News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by have_faith on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @01:46PM (#14454448)
Global internet ad spend superseding global TV ad spend finally. Ad-blocking as high as 26% in some countries (Germany) and rising. Looks like there is a battle for attention being waged, I wonder who will win...
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by Eerie on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @03:15PM (#14455130)
>I wonder who will win...

Ad-blocking had already won. I haven't (involuntary) seen ads for several years now. There were a few regressions here and there, but they were all fixed extremely fast. The new fancy ad-block detectors were defeated in a matter of days.

26% ad-blocking is a nice start, but the real fun begins when it is at +96%, and Google/Facebook/InsertNameHere lose their main source of income.

I think a very strong and concerted push to outlaw ad-blocking is almost inevitable, but ultimately it will be as futile as trying to outlaw the BitTorrent protocol.

Will the ad-supported crap-manufacturing eyeball factory that is the modern Internet crash and burn, leaving only Patreon to stand atop the pile of ruins?

We can but hope.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by colmvp on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @05:11PM (#14455952)
Some companies are evading it by sponsoring content. It's kind of ridiculous, but now I know companies like Square Cash, Me Undies, Parachute Sheets, Blue Apron, The Great Courses Plus, and Casper Mattress by heart because they keep sponsoring a bunch of podcasts I listen to.

I totally get that podcasts have to earn money somehow, so I'm not mad or upset, but it has been an effective way of evading my usage of Ghostery and ublock / disassociation from social media.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by threeseed on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @08:03PM (#14456887)
Fellow fan of the pod. They've done advertising really well.

I am not even American and I can also remember every single sponsor and product they've ever advertised.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by hammock on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @08:30PM (#14457008)
Only because it's new and relatively unsaturated...every new medium was the same way. When radio, TV and the internet each started running ads you could say the same thing.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by k-mcgrady on Thursday June 01, 2017 @03:49AM (#14458628)
>> Only because it's new and relatively unsaturated

Depends how long you've been listening to podcasts. There are lots of shows I listened to regularly for 3-5 years that I've completely stopped listening to because of the sheer volume of advertising (plus the fact that every week/day/episode the advertising is exactly the same). All TWiT Network shows for example are unsubscribed for me despite listening to about 10 of them and not missing an episode for years. So, in some older shows, saturation has definitely been reached. I think a lot of it is to do with necessary spending.

Podcasts are so simple to make yet people put together networks that have these high-end studios and camera systems when all they really needed was some guests, a few $100 mics and Skype.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by htormey on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @06:16PM (#14456363)
Well ad blockers dont work with native apps right? A huge number of people use facebook/googles native iOS/Android apps so this most likely won't kill their business.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by votepaunchy on Thursday June 01, 2017 @09:26AM (#14460026)
At least on iOS ad blockers are integrated into Safari so any native app using the Safari View Controller will use configured content blockers. That's why Facebook and others will continue to use the legacy web view.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by htormey on Friday June 02, 2017 @12:05PM (#14470913)
Yeah which Facebook doesn't use for rendering newsfeed ads. I'd imagine that google does the same thing for its native adverts. Also, I'd imagine that all banner adverts displayed in third party apps are native as well. Disclosure, I worked on the main Facebook app.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by MarkMc on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:33AM (#14458772)
Google Revenue:

2013 $57 billion

2014 $66 billion

2015 $74 billion

2016 $90 billion

Facebook Revenue:

2013 $8 billion

2014 $12 billion

2015 $18 billion

2016 $27 billion

If ad blocking has already won, I'm sure Google and Facebook will be happy to continue losing.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by Eerie on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:37AM (#14458796)
Ad-blocking won in a sense that it seems to be unbeatable. It is not widespread enough yet to damage Google/Facebook revenue. However, the usage of ad-blocking continues to rise exponentially, so the next few years are going to be interesting.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by johnsmith21006 on Thursday June 01, 2017 @12:09PM (#14461539)
Ad blocking is unbeatable? Can you explain? Seems to me ad blocking could be stopped if they wanted to and just not enough.

But in the end if more blocking does not the ones that are not blocked just become more valuable so does not change really anything? I mean advertising is going to continue to grow no matter what.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by real-hacker on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @11:21PM (#14457755)
Native ads will prevail. And the kinds of promotion that is blended in the content. I believe it is already happening.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by Eerie on Thursday June 01, 2017 @01:35AM (#14458219)
As long as it's recognizable as an ad, it can be blocked. If it's not, then can you even call it an ad, really? It will be, I suppose, a very sophisticated product-placement. Certainly not something you can do automatically across millions of websites. So ad-blocking still wins.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by nl on Thursday June 01, 2017 @02:52AM (#14458454)
There aren't any widely deployed AdBlockers which work on the FB mobile app, Snapchat or Instagram.

