> not known by the security staff.
They may just not care, or at least not make that a priority. If the dongle stuff was done just to comply to some norm or regulation, actual security could be perceived to be secondary.
> The writer already assumes that we think he is lying.
Not quite. He assumes we think he could be mistaken. ("[…] it could be conceivable […] that, in my grief, I remotely logged in, sent the email and forgot I did it"). Still a bit fishy, but not as much as you make it sound.
> is it very likely not to check your email at least just before you show up at work 6 weeks later?
That can be estimated, but not that if it were me, that would be a virtual certainty. I never check my work email outside of work. I go to work first, then I check my email.
> It is a throwaway account.
Of course it is. One does not want to tie a long term account (which may be tied to a meat-space identity) with negative stuff like that. The evidence by throwaway is practically nil.
> Not quite. He assumes we think he could be mistaken. ("[…] it could be conceivable […] that, in my grief, I remotely logged in, sent the email and forgot I did it"). Still a bit fishy, but not as much as you make it sound.
Not quite assuming that we think he's lying, but a very common tell for lies is that the lier is preempting challenges to weak points in the story.
A lot hinges on his location and the exact job, but it smells very fishy that he apparently is set up for remote access to email (so it sounds like a "regular" knowledge worker job where checking your email from not-the-office at times is not uncommon), but when leaving very suddenly, ie. with no time to hand over work to colleagues, as you'd normally do for planned leave, he wouldn't bring the dongle with him, to be able to check in and make sure his colleagues have what they need to move on without him.
I would add the general style of the write up. It does not seem like a person being actually keen to receive an answer but is written like a tale. For example, notice the start of each paragraph: "Anyway"; "now maybe"; "the fact is". (That might be his personal way of writing as well, but it adds to the suspicious feeling)
And of course the fact that one can simply quit by Email, especially after having worked at a company for a long time seems highly unlikely, I would at least expect them to call you before moving on.
a work dongle is needed to read reply email and he said that he didn't bring it.
This very much depends on the country, and local employment expectations. There's the old joke comparing US and European "out-of-office" auto replies:
US: "I am on holidays, but I'll check in with my email about every night. I can be reached at $PHONE_NUMBER for an emergency"
Europe: "I am on holiday. I will return in 4 weeks."
Also :
+ if it was holidays or a child he wouldn't have left in a rush : those departure should arguably be prepared in advance
+ "Technological details" are very vague and sounds like something he overheard but didn't understand or know how to use.
+ the throwaway account means nothing and could very well plead in his favour : he's not sure he wants to spend time attacking his company so he stays anonymous before taking a rushed decision.
+ not checking his email is consistent with not having the dongle !
Thanks for your counterarguments. I of course admit that my assumptions are assumptions and henceforth definitely not airtight. However, I just wanted to say that I would have never actually responded to that question itself with how I commented on HN, just to be safe.
Nevertheless I strongly believe in the presumption of innocence, even outside of court, as a general moral rule we owe to others.
Outrageous might of been a little strong though :)
It's only outrageous if you act on the suspicion.
+ No follow up comments on questions for some more info or thanking people that feel for him.
+ Using a very general name as nickname (although not English).
+ A throwaway account. Although it's understandable, because it is a personal story; if this would happen to me everyone would know.
It also interesting to see how good the story is. When people respond to this in the sense of "who did it?", they come up with the CEO. If he would have weaved in the name of one of his colleagues that used to joke around with fake email addresses, the story plot becomes weaker.
It's not unusual for database servers to have functions available to send emails from stored procedures - it doesn't seem completely unlikely to me that someone could use something like this to send spoof emails.
Nevertheless, it does pose a more general question. Given that in many workplaces the employer has access to your work email/account, how can one prove that he/she did not send a particular email?
You don't, that's up to the police, prosecutors and forensics experts to handle.
Even though I only worked peripherally with digital forensics people, and I know a lot about how email/computers/networks work, I know enough to know that I could never get away with forging an email (especially not one where anything serious depended on it).
In a more broader way, how can one prove innocence if their company use the employee's credentials (ID/email/etc.) to drop the blame on them? Wouldn't it be the employees words against the employer, while at the same time the employer has the control over the data/evidence?
I mean, if this particular case is real, someone has performed a serious crime, risking years in jail, for a comparably trivial reason and small gain - it's not an indication that the perpetrator is likely to be risk-averse, meticulous and smart.
If we were looking at a forged email as a part of a sophisticated campaign for extracting secret information or defrauding very large amounts of money, then it would be likely that the forgery is done carefully by skilled people thoroughly removing all traces - but for a reason like this? not likely. Heck, digital "intelligence ops" by major governments sometimes leave traces due to some sloppiness or carelessness, it's very hard to be sufficiently thorough.
The author implies that he's used the 'SQL' way of sending emails. Calling it 'SQL' sounds like a way of feigning ignorance of the details - and therefore giving a defense on future cross-examination.
I suspect he either used it personally to resign, or asked a colleague to, who has effectively been set up.
Apply Occam's Razor to it. What's more likely; that some unknown person resigned on this guy's behalf or that he resigned and he's going with this b.s. story to save face or that none of this happened? One of the latter two is the most likely.
It's a pile of baloney.
It's fine to say "this is the internet and people invent stories" but to apply Occam's razor you need to actually come up with a motivation that would cause this guy to actually invent this story and post it online.
Why he chose to post is a separate issue. People have any number of motives for doing things, and what you believe to be reasonable explanations depends on how you think about human psychology. Personally I have seen enough people post lies online that I don't even worry about what the motives are anymore. I just look at what I think is more likely; is this story true or not? This story reeks to me. There's no way some unknown person resigned for him. Either he did it and regretted it or this whole story is made up. Both of those are way simpler than the claim that some unknown person logged into his secure email and that the company reacted so nonchalantly to him telling them he didn't do it. If someone hated him enough to write a fake resignation letter and risk their own career like that, he would know who it was.
Frankly it's one of the more obvious fake stories on HN in a while.
I think you should be careful to invoke Occam's razor like this though. It states: "Among competing hypotheses, the one with the fewest assumptions should be selected". You can't compare two hypotheses unless you express all of their respective assumptions.
+ He could have been on holidays, or getting a child, but it is the death of his mother. Of course, we are gonna feel really bad for him. That's really good for the story.
+ The security of the system is such that on one hand a dongle is needed, but on the other hand someone can fake sending email through your account. This is apparently widely known by non-expert colleagues to just joke around, but not known by the security staff.
+ Technological "details" that do not seem to make sense such as SQL to make it sound like a true story to the uneducated.
+ The writer already assumes that we think he is lying. Hence, he comes up with the dongle story. We would already have been fine with his word that he just didn't send the resignation letter.
+ He physically shows up 6 weeks later without checking his email once (reply email). Of course the effect of the story is much stronger in that case. However, is it very likely not to check your email at least just before you show up at work 6 weeks later? [Edit: incorrect assumption, see @c8g.]
Then what would be motive of the person asking the question. It is a throwaway account.
+ A researcher who wants to see what the difference is between a fake story on Facebook versus one asked on StackOverflow? How could such an effect be properly compared?