Re:Oliver Byrne's edition of Euclid
by wyclif on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @05:54PM
(#1453318)
I submitted this because I've been poking around in my Dover edition of Euclid. Then, yesterday, I found this site. To me it's like what Edward Tufte would do if he published Euclid (Byrne was a 19th-century civil engineer and surveyor from Ireland).
To my delight, I noticed that Taschen has republished this wonderful edition, so I ordered it from Amazon and I'm now awaiting delivery so I can peruse it, enjoy it, and keep it for my children's future math education:
Re:Oliver Byrne's edition of Euclid
by Alex63 on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @05:58PM
(#1453331)
Doesn't Tufte in fact use Byrne's graphic proof of the Pythagorean Theorem in one his books? If I were at home I could check, but I think it's in Visual Explanations.
Re:Oliver Byrne's edition of Euclid
by zbyszek on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @07:08AM
(#1454609)
I used to have facsimile editions of Defoe's novels, replete with these long s's, and found that the unfamiliarity soon fades and you cease to notice them.
Re:Oliver Byrne's edition of Euclid
by petercooper on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @06:27PM
(#1453434)
Last week I received the new TASCHEN print of Byrne's Six Books of Euclid. It is gorgeous and considered a "facsimile" of the original. It comes in a box with a separate "behind the scenes" book.
Re:Oliver Byrne's edition of Euclid
by petercooper on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @08:04PM
(#1453649)
I only bought it because someone on Twitter remarked at how nice it was.. it seems to be a very "viral" book in that way. One look at it, and you wanna buy it (even if you actually don't).
Re:Oliver Byrne's edition of Euclid
by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @06:46AM
(#1454591)
Annoyingly the web preview is in color, but the PDF download is black and white only.
Actually, on closer inspection the download is missing many of the larger diagrams completely for some reason, while others are rendered without color.
Re:Oliver Byrne's edition of Euclid
by pvg on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @08:25PM
(#1453686)
It's both beautiful and meticulous. Its aesthetic merits aside, I am fairly skeptical the presentation actually offers any improved elucidation of or insight into The Elements
Re:Oliver Byrne's edition of Euclid
by ppereira on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @02:51AM
(#1454303)
I've been tutoring Euclid to a Gr. 6 student. I gave him both the Heath and Byrne editions to work from but he has a much easier time with the Byrne, primarily because the proofs appear much shorter. The coloured pictures strip out an entire layer of pointer dereferencing.
Re:Oliver Byrne's edition of Euclid
by zb on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @08:45PM
(#1453728)
If you compare Byrne's version side-by-side with another (as Tufte does in Envisioning Information) then I think you'll agree that it's much easier to follow.
Re:Oliver Byrne's edition of Euclid
by Adaptive on Wednesday June 23, 2010 @12:06AM
(#1454081)
Agreed. Having worked through Euclid with letters (in class, often out loud, mind you, so that may skew my imagination here) I really cannot imagine that colors enhance the process at all. I wouldn't be against colors in addition to letters, but colors alone, despite the superficial aesthetic appeal, seems nutty.
To my delight, I noticed that Taschen has republished this wonderful edition, so I ordered it from Amazon and I'm now awaiting delivery so I can peruse it, enjoy it, and keep it for my children's future math education:
http://www.amazon.com/Six-Books-Euclid-Werner-Oechslin/dp/38...
See for example spreads, etc: http://www.taschen.com/pages/en/catalogue/classics/all/06724...
Actually, on closer inspection the download is missing many of the larger diagrams completely for some reason, while others are rendered without color.
Compare, side by site
http://sunsite.ubc.ca/DigitalMathArchive/Euclid/bookI/images...
and the drab
http://aleph0.clarku.edu/~djoyce/java/elements/bookI/propI1....