Saturday June 17, 2017 @09:39AM (#14575845)
Presumably you're allowed to destroy the Tesla you own - which wouldn't be true with a long term rental, you'd have to give that back.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by elmigranto on Saturday June 17, 2017 @12:49AM (#14574329)
Software-like licenses make their way to hardware world. I wonder how soon we'll start seeing "as is" and "no guarantees of any kind" clauses…
Re:Tesla Autopilot by erikpukinskis on Saturday June 17, 2017 @12:54AM (#14574339)
I mean... Autopilot is software, right?
Re:Tesla Autopilot by sjwright on Saturday June 17, 2017 @01:57AM (#14574508)
If you consider that the hardware is entirely comprised of third-party commodity parts* then yes, whatever it is that makes Autopilot a distinct product/proposition is entirely software.

* It's all really just off-the-shelf cameras, sensors, processors etc sourced from various suppliers. Of course we should acknowledge that the validation and alignment of these parts plays an important role, but there's not really any secret sauce there.

Re:Tesla Autopilot by elmigranto on Saturday June 17, 2017 @02:25AM (#14574577)
I wouldn't say that. It certainly not exclusively software and I don't think it is honest to divide a system like that into "soft" and "hard" components, since neither one has value for customer on its own.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by jyrkesh on Saturday June 17, 2017 @03:07AM (#14574679)
Really? You don't see this as any different than iOS running on an iPhone? I can't use the iOS license on any other device, I can't run binaries on the device outside of what's available on the App Store. I'm wholly restricted to their rules on both the hardware and software sides of things.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by elmigranto on Saturday June 17, 2017 @03:51AM (#14574795)
I don't get what's the disagreement here. Apple sells you a whole system, iPhone + iOS. They don't sell you two things, like in PC world, for example, and that's different and that's okay as long as everyone is upfront about it.

What I am saying is that Apple sells you a product. You own it. You can do whatever you want with it. Feel free to alter any part of it, just don't expect it to work or keep your warrantee. The fact the product has limitations out of the box is a different matter. (Kind of like no one complains that kitchen timer can't boil water, or doesn't have nanoseconds precision — you want those things, you buy a different thing or make your own.)

What Apple doesn't do is to restrict you in how you use their product. There's no such thing like "you can only non-commercially photograph your family" or "never resell your iPhone", or "detaching screen is illegal".

And, more importantly, there is nothing Apple can do to stop you from doing any of those things.

Re:Tesla Autopilot by elmigranto on Saturday June 17, 2017 @04:01AM (#14574823)
In a nutshell, the difference is "sell" vs "license", "own" vs "rent".

You own your iPhone and you rent your Tesla Autopilot it seems.

Re:Tesla Autopilot by quotemstr on Saturday June 17, 2017 @04:10AM (#14574851)
People try these shenanigans every generation or so. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine
Re:Tesla Autopilot by barrkel on Saturday June 17, 2017 @04:27AM (#14574892)
It's not going to work, things will change or we will have no self driving cars. There must be someone who's liable, and that person will be the corporation that wrote the software. That in turn will mean restrictions; the software must be updated on a timely basis, and the risk to the company must be controlled in an actuarial sense just like vehicle insurance.

Vehicle insurance like today can't be used because incentives aren't aligned. Fully self-driving cars will come with an insurance package, and the company will need to control its insurable risk, or there will be no self-driving cars at all. If it's against the law, the law will change, not the model.

I'm sorry, but society will demand it. You will not and cannot have full ownership control over a self-driving car.

Re:Tesla Autopilot by raldi on Saturday June 17, 2017 @01:20AM (#14574415)
It does seem a bit like having to pay extra for pencils if they're being used for commercial purposes.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by lifeformed on Saturday June 17, 2017 @05:20AM (#14575018)
I wonder if it's to prevent the following scenario in the future, where the self-driving capabilities are perfect and legal: rich people buy as many Model 3's as possible, and deploy their own taxi fleet. Each one pays itself off in 4-6 months (est ~$15/hr, can operate 24/7), and generate lots of passive income forever.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by EmielMols on Saturday June 17, 2017 @06:06AM (#14575125)
This is not how markets work. Once the "self-driving capabilities are perfect and legal":

- investing in such a fleet would be like investing in any other kind of business: it's easier if you have the money, but if not you can go to any bank and get a loan.

- prices for a trip with a self-driving taxi will drop immensely, this is probably going to be a big liability if you would start the aforementioned business

- other effects that I can't think of right now

It is true that in a lot of places rich people have an edge on the less-wealthy (it's easier getting/staying rich if you are rich), but that's more of a generic problem than something that would be amplified by change to self-driving cars.

Re:Tesla Autopilot by thejerz on Saturday June 17, 2017 @10:57AM (#14576150)
No one is forcing you to buy the car. If you don't like the terms of the license, don't buy it.
Re:Tesla Autopilot by dsfyu404ed on Saturday June 17, 2017 @11:04AM (#14576178)
Do you work for Deere or something? That's exactly the opinion that most people are against when applied to hardware as evidenced by the support (among people aware of them) for "right to repair" movements.

The "you don't actually own the hardware you paid for" model is slowly becoming untenable for hardware sold to individuals.