News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by ugh123 on Friday June 09, 2017 @03:29PM (#14523775)
>They didn't share what was in his check but it wasn't good.

Always ask to see the background check details if you're the hiring manager (you should have the rights to see that despite what HR might tell you). Could be just a personal issue an HR employee might have with a former colleague. Or discrimination-based (happens).

Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by Gibbon1 on Friday June 09, 2017 @05:29PM (#14524731)
Reminds me one of my old bosses hired someone. And then HR fired them because they had a pot conviction. So then my boss hired them as an outside contractor. Every six months HR would discover he was on the 'no hire list' and terminate his contract and my boss would cut him a new contract.
Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by walshemj on Saturday June 10, 2017 @08:19AM (#14527071)
Reminds me when I worked a big telcom (BT) on of the guys in our section was an ex teenage Phreak and had been done for hacking PRESTEL.

One day one of the feared internal security team who had caught him years ago was in the building and met him and freaked out - our centre mangers politely told him to f off when he demanded that we fire the guy.

Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by walshemj on Saturday June 10, 2017 @08:21AM (#14527078)
Was not the manger involved in the hearing in most big companies its the mangers who make the firing decision with input from HR.
Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by pkaye on Saturday June 10, 2017 @12:22AM (#14526153)
HR doesn't need to approve of contractors?
Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by valuearb on Saturday June 10, 2017 @01:33PM (#14528242)
In a good company, HR has as little authority as possible.
Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by 65827 on Saturday June 10, 2017 @01:57PM (#14528335)
Yeah let me guess this dude was white. Unbelievable, the world must be so different in that skin.
Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by Gibbon1 on Tuesday June 13, 2017 @01:13AM (#14542964)
My boss was French.

Socially Adept Frenchman: 1 Human Resources: 0

Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by tptacek on Friday June 09, 2017 @05:16PM (#14524657)
I'm not sure what you're referring to. If you mean a formal background check, which summarizes your criminal history or your credit history, then candidates are entitled to copies of the specific report the company claims to rely on in taking an adverse action, but nothing else.

If you're referring to private reference checks, of the type that would surface "personal issues people might have with formal colleagues", you're not entitled to anything whatsoever.

If you're a hiring manager in an organization where HR handles background checks, you personally as the hiring manager are entitled to nothing. I would venture further that it's inappropriate for HR to provide criminal/credit background check information to hiring managers.

Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by WhitneyLand on Friday June 09, 2017 @08:42PM (#14525599)
>you [as] the hiring manager are entitled to nothing

You mean in any kind of practical or legal sense or in your personal opinion?

I see this happen all the time and am not aware of any thing barring this in the U.S.

Think about the two extremes. If a startup of a few people run a background check there is no HR dept so the CEO/hiring manager is seeing it.

On the other hand if the hiring manager is the CEO at an F500 company trying to hire a handpicked rockstar exec and a background check pops there no way that person will be rejected only on the word of HR without understanding what the issue is and the context around it.

Somewhere in the middle of those extremes companies may have policies to address the situation, but I don't see how any blanket statement can be made here.

Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by tptacek on Saturday June 10, 2017 @02:24AM (#14526375)
I asked the author what they meant, and then laid out what the facts are. It's simple:

* Candidates are entitled to copies of background/credit reports used to make adverse decisions against them, under the FCRA.

* Candidates are only entitled to the specific document, collected under the FCRA, that was used to make the adverse decision.

* Reference checks --- calls to previous employers and coworkers --- are not governed by the FCRA or, as far as I know, any other law. Candidates are absolutely not entitled to any information about reference checks, but a candidate that "flunks" a reference check might be told so when they're refused a job. Or they might not.

* No law entitles hiring managers to any documentation whatsoever.

Only the last point I made was one of opinion, but I think it's a widely held and pretty common sense opinion:

It is terribly inappropriate for HR to share background check documentation with hiring managers. Companies that employ background checks should have simple, static rules, like "no previously undisclosed felonies" or "no violations relevant to the job", that are evaluated by HR.

It's already a grave violation of candidate privacy to do these kinds of checks in the first place (which is why they have to collect special permission from candidates to do them at all!). It's negligent to then pass that information around the org chart to help others in the company read tea leaves from them.

My opinion here is informed by experience working with companies that do background checks, but I wouldn't be surprised to learn that there are fucked up companies where HR passes copies of credit and background reports to other employees.

Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by justin66 on Saturday June 10, 2017 @11:49AM (#14527758)
> It's already a grave violation of candidate privacy to do these kinds of checks in the first place

True, but in general, it is likely that whatever a background check turns up on someone, such that they're unemployable, is probably available to anyone with a web browser and some time on their hands. The people in the org who want to satisfy their curiosity or sense of self importance as to why someone didn't meet the company's standards can probably find a way to do it.

The reason one really shouldn't what to see this info at all if they can help it (and should have a trustworthy HR office handle this stuff) is that pretty much everything done in the hiring process can be used later on in court. The safest possible position for a hiring manager if the question comes up is "HR indicated the candidate did not pass our background check and so we moved on." And only an idiot wants to answer questions later on about with whom they shared damaging information about a candidate.

Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by WhitneyLand on Saturday June 10, 2017 @07:56AM (#14527025)
Well, the thing is sharing background issues is not limited to rogue or obscure companies. For example if you search the archives of WSJ it comes up reliably at some well known places.

To be clear I don't think a lot of this stuff is right. It drives me nuts to see someone ace technical interviews and then not be hired for some insignificant drug related issue. How do companies not realize this probably hurts them more than the candidate? A lot of tech companies don't do drug tests at all, I'm guessing because they've figured this part out.

Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by walshemj on Saturday June 10, 2017 @08:05AM (#14527042)
Its not the law here HR is working for you as the hiring manger so dam right I want to see the docs - and BTW I have more experience in IR/HR issues than many junior HR.
Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by valuearb on Saturday June 10, 2017 @01:47PM (#14528295)
HR is there to serve the organization, not the other way around.

If you are trying to hire a talented employee, and HR says no way, you better demand they justify it. It's your job to advocate for people on your team, even when they haven't come on board yet. Otherwise no one will.

It's far to easy for HR to auto-reject because of hard-wired criteria, they have no incentive to challenge their own rules for a good candidate.

I know a kid who once was a chip-runner at a casino. The way the job worked was he took cash/chips from poker players and went to the cage to get them chips/cash. He got paid minimum wage plus tips, and was on the hook if he got shorted. But the plus was he'd get $1 tip for each transaction, sometimes more.

But this kid optimized the whole job. He hustled like crazy, minimized cage trips by carrying 7 or 8 racks at a time, and even took optimal routes through the poker room. Watching him work was inspiring, the kid was so driven.

He was making a ton of money, far more than the other chip-runners, and someone ended up complaining. So the room decided chip-runners should pool all tips together. He quit in a rage the next day and chip-running service in the room became awful, the remaining chip-runners now saunter at their own pace, carry a single rack at a time and minimize their risk by slowly counting everything three times.

A couple years later the kid got busted for selling weed out of his house. He ended up serving a few years in prison. He's going to now fail any HR background check/screen. I'd still hire him in a fucking second, and expect him to rapidly work his way up from any entry level role.

Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by pvg on Saturday June 10, 2017 @07:11PM (#14529727)
One of the reasons I doubt any sane HR department would hand a hiring manager the results of something like a criminal background check is precisely to protect the organization.
Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by yardie on Friday June 09, 2017 @03:33PM (#14523817)
Didn't know I could do that.

I've had my own background checks in the past and no one has shared them with me. Speaking to HR, unless there is a negative item on your record they aren't required to.

Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by Ralfp on Friday June 09, 2017 @06:04PM (#14524955)
In EU even something like recruiter scribbling notes over your printed CV during job interview automatically grants you right to look into them as it is considered personal data processing.
Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by marzell on Friday June 09, 2017 @03:37PM (#14523838)
If the background check was done on you, I believe they have to provide a copy of all the data they received if you request it.
Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by pionar on Saturday June 10, 2017 @07:48AM (#14527015)
At least at the federal level, no they don't. Unless they decided not to hire you (or fired you afterwards). Then they only have to provide "a notice that includes a copy of the consumer report you relied on to make your decision" - https://www.eeoc.gov/eeoc/publications/background_checks_emp...
Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by yardie on Saturday June 10, 2017 @01:50PM (#14528302)
I've requested it, just for my own amusement. They told me no. Unless they didn't hire me based on something from that background check they didn't have to give it to you.
Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by twohlix_ on Friday June 09, 2017 @04:46PM (#14524417)
Depends on the state.
Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by PhasmaFelis on Friday June 09, 2017 @03:53PM (#14523967)
> Didn't know I could do that.

o_O

Why would you assume you couldn't?

Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by cperciva on Saturday June 10, 2017 @10:18AM (#14527409)
Discrimination is exactly why you want to leave that decision in the hands of HR. In the event of a lawsuit they'll have evidence to show that they followed the process your lawyers signed off upon and the decision to say "no hire" was based solely on permissible factors. At large companies, this will go as far as "here's a database dump of all the applicants with X on their criminal record... as you can see, we didn't hire any of them".

As soon as individual managers want to make those decisions for themselves, it becomes much harder to refute claims of discrimination.

Re:Verelox Wiped by Ex-Admin by valuearb on Saturday June 10, 2017 @01:54PM (#14528326)
That's a terrible policy. You need to optimize for getting the best employees, not minimizing discrimination complaints. How often is a felon going to sue because the company once made an exception for a specific felon because of specific outside factors, and how can that cost you any suit?

"Your honor, my client, the recently released child rapist with an iffy work record, is suing because BigCorp says they normally don't hire felons, but a few years ago BigCorp made an exception for a felon who sold marijuana, got his college degree in prison, then after he was released worked at non-profits helping the poor while getting an advanced degree in computer technology and writing several highly regarded academic papers on improving user interfaces for the disabled. That's not fair!"

The specific facts matter, and HR should be fired if they have blanket polices that ignore them. HR needs to serve the business, not the other way round.