News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jacque Fresco has died by rodolphoarruda on Friday May 26, 2017 @08:09AM (#14423470)
I remember when I watched the Zeitgeist documentaries and had my first contact with this 'resource based" society. Weeks later I had dinner with a friend who was a director in a Spanish consulting firm specialized in the banking sector. I tried to impress him with what I had seen in the documentary. In the end, it was like having an atheist trying to convince the pope about his convictions.
Re:Jacque Fresco has died by erik14th on Friday May 26, 2017 @11:24AM (#14424698)
As much as I like Fresco's vision, it sounds to me like saying: "hey, you know all that code we wrote for Society 1.0 in the last couple thousand years? let's throw all that out and write Society 2.0 from scratch" and he acknowledge that when he says the actual system would have to collapse for his ideas to take place. His spec is beautiful but without backwards compat and no smooth transition route, I can't see it happening.
Re:Jacque Fresco has died by ilaksh on Saturday May 27, 2017 @12:05AM (#14428873)
I always thought Fresco has quite a lot of great ideas, but after a few years, I came to think of his perspective as a bit 1950s-ish in terms of the lack of incorporation of network robustness, decentralization, etc.

I believe we need to take that a lot of that techno-communist stuff to some degree and actually combine it with decentralized perspectives. Because we _are_ currently doing a horrible job of measuring and acting holistically -- and certainly on some level we need to be able to have sort of total measurements of things and limitations in different regions, etc.

And we can use technology to make gathering these holistic measurements, as well as acting cooperatively, more feasible, to the degree it is wise. For example, common information systems or schemas for large-scale public data mining of natural resource usage, or simply fair tax reporting, etc.

But at the same time, I feel that the biggest pitfall of both competitive (capitalist) and cooperative (communist) approaches is over-centralization. Here we can also look to new technologies like block chains, Bitcoin, Ethereum, etc. that enable decentralized large-scale trust/databases.

The problem we have now is that we actually do have a smooth transition to basically what Fresco was envisioning, except he forgot how problematic it can be to have massive governments or corporations or AIs with a centralized monopoly on production. We are headed towards that actually now -- Google for organizing and searching all information, Walmart for distributing goods in stores, Amazon for everything else, youtube for video, Uber for getting around, etc. Because these monopolies are so powerful (I call them 'technopolies') they are basically de facto government entities -- except worse.

So anyway again the way out of this is to decentralize all the things again, using technology so that we can have a common platform, common total measurements, etc., but also do it in a robust way that has room to evolve and is not dependent upon over-powered nodes.

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by david927 on Friday May 26, 2017 @12:27PM (#14425233)
Ideas often don't neatly, slowly segue into other ideas. The Ptolemaic model didn't migrate a step at a time to the Newtonian model.

If progress has taught us anything is that we often spend too much time arguing at the leaf level when what is needed is to back a branch or two toward the trunk and make a change there.

Moving out of Monarchy and Feudalism to Democracy was a sea change that overthrew everything before it. We managed it and are much happier because of it. While I don't agree with Fresco's vision entirely, it's not because fundamental changes aren't feasible or even, possibly, necessary.

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by staticelf on Friday May 26, 2017 @08:37AM (#14423590)
I was also pretty juiced up and into the venus project for a while until I realized nobody is interested in living in such a world. Then I gave up.
Re:Jacque Fresco has died by barrkel on Friday May 26, 2017 @09:57AM (#14424047)
We're built for a hedonic treadmill; our striving, and unhappiness with a steady stable state, increases our probability of genetic propagation at the cost of our neighbours. It's baked in at a low level, and if we don't figure something out, it'll be the doom of us all.
Re:Jacque Fresco has died by xenu101 on Friday May 26, 2017 @09:07AM (#14423717)
People are interested, they're just not interested in working towards it or giving up things for it.

Fresco paints a gloomy picture of the now and the future, but the facts are that "on average", humans are living better lives than they ever have. This progress has not yet stopped.

