News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by camus2 on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @01:34PM (#14508266)
But that's what exciting about science. It doesn't claim to come with ready made answers about our surroundings, humans discover things on their own.

Sometimes humans get things wrong, and there is no shame in being wrong with science, it's part of the process, unlike "other domains" where people can or will never admin they are wrong, while still using the product of science every day, in contradiction to their own "science".

Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by dang on Friday June 09, 2017 @04:22PM (#14524216)
Please let's not have generic science vs. religion threads (a.k.a. flamewars, because that's what they turn into). This comment wasn't so bad, but it predictably led to much worse because it's impossible to say new or substantive things about anything so generic.

We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14508125 and marked it off-topic.

Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by jansho on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @01:53PM (#14508437)
I don't know, the inability to admit being wrong is a human trait and can apply to anyone, including scientists and believers.

Why does everyone think that there's only two "origin" stories and they're both mutually exclusive? I believe in evolution, and I'm a monotheist. I don't reach this conclusion very easily. Why not evolution as God's* way of creating things.

*I hesitate to use this word because of the baggage it carries, but somehow Designer or Creator doesn't seem sufficient here...

Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by nkrisc on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @02:52PM (#14508908)
Why not evolution as "God's" way of creating things? Well, why not anything? You can posit anything you want, can you test it? Is there evidence to support it?

Why monotheist? How do you know for certain there aren't more gods? How did you arrive at that conclusion? Can you test it? Could you admit your belief in monotheism could possibly be mistaken?

We can ask "why not anything?" all day and not get anywhere so it's more worthwhile to focus on the things for which evidence can actually be gathered. Evolution is testable and there exists much evidence of it occurring in the past. The other origin, not so much.

Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by jansho on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @04:24PM (#14509586)
Well,

"Why not" is one way to keep an open mind. Why not this world in a multiverse. Why not this world in a simulation. Why not a simulation within a simulation. Why not a programmer who wrote the code for this world - and how is this any stranger than our other what ifs.

We're human, we don't just operate on facts - we rely on educated assumptions that we make, some of which may be strong enough to translate into belief. This may be driven by evidence, or just our humanly intuition and experiences.

But this is also human: The beauty of science is that it adapts as new evidence is revealed - someone here said this earlier. [No final answer] but rather based on the current evidence, an answer can be formulated that is consistent with the evidence available at that time.

It's human because it depends on our perspective; where we are in time, whether we find the truths (evidence) or not, and whether we are capable of perceiving all truths. Science is continually evolving in our minds - or more accurately, in the collective minds over time. Can the great jigsaw puzzle ever be solved? That's not the aim of science, as it is proud to point out, but it argues that whatever picture we come up with, it's justified as long as it's based on the current collection of evidence - this is a philosophy.

And I'm personally not satisfied with this, as a way of life. Why don't I deserve the truth in its entirety, in my lifetime? You would ask, why do I even question whether I deserve or not? I guess it's a human thing. But for me, as a person, I intuit closest to monotheism. Monotheism provides a framework where anything is possible, but bound by the belief in the Great Programmer who can do whatever he wants. It can work for anyone, regardless of their time and place; and for me as a person fortunate to live in an advanced age, I can accept evolution, because I think it's pretty robust and who am I to question how he creates the world. This for me is more liberating than having to accept whatever picture current evidence is showing - actually, I look forward to witness more development. It's also quite a comfortable position to be in; if science does show that we live in a simulation, that's OK, if it shows that we live in a multiverse, that's cool too.

Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by arunix on Thursday June 08, 2017 @07:58AM (#14513473)
I used to be a monotheist and found the certainty it provided quite reassuring. It took a lot of time and contemplation in order to move beyond that, but now I'm quite comfortable to live with the uncertainty resulting from a non-faith outlook.

There are even some traditions that acknowledge the uncertainty of what we know e.g. [1]

But, after all, who knows, and who can say Whence it all came, and how creation happened? the gods themselves are later than creation, so who knows truly whence it has arisen?

