We think developers might appreciate a "GameCenter Light" which is easy to integrate, cheap and does does the basic things right.
Discoverability is another interesting topic, and of course GC will be huge for that. I think that again it would be possible to start a light version, which offers additional exposure for developers and their games. There are many ideas that could be implemented in that direction.
From my comment you know: 1) I'm on HN, so I'm automatically sympathetic 2) I'm smack dab in the middle of your target market
That should have caused you to swing into sales mode. You're telling me what "we think [hypothetical] developers might appreciate." Hypothetical developers will never pay you any money. I might, if you can convince me not to write the GC integration code next week (Not a joke, I am actually gearing up to test a new game with it this month).
What would I do with a GC lite? In my experience (and from talking to the apple engineers at wwdc), GC looks really easy to integrate. It's also free. If your play is to do less than GC, how will you compete with free?
There are some things that GC is doing wrong. Maybe you can improve on these. But you haven't touched on anything that specifically irks me about GC yet. So I have no reason to buy in.
1) I'm betting on Apple's Game Center. It will be popular with developers. You need penetration--how will you compete with Apple on numbers?
2) The other reason I'm doing GC integration is that people who don't have my game can get invites from friends who do for multiplayer matches. This is huge for discoverability. You can't do that. Again, how are you going to compete?