Same with the Google search app.

> So ad-blocking still wins.

FB is losing all the way to the bank at the moment.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by real-hacker on Thursday June 01, 2017 @03:27AM (#14458567)
Yes, I agree. Technically, with text classification/image recognition we can block all forms of ads, but you risk throwing out the baby with the bath water, and from my own experience, these 'plug' ads are not so repugnant, can even add an element of surprise to the content sometimes.

My point is that with adblocking tools being adopted by more users, ad platforms will perhaps begin to use this new format.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by mastazi on Thursday June 01, 2017 @02:52AM (#14458453)
> As long as it's recognizable as an ad

Are you saying that there are ad-blockers based on image recognition?

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by Eerie on Thursday June 01, 2017 @04:12AM (#14458691)
Not yet, because there is no need, so far. Here's an article about a proof of concept, though: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/princetons-ad-blo...
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @05:27PM (#14456069)
Google's ads are as links, served along with their regular search results, and marked as ads. The only way to block those would be to remove all the links marked as ads, and the predictable response would be to stop marking them. So, no, I don't see adblockers hurting Google (at least, not their main business).
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by eric_h on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @05:55PM (#14456244)
That's only google's search ads, though. DoubleClick does a lot more than text ads on google's search page.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:45PM (#14456808)
What's the revenue breakdown, though? If Google just kept text ads on their search page, how much revenue would they lose?
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by mastazi on Thursday June 01, 2017 @03:01AM (#14458484)
They would lose about 20% of their revenue, based on 1st quarter 2017 breakdown.

Source: page 33 [1] here https://abc.xyz/investor/pdf/20170331_alphabet_10Q.pdf

[1] Page 33 in terms of PDF document, if you are looking at the printed page numbers then it is page 31.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by bitmapbrother on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @04:53PM (#14455829)
>but the real fun begins when it is at +96%, and Google/Facebook/InsertNameHere lose their main source of income.

You don't really think it'll ever get anywhere near that percentage, right? When the major players start devoting time and resources to defeating ad blockers that's when the real fun will begin.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by AJ007 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @05:46PM (#14456194)
If the % of ad blockers is high enough, the content providers just switch over to paid subscriptions. E.g. Youtube Red.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by Eerie on Thursday June 01, 2017 @01:38AM (#14458234)
>If the % of ad blockers is high enough, the content providers just switch over to paid subscriptions. E.g. Youtube Red.

This would be an amazing development. 99.9% of the providers who switch to paid subscription will go out of business, because their content is toxic garbage that people will never click if it cost them money. The remaining will be those who care about quality and consider the viewers to be their customers, not their product.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by real-hacker on Thursday June 01, 2017 @06:27AM (#14459159)
Especially when the ad-blockers are running on the browsers (Chrome), which are controlled by the ad platforms (Google). If I remembered it right, reportedly Google had struck a deal with AdBlock Plus to whitelist Google ads.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by Eerie on Thursday June 01, 2017 @07:54AM (#14459501)
> If I remembered it right

Serious question. No intention to insult.

You are on the Internet, not sitting in a pub with no wi-fi. Instead of writing "if I remembered it right", why not spend 2 minutes googling, to find out how AdBlock Plus actually operates?

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by real-hacker on Thursday June 01, 2017 @11:45AM (#14461262)
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by fauigerzigerk on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @04:17PM (#14455563)
>I think a very strong and concerted push to outlaw ad-blocking is almost inevitable

Is there any indication for such a push? What might get outlawed is paid unblocking, because that is arguably extortion, but free, non-commercial, browser based ad blockers will never be outlawed.

I think what will happen once advertising growth can no longer outrun ad blocking is one or both of these two things:

a) Commercial content producers move to unblockable platforms, i.e off the open web.

b) Google et al come up with a server side solution that creates trust between advertisers, ad networks and websites so that browsers no longer need to make blockable requests to third party sites in order to retrieve ads and send clicks. That would force any ad blockers to become a lot more resource intensive because they would have to analyse the content itself, which would slow down the page massively.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by aggie on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @03:56PM (#14455414)
> as futile as trying to outlaw the BitTorrent protocol

It doesn't need to be eradicated, just kept underground to limit adoption. Millions use torrent, yes, but many more do not and the movie studios are still raking in money.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by skybrian on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @10:11PM (#14457447)
What do you do about ad blocker-blockers?
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by Eerie on Thursday June 01, 2017 @01:28AM (#14458195)
https://reek.github.io/anti-adblock-killer/

Or use uBlock Origin, which supposedly has it integrated (I'm not sure, as I'm using AdBlock Plus)

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by nothis on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @02:46PM (#14454922)
>Ad-blocking as high as 26% in some countries (Germany) and rising.

