Ask HN: Review my startup - Social gaming framework for Android, iPhone
The server infrastructure is hosted at Amazon EC2 which greatly simplifies the dynamic scaling of the network. Gameserver instances are created via a web-interface and provide detailled statistics about the games, the players and the connections (including a real-time display of active users). Our plan is to charge based on the used resources, trying to make a very good offer for indie devs in particular.
Recently we've started private beta phase with the Android implementation, and will soon support more platforms. The first developers have deployed games on the Android market using the framework; everything works great and we are as excited as the devs are! It feels like a great moment to tell the HN community about the project - and to ask for feedback in particular.
Thanks!
http://www.flockengine.com
At one point, we were planning to open source our gaming framework and build business around server-side functionality. However, after various discussions, I finally abandoned that plan and we are focusing to use it internally.
First, in games particular, considerable amount of work is spent on the client side. Unless you are super-successful to encounter serious scalability issues, all the hard problems are on the client-side.
Although gaming companies do not currently have that much back-end guys, they still have quite capable coders in general, who can learn back-end stuff quite easily. Thus, you really need to provide significant value to them (us). Looking through your APIs, you currently have solved some basic authentication stuff. That's okay as a start but definitely not enough to attract skilled teams.
Second, game business is very hit-driven, thus you are likely to serve the less-profitable long tail developers. The best offering for them is not to provide server-side technology per se, but bring more buyers/players for their games. Thus, approach that e.g. OpenFeint has taken seem to serve those guys better, they basically are offering the stuff that you offer + the existing community.
But best luck! I suggest that you talk to experienced game studios. Find out what are the biggest pain points and try to provide solutions to those.
EDIT: Note, I didn't want to sound discouraging, although reading it now, it definitely came out like that. I think there's definitely opportunities in this space, I just wanted quickly to highlight some key issues. Note also that it will be a very competitive space, because successful mobile multiplayer game companies can also try to enter the space with their proven propriety solutions. That's part of our long term plan, i.e. we first try to create succesful mobile multiplayer games, and then consider platform-provider option again.
OpenFeint looks pretty similar but has a primary focus on highscore and leaderboards, which is a free feature of theirs. I couldn't find out how much they charge for their turn-based multiplayer feature though. We are trying to make a good offer for small developers; for the first developers it looks like < $10 per month with around 150,000 connections.
For Android there are also a couple of highscore/leaderboard services such as ScoreLoop and ScoreNinja. We plan to provide interfaces to both and more.
Apple's GameCenter (see WWDC Session 404) will be a big "competitor" on the iOS arena, but they probably won't expand to Android or other platforms. We are starting off on Android and see where it goes from here. Flash is an interesting option too.
> Looking through your APIs, you currently have solved some basic authentication stuff. That's okay as a start but definitely not enough to attract skilled teams.
Yeah, I agree. Right now we have a MVP, and many ideas.
> But best luck! I suggest that you talk to experienced game studios. Find out what are the biggest pain points and try to provide solutions to those.
Thanks, and I agree this is the best approach right now.
First, "Flock is an easy-to-use social gaming network for Android and Iphone". I have no idea what that means. Is it a tool I download to chat with my buddies in game on iPhone? Is it something that will help me as a developper to create and publish game? Is it a kind of steam for iPhone and android?
I think the main page as too much "features" and not enough of "wtf is flock?".
Like, "Integrated encryption with SSL/TLS and AES-256".. I really don't care about the encryption you use if I'm not to use your service because I don't know what it is.
If you absolutely want to tak about security, say it in a: Flock is a secure and reliable way to blah blah.
Keep it simple!
Before: "Flock is an easy-to-use social gaming network for Android and iPhone"
Now: "Flock is the easiest way to connect users on Android and iPhone to multiplayer games."
That's really the core functionality right now. The social part is rather peripheral.
1) I'm betting on Apple's Game Center. It will be popular with developers. You need penetration--how will you compete with Apple on numbers?
2) The other reason I'm doing GC integration is that people who don't have my game can get invites from friends who do for multiplayer matches. This is huge for discoverability. You can't do that. Again, how are you going to compete?
We think developers might appreciate a "GameCenter Light" which is easy to integrate, cheap and does does the basic things right.
Discoverability is another interesting topic, and of course GC will be huge for that. I think that again it would be possible to start a light version, which offers additional exposure for developers and their games. There are many ideas that could be implemented in that direction.
From my comment you know: 1) I'm on HN, so I'm automatically sympathetic 2) I'm smack dab in the middle of your target market
That should have caused you to swing into sales mode. You're telling me what "we think [hypothetical] developers might appreciate." Hypothetical developers will never pay you any money. I might, if you can convince me not to write the GC integration code next week (Not a joke, I am actually gearing up to test a new game with it this month).
What would I do with a GC lite? In my experience (and from talking to the apple engineers at wwdc), GC looks really easy to integrate. It's also free. If your play is to do less than GC, how will you compete with free?
There are some things that GC is doing wrong. Maybe you can improve on these. But you haven't touched on anything that specifically irks me about GC yet. So I have no reason to buy in.
I do have a different angle than Flock, and I am far down the path to launching. But, my daughter just arrived at 31 weeks and my time is now happily gone.
So, good luck to you (and to myself! Heh).
Edit: the teaser site is http://PlayRelay.io
we probably will change to a better name sometime soon. suggestions are appreciated :)
I can't imagine a reason for Apple to reject such a framework, since it is really only basic socket connections with a bit of additional logic. They can't take sockets away from developers.
We recently switched from PHP to web.py and this was hopefully the last orphaned link.