Hence, Fresco predicts we need to wait for the next "bust".

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by JackFr on Friday May 26, 2017 @09:36AM (#14423885)
It's not just "on average", people are materially better off today than at any other period in history, at all levels. The poorest people today are better off than the poorest people at any previous era.
Re:Jacque Fresco has died by lawless123 on Friday May 26, 2017 @11:36AM (#14424789)
The poorest today and the poorest in this era are often slaves and often starving.

That hasn't changed. If you're referring to the poorest in your particular nation state, consider they're probably not the poorest in the world, which we're all using in some way.

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by JackFr on Friday May 26, 2017 @12:27PM (#14425232)
No - I am explicitly considering the world. There are fewer people (as a percentage) starving and in bondage than in any prior era.

I don't think I have an overly rosy picture of the present. Rather I think your picture of the past is too romantic.

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by wu-ikkyu on Friday May 26, 2017 @02:45PM (#14426253)
>There are fewer people (as a percentage) starving

There are more people (in real numbers) starving than ever before. Looking at this in terms of percentages is misleading

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by pixl97 on Friday May 26, 2017 @04:12PM (#14426795)
>Looking at this in terms of percentages is misleading

Um, per capita is the important metric.

If there are 2 million people on your planet and 1 million of them are starving, then in a few generations there 100 million people and 2 million of them are starving you have drastically reduced the rate of starvation. Malthusian predictions of the past have said that the rate of starvation/bad things happening would increase as the population increased. It has not.

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by wu-ikkyu on Wednesday May 31, 2017 @12:11PM (#14453605)
>Um, per capita is the important metric.

The true number of starving people is not an important metric?

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by xkarga00 on Friday May 26, 2017 @11:12AM (#14424594)
That's the problem, we are only _materially_ better. It is sad we still cannot figure that out.
Re:Jacque Fresco has died by BuckRogers on Friday May 26, 2017 @11:31AM (#14424746)
Yup you nailed it. In many ways like work-life balance, times are worse than the middle ages.

Also material betterment doesn't scale, we can't focus on material betterment for all because until we figure out fusion and get our own Dyson Sphere going, we have finite resources.

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by cholantesh on Friday May 26, 2017 @11:46AM (#14424868)
>In many ways like work-life balance, times are worse than the middle ages.

Is this actually established? It's my understanding that the work-leisure dichotomy didn't really exist in medieval Europe. Also, considering how much of the fruit of your labour ended up supporting local and distant aristocracy, I can't imagine mental health being particularly high for a lot of people.

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by goodJobWalrus on Friday May 26, 2017 @11:56AM (#14424929)
Anthropologists seem to agree* that hunter-gatherers (our ancestors, but also ones living in modern times) worked a little less than 8 hours a day.

* For source, I've seen Yuval Noah Harari and Peter Gray writing about it.

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by ue_ on Friday May 26, 2017 @12:01PM (#14424961)
Although I don't think it's very wise to say we should try to reach for the ideal of the hunter-gatherer society, but it's undeniable that the combination of (i) overproduction and (ii) machinery being used for short-term profit rather than meaning people have to work less is causing a lot of time used working when it could, in a society not driven by profit, be used for various kinds of fulfillment and sharpening one's intellectual faculties.

As Oscar Wilde put it:

Now and then, in the course of the century, a great man of science, like Darwin; a great poet, like Keats; a fine critical spirit, like M. Renan; a supreme artist, like Flaubert, has been able to isolate himself, to keep himself out of reach of the clamorous claims of others, to stand ‘under the shelter of the wall,’ as Plato puts it, and so to realise the perfection of what was in him, to his own incomparable gain, and to the incomparable and lasting gain of the whole world. These, however, are exceptions. The majority of people spoil their lives by an unhealthy and exaggerated altruism – are forced, indeed, so to spoil them. They find themselves surrounded by hideous poverty, by hideous ugliness, by hideous starvation.