So they will get more aggressive (we already can barely distinguish an ad from a post on most websites) and more annoying and more manipulative. And they'll keep crossing lines that will cause shit storms and ad-blockers will get more aggressive and more clever and more political.

Personally, I have big hopes for new models emerging where you pay a fixed, reasonable flat-rate sum once a month ($10 or $15) to access "premium" content across multiple sites. The reality is, from most higher quality sources, I read maybe 0 to 3 articles a month but there's dozens of them. I won't pay $10 to each of them, monthly, but I'd pay $10 to access them all. The question is just how to split the money. Most views? That would almost cause the same clickbait problem we have now. Some quality measurement (likes, upvotes, etc)? Would lead to pandering. If some company could come up with a smart way to solve this and convince a few sites to jump on board with premium content, I'd be in. It's a hard problem. Kinda like search engines...

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by alexanderdmitri on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @04:18PM (#14455567)
This is a really tough problem, particularly because advertising revenue has become a metonym/euphemism for online surveillance and tracking. IMO, the only way to fix this is very clear legislation about tracking, data-aggregation, "targeted ads" and privacy rights concerning internet activity and information. Otherwise the internet will continue to evolve down the most profitable path, which is the one we're on. The personal data being accrued on individuals is not only easier to achieve than convincing the average internet user to pay for a service, but it's also something that will only gain more value as the aggregating entities learn trickier and trickier ways to use the data they're taking.

I did product demonstration and sales for a couple years, travelling around to different venues and stores to sell a great product. As a result, I now have a nightmare scenario in my head based on the fact that if, while in the sales cycle (feature -> benefit -> emotional benefit), someone like me had a device giving "suggested" points to tailor my pitch based on the personal device of the person(s) being pitched (like for health: "cancer", "weight", "diabetes"; similar products purchased, hobbies, or really anything that allows a higher chance of emotional connection like insecurities, pride points, value system, all things that can be gleaned via content consumption and posting on the internet), my sales and closing percentage would be through the roof.

I might be suffering from something similar to Slothrop's anti-paranoia[1], but to me it seems like this sort of vision is where the current "advertising"-based model of the internet is heading and why a saner subscription model will not dominate without clear legislation.

[1] http://jtls.shirazu.ac.ir/article_201_cefaf62f0af6aa172e2b36...

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by cbzbc on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @05:12PM (#14455956)
To my mind clear legislation would also have to include liability - something the ad platforms will be loath to accept.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by sheeshkebab on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @03:05PM (#14455055)
The problem is - even on sites where you pay to see content (nyt, wsj, etc), they still show you ads, to a paying logged in subscriber, which is completely ridiculous.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by sangnoir on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @04:50PM (#14455810)
Is it ridiculous though? People buy newspapers (nyt, wsj, etc) and they always had ads in them since time immemorial. The same goes for magazines and cable/satellite TV.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by alexanderdmitri on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @05:09PM (#14455936)
This is what I remember the Washington Post looking like when I read it back in the 90's: http://large.stanford.edu/prizes/nobel/news/wp/images/wpbig....

I don't remember ever seeing ads mixed in with the main content. I think it was general practice to section them off somewhere else or put them in the classifieds.

Compare with: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/global-opinions/wp/2016/...

Then check out the parties sending js to your browser behind the scene. Apples and oranges IMO.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by pcl on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @05:27PM (#14456070)
I saw no ads on your second link. Then I remembered I have my ad blocker enabled...
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by alexanderdmitri on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @06:23PM (#14456408)
These two scripts seem to have found good workarounds for my current ad-blocker's attempts:

https://js.washingtonpost.com/wp-stat/rum/wprum.min.js

https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-stat/ad/zeus/wp-ad.min.js

Looking at the output from the browser's console log on this page has me feeling like advertisers and analytics are a pretty gropey bunch. No means no, stop trying to touch my local storage!

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by barking on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @03:39PM (#14455284)
The telegraph in the UK does this, they even show you a full screen Matt cartoon that begs you to turn off adblocker, on EVERY new tab/window.