Whence all creation had its origin, he, whether he fashioned it or whether he did not, he, who surveys it all from highest heaven, he knows - or maybe even he does not know.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nasadiya_Sukta

Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by Myrmornis on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @04:59PM (#14509826)
The thing is it's just not very interesting what you "intuit". You're free to do it, but it's of no consequence. Some things that are interesting are (1) observations of reality that allow us to choose among competing hypotheses for how reality works and what has happened in reality, and (2) such testable hypotheses.
Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by jansho on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @06:02PM (#14510219)
If there is a god, of course there are consequences. (This opens up another mess of a rabbit hole so I'll stop here!)

You're right, I "intuit" it because it's unifying and seems to cover all bases, and therefore quite a comfortable position to be in. I also "intuit" it because of the vast indescribable complexity of this world, and it's not just the equations but the thrill, humility and beauty of it all is too much that I have to accept that it doesn't just happen.

But in my earlier point, I wanted to show that a belief in a 'Great Programmer' is not incompatible with a belief in science. I am free to be interested in those two things you mentioned, but I can also attribute the wonders to a god. In a way this is like enjoying an unfinished picture/ story, but knowing how the thread begins and ends: everything comes from him, and everything returns to him. It's like sitting in the privileged seat to witness a slice of this drama. And for me, the least I can do is to acknowledge the great auteur behind it.

Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by nkrisc on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @05:59PM (#14510201)
That's great but it doesn't prove anything. You're free to believe anything you like, or anything you intuit, but that has no bearing on whether it's true or not.

So, the reason I find those two origin stories can't coexist? Simply because there is no evidence to suggest one of them is remotely true. It's nothing personal. I too believe many things, but I'm happy to admit I may very well be wrong. Call them operating assumptions.

Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by jansho on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @06:21PM (#14510313)
Yes but see, the same uncertainty also goes to you. Evidence may paint a picture, but evidence is also continuously fluid so there is never a correct picture. A more accurate picture, possibly. But even so, we're not just ruled by rational thinking. Even scientists are driven by a thing called wonder and curiosity - you need those facilities together to make progress. Call intuition as one tool to take advantage of.

But hey I may be wrong too. There's no telling unless He says "Game's up, now who amongst you could see me." I admit that there is that fear in me, but as I explained in another child post, I just can't put down the super complexity and beauty of this world to a chance.

(If my tone seems condescending, I apologise as this is not in my intention at all.)

Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by nkrisc on Thursday June 08, 2017 @01:07PM (#14515495)
Of course I can only be as certain as the evidence we have. I also know that our understanding will probably evolve and change and we learn new information.

As for chance? Well, for every Earth (only one we know of) there are (as far as we know) billions of dead planets. After billions and billions of dead planets I'm perfectly will to accept that one with life is just chance.

Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by jansho on Friday June 09, 2017 @04:16AM (#14519956)
That's not the only chance though. It's a chance within a chance within so many other chances over many, many years, from the moment the Big Bang happened.

For sure our knowledge will grow, but I am not so sure if this will apply to our understanding. Yet the more we know, the more we seem we don't know!

Hey thanks for letting me indulge in this thread, I was hoping to test my thoughts and learn something new (I did) :)

Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by boneheadmed on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @07:14PM (#14510619)
Unfortunately, you can't test evolution in the same way that you can test for example if an artificial organ will function in an animal. You can only speculate about the past.
Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by roywiggins on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @03:40PM (#14509295)
The current Pope is cool with evolution. I think this is a common view, especially among religious scientists. Only some people think evolution is incompatible with divine creation.
Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by eric_the_read on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @07:21PM (#14510653)
Not that you're wrong, but this isn't exactly news. St Augustine, back in the late 4th century/early 5th, was "cool" with evolution, if you care to use those words:

"Th[e] tree surely did not spring forth suddenly in [a mature] size and form, but rather went through a process of growth with which we are familiar. …[It] took its shape as it [gradually] developed with all its parts. … One [form of tree] comes from the other [form of tree], therefore, in succession, but both come from earth and not earth from them. Earth, then, is prior and is their source. The same is true of animals." (http://www.historyandapologetics.com/2015/02/st-augustine-on...)

While he didn't think that a new genus could arise in this way, he was pretty clearly on the right track, especially given the rather sketchy knowledge on the subject of biology in his day.

Re:Oldest Fossils of Homo Sapiens Found in Morocco by davidw on Wednesday June 07, 2017 @02:10PM (#14508571)
Science is about stuff that is falsifiable.