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by taw55 on Friday May 26, 2017 @05:13PM (#14427237)
I might be wrong, but I think agricultural societies had very long working days at harvest time but relatively short ones on average. During the transition of feudalism to industrialism working hours rose significantly (as did productivity, but kept churning due to new class relationships).
Re:Jacque Fresco has died by cholantesh on Friday May 26, 2017 @01:32PM (#14425782)
GP specifically mentions the middle ages, though; I think 8 hours would have been considered pretty light by then.
Re:Jacque Fresco has died by dragonwriter on Friday May 26, 2017 @01:37PM (#14425817)
It would have been light in some parts of the year, but long in others. In addition to natural seasonality in agricultural work, simply the availability of light limits many kinds of labor until you have something better (both in light quality and resource, including labor, cost for the light provided) than firelight.
Re:Jacque Fresco has died by cholantesh on Friday May 26, 2017 @01:47PM (#14425883)
Makes sense - sounds like a lot of trades today, albeit a bit better (maybe) because you had one client and they provided for you during the off season.
Re:Jacque Fresco has died by atlih on Monday May 29, 2017 @08:46PM (#14442367)
You do realize that your argument also works flawlessly for Kim Jong-un in North Korea, right?
Re:Jacque Fresco has died by staticelf on Friday May 26, 2017 @09:10AM (#14423739)
That assumes that there will be people remembering the venus project or even have the resources to fight for it at the correct time. Also, it assumes that humanity will survive the climate changes that are due.

I think we have taught ourselves that we rather suffer and keep things as they are rather than actually improving them in a radical way like in trying out new economic models.

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by xenu101 on Friday May 26, 2017 @09:22AM (#14423793)
He believed himself that the chances are slim. We may well be headed for the next dark ages. I doubt we're going extinct though, unless we're literally turning this planet into Venus (put somewhat intended).
Re:Jacque Fresco has died by BuckRogers on Friday May 26, 2017 @11:26AM (#14424715)
The Venus Project has inspired me to extend on their ideas in certain ways, but commit myself to the idea in general. If I ever have vast sums of money like Bill Gates, I'll use it to start something small-scale where people can live outside of current nation-states and demonstrate to the world how life can be if they choose.

I think it's just a matter of this, demonstration. It won't attract everyone, there's a lot of very confused people in a lot of nations who think their way of life can't be topped (especially the US).

The likelihood of 1 person like me who agrees with Fresco's vision netting billions of dollars to begin is higher than a bunch of people on their iPhones suddenly agreeing to the idea in an awakening. It can happen, without a nuclear holocaust "awakening" too. Just need the Elon Musk of the Venus Project to start small.

Jacque did a lot of hard work to get the idea out there.

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by taw55 on Friday May 26, 2017 @05:07PM (#14427189)
The problem with the Venus project is that it basically looks at human individuals as robotic entities that will behave and function if only put in the right environment and subject to the right inputs. It's all horribly modernist/constructivist.

The architecture proposed has no individualism about it, this is like a cartoon version of collectivism where there is no opportunity for self-actualization.

I wouldn't want to live in that world, but even if I did I'm sure it would quickly morph into something else entirely.

The resource idea is nice at first glance, but it only considers needs and not wants. The Soviet Union had the issue where production was always lagging behind trends and demands, China started growing when they cut loose entrepreneurial forces (though those are still heavily guided at macro scale, much like seen in postwar developed countries during the Keynesian era).

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by atlih on Monday May 29, 2017 @08:41PM (#14442347)
And then came Zuckerbergs Harvard commencement address. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BmYv8XGl-YU

Basically poor Jacque was 40 years ahead of his time.

Re:Jacque Fresco has died by stupidhn on Friday May 26, 2017 @02:40PM (#14426226)
>In the end, it was like having an atheist trying to convince the pope about his convictions.

I think a better analogy might be "reading a single article on the internet, then projecting yourself as an expert".

I fully expect that the Pope could debate your average atheist into submission.