If Telegram isn't that secure, then why are extremists like IS using it over Signal or WhatsApp? I know Telegram has better features for big groups and much better multi-platform support, so is that the reason? I'm legitimately asking without any snark.
I am talking about politicians, head of terrorist groups, etc.
While saying that top politicians are complete idiots is probably wrong - then again maybe not, I am not sure anymore - the fact that H. Clinton, run the most expensive campaign in history, with backing from all major tech corps AND her staff didn't bother to use encryption at any scale, let alone running a mail server (God knows what kind of software the server was running if it was OpenBSD or Windows Server 08), to me says a lot about how flawed the understanding of these people and their consultant's is about today's world.
Watching "House of Cards" everybody seems incredibly smart, driven, etc. but the politicians I see in real life on average and on the not-very-smart side and the few I've met in person are clueless beyond salvation.
Ps. Sorry for possible mistakes, I'm reading from mobile.
Sadly, one of the conclusions you can draw from Telegram is that a security business is almost better off with no security.
Pavel Durov says that Telegram is "heavily" encrypted over and over again, journalists who don't know better take that at face value and encode it into every headline ("Telegram, the encrypted messaging app, ..."), and meanwhile since there is no encryption there is no risk of anyone finding or publishing vulnerabilities in it.
Since cryptography already seems unreal to most people (and is always just a matter of getting the smart IT guy to 'crack' it on television), everyone's already predisposed to thinking that security = Switzerland. Unless there's a major change, the charlatans will win every time.
Also, is there evidence that extremists aren't using Signal and WhatsApp?
WhatsApp and Signal offer non-anonymous groups only. They are probably used by people who already know each other.
Anyone who has used Telegram for more than 5 minutes knows there are secret chats. The effort being made to rig the information against Telegram also tells a lot about its relevance.
The telegram desktop main developer said[4]: "Well, I'm afraid there isn't. They are just not in high priority, many other important things first."
It seems stickers, funny bots and GIFs have more priority over security. I think this tells a lot.
[1]: https://github.com/telegramdesktop/tdesktop/issues/871
[2]: https://github.com/zhukov/webogram/issues/126
[3]: https://github.com/vysheng/tg/issues/1189
[4]: https://www.reddit.com/r/Telegram/comments/2z24ly/how_to_sta...
Secret chats are not enabled by default, and most users don't enable them; so yes, messages are generally stored without encryption on the Telegram servers. That's a more neutral way of presenting the information.
I think his point is the reverse, while people trust Signal because of Moxie & Trevp.
puts Tinfoil hat it's possible that Trevp is not "that" involved with Signal because he doesn't want to be involved with the government and backdoors.
The point of all of this should be that it's not about people, places, or jurisdictions. If you make it about that, the charlatans who want you to think that Switzerland = secure will win every time.
They don't. From the Telegram FAQ:
"Cloud chats are stored encrypted in the Telegram Cloud, and the keys needed to decipher this data are kept in other data centers in different jurisdictions. This way, local intruders or engineers can't access this data, and several court orders from different jurisdictions are required to force us to give up anything. Thanks to this structure, we can ensure that no single government or block of like-minded countries can intrude on people's privacy and freedom of expression."[1]
They want people to think like that because they've built businesses that require it. Telegram stores the messages you send/receive unencrypted on their servers. That's not good, unless you've been trained to think that "privacy" is just about choosing the company, government, or legal jurisdiction that gets total access to your data.
Security professionals know that's not how we should think about security (never trust people!), because Durov is leaving a lot out: there aren't safe jurisdictions, servers get hacked, and centralized databases will get compromised. Logic, though, is probably no match for conspiracy theories.
1: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-intersect/wp/2015/11...