Even if you're a paying customer.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by jlgaddis on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @03:55PM (#14455408)
Isn't this basically what we have now with the cable TV industry? There, many complain because they're paying for content (channels) that they never watch and don't want.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @06:21PM (#14456392)
I think that's a bad analogy, because cable companies actually pay per-subscriber fees to channel providers. I think a better analogy is Spotify premium, where songs are paid based on listening rates (even though I think how Spotify divvies up the money is still pretty unfair to less popular musicians).
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by H1Supreme on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @02:24PM (#14454777)
I realize the ad revenue is a big part of online businesses, and I don't mind that. But, what most people mind is being bombarded by non-stop ads. There are a few popular sites I refuse to visit because of this. Pages constantly scrolling because of new ads loading from every angle.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by wutbrodo on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @01:56PM (#14454552)
I wonder how a couple countries (like India) manage 28% mobile ad blocking while only about 1% desktop ad blocking. (for the US it's reversed, 1%/18%)
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by vishnugupta on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @02:45PM (#14454920)
In India, most of the new users arriving on the internet via mobile are from tier-2/3 cities. Which implies limited bandwidth due to infrastructure as well as being price conscious. So the majority of mobile users are very paranoid about data consumption, to the extent that they toggle the data just to check FB/WA. Upshot of this is one of the first thing they do on a new phone is install ad-blocker
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by wutbrodo on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:40PM (#14457343)
I figured as much, but if ad blocking is already in people's technological Overton window, why isn't it similarly popular on desktop?
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by vishnugupta on Thursday June 01, 2017 @07:53AM (#14459486)
Two reasons I can think of, again specific to India. Desktops are typically connected to wired broadband which is way cheaper and also desktop users are usually better off than mobile only users. And only a fraction of new users are coming from desktop. Infact India is one of those countries where cinsumers leapfrogged desktops to go from no computer to smartphones.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by wutbrodo on Thursday June 01, 2017 @01:54PM (#14462665)
Yea, I was more or less aware of all this, but I was thinking more of people like my grandparents/cousins in Delhi. I could understand them and people like them not using ad blockers for the same reason as people don't in the US (lack of awareness), but it's tough for me to do so when every person with a phone seems to be familiar with it (though this is belied by the explanation elsewhere on this thread that the popular browser in use has it built-in).

The bandwidth caps at my grandparents' Delhi house being super-draconian (they're about as upper-middle/upper-class as you'd expect). Though I guess their cap (a couple GB) is in this middle range where it seems low from the perspective of video streaming etc (and I don't even really watch TV) but is high enough that ads aren't really presenting much of a problem. This would be in contrast to the presumably much-tinier caps (and correspondingly higher incentive to block ads) that mobile users are presented with.

At any rate, thanks for the explanations!

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by anjneymidha on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @03:50PM (#14455369)
This is a good question, and there are very few n=large enough surveys to point to any single cause, but the biggest one is that almost 50% of Internet traffic in India is on UC Browser (from Alibaba) that has very robust ad blocking (which consumes less data than Chrome while browsing). You should expect this to change as Jio becomes more widespread.

Disclaimer - I led the India section of this report.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by vram22 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @07:11PM (#14456655)
>almost 50% of Internet traffic in India is on UC Browser

Is that on mobile only, desktop only, or both? From your last sentence about Jio, looks like it is for mobile.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by wutbrodo on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @09:39PM (#14457341)
Thanks!
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by ice109 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @01:49PM (#14454478)
i don't understand mobile-adblocking. i thought you couldn't block mobile ads without rooting?
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by uptown on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @01:55PM (#14454533)
Mobile Safari supports content-blocking extensions.

https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2015/511/

Presumably there's something similar on Android.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by schoen on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @02:25PM (#14454782)
Is there maybe an ambiguity between "blocking mobile ads in apps" and "blocking web ads in a mobile browser"? The former might require lower-level tampering, while the latter might just require using a mobile browser that blocks ads or can run extensions.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by lanius on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @01:54PM (#14454523)
I use uBlock Origin on Firefox for Android without root.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by PKop on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @03:03PM (#14455039)
Not on iOS, presumably since Apple isn't making their money from advertising.

They would have no reason not to sell the feature of "better user experience" from blocking ads / trackers.

I use https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/purify-block-ads-and-trackin...

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by sergiotapia on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @03:14PM (#14455124)
On the iPhone you can block ads on non-rooted phones! It's awesome.

I use AdBlock Fast, but I say "use" casually since it's just an app you install and you're done with it. I never actually opened it after installing it months ago.

No more ads ever on mobile.

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by briandear on Thursday June 01, 2017 @03:45AM (#14458620)
Crystal is my ad blocker of choice on iOS -- I love how Apple made these apps possible. Huge savings on my data consumption!
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by unit91 on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @02:07PM (#14454631)
Local VPN-based solutions do the job without root. Check out AdClear, Adguard, etc.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by tomaskafka on Saturday June 03, 2017 @06:37PM (#14478867)
On Samsung with Knox (surely S6 and later, maybe S5?), AdHell works just like if it had root. Best thing ever.
Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by patwolf on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @03:18PM (#14455168)
I used to use a VPN solution on Android without root, but I eventually switched from Chrome to Brave, which has worked quite well.

https://brave.com/

Re:Mary Meeker’s 2017 internet trends report [pdf] by real-hacker on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @11:33PM (#14457799)
In China, some routers provide the optional feature of blocking ads by domain names.