News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by heisenbit on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:32PM (#14368642)
BBC may want to rethink that. Either it is illegal and then the police and courts are the place or it is legal and then it is none of their business. What they are threatening is when they perceive their TOS are violated that they use personal information and interfere in other relationships. This exposes the BBC to liability e.g. if the person is fired they may ask the BBC to pay up. See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tortious_interference
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by Veen on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:09PM (#14368981)
Anything you choose to publish on the BBC's website is their business. It's not as though they're going around looking for naughty posts on third-party websites and tattling about it.

There is no automatic right to anonymity when posting on someone else's website. If you post something publicly, surely the expectation is that you're fine with anyone seeing it. If the BBC chooses to share that with your boss, why is it different to anyone else choosing to share it with a member of the public.

If you don't want everyone to know that you're a dick, don't be a dick in public.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by nsnick on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:24PM (#14369143)
It doesn't matter whose business it is, the BBC still can't use communication between you and the BBC to interfere in a relationship you have with your employer that is illegal.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tortious_interference

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by oliwarner on Friday May 19, 2017 @03:41PM (#14378785)
This does depend on the scenario. If the abuse it's coming from a corporate network, from an employee, the employer is getting contacted. They are legally responsible for both.

If it's somebody posting from home in their own time, dobbing them in seems a bit weird. How do they know who I work for?

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by Veen on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:32PM (#14369229)
An analogy I have in mind might help. Say I write book arguing that a marginalized group are in fact responsible for all the evils in society. A publisher chooses to publish that book. Someone decides to send my boss a copy of the book and I get fired. Do I have cause to sue the sender for tortious interference?

I don't know what the status of private communications with the BBC would be in this regard, but if you're using their platform to publish, then I think that my argument holds.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by npiazza83 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:47PM (#14369381)
The court treats the actions of individuals on a case by case basis. Your analogy breaks down when codified into a business contract. By stipulating a course of action that may cause real financial harm. Even if they were to stipulate fines or other remedies in response to perceived financial harm on their part the enforcement of such penalties is not their responsibility. They have taken enforcement powers away from the government.

Think of it like this: If I'm a web developer and I haven't received payment for my services I can withhold those services or even retain control of the product I am providing or use the courts to enforce the contract, but if I used the client's credit card info to enforce fines and pay myself I have broken the law regardless of whether I put it in the contract.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by AcerbicZero on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:43PM (#14369344)
IANAL, but as I understand it, in that situation you would not have grounds to sue the sender.

However, if the publisher you sent the book to publishs it, then goes to your boss with the intent of getting you in trouble and/or fired, you might have something to sue over.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by wcummings on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:28PM (#14369190)
It's not really between you and the BBC, it's not private correspondence, it's a public post.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by npiazza83 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:29PM (#14369771)
Its A) codified into a business contract, not the actions of a private individual B) the use of private metadata and C) the stipulation that BBC is the enforcement mechanism that is problematic here.

Otherwise the BBC would quickly find that when they are late paying the contractors who work on their website their credit cards mysteriously get charged for the services rendered.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by chc on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:34PM (#14369253)
FYI, many people will perceive this comment of yours as dickish. Do you want everyone to know you're a dick, or do you feel like you're just expressing an opinion and having somebody attempt to personally harm you based on it would be an unreasonable overreaction?
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by Veen on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:58PM (#14369479)
I'm not a relativist. I think that in a civilized society there are standards of behavior that all reasonable people can agree on. Everything I say is premised on that assumption, so you're free to reject the argument if you don't feel such standards exist.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by chc on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:05PM (#14369560)
I certainly agree such standards exist. But one of those standards of behavior that reasonable people agree to seems to be "Don't try to ruin people's lives just because they hold unpopular opinions." The people I know who do believe in that kind of vigilante justice against ideological opponents are not at all what I'd describe as reasonable. Like, do you look at Joseph McCarthy and his supporters and say, "There was a bunch of reasonable folks"?
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by astrodust on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:32PM (#14369231)
Just forward them to the police and get an ASBO slapped on them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-social_behaviour_order
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by foepys on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:25PM (#14369155)
> If the BBC chooses to share that with your boss, why is it different to anyone else choosing to share it with a member of the public.

I assume you never did something embarrassing in a bar? Or were more than a little drunk?

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by npiazza83 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:30PM (#14369214)
Funny, I've never heard of an Officer of the BBC. I've heard of an Officer of the law and an Officer of the court. They're generally responsible for enforcing penalties, fines, jail sentences, probation, sex offender lists, etc.

If you'd like to add, "tattling to your employer" to that list I suggest you talk to parliament. They get awfully upset when you try to "do things for them" via cellophane business contracts.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by rendall on Friday May 19, 2017 @08:20AM (#14374875)
Certainly BBC has officers. Some of them even have "Officer" in their job titles.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC#Executive_Committee

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by npiazza83 on Friday May 19, 2017 @08:57AM (#14375112)
In making this argument to personal friends I have heard several times, "Well what about tow trucks? They have the right to enforce contracts on private property and they aren't officers of the law!?"

The answer is that there are existing federal statutes in place to allow this. They are controversial and often challenged. Tow truck drivers operate in a grey area of the law and are frequently found to be in violation of the law. I would hope that the BBC values their operating license more than my local tow company.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by lostlogin on Thursday May 18, 2017 @03:04PM (#14370089)
You really don't see a difference between an individual sharing something about you and the same info coming from one of the biggest media corporations on earth straight to your boss?
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by logicallee on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:02PM (#14369519)
>There is no automatic right to anonymity when posting on someone else's website.

Put another way, anyone who posts anything on your site, you have a right to discover the name of. Do you agree with this satement? Do you agree that YCombinator, owner of the site you are posting this on, has a right to investigate and discover your name? (Which you are not posting under.)

For me, I would think that would be the case if you cross a certain line. They do not have the right to discover that you're actually (celebrity investor) and then, since of course you have "no right to anonymity", publish the fact that (celebrity investor) comments here.

I think this example logically proves that in fact you do have a right to post anonymously. (Since if you didn't, sites would have a right to go to any length to discover your identity.) Or what am I missing? I might have a flaw in the deduction made in this comment and am open to someone pointing it out.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by abandonliberty on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:21PM (#14369114)
This would be much more reasonable if work networks or devices were used during the behavior.

"Where the BBC reasonably believes that you are or may be in breach of any applicable laws"

They are actually reaching out to claim you have violated laws. Is this not potentially libelous?

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by kazinator on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:44PM (#14369346)
Tortious interference occurs only if the BBC carries out their threat.

But what is the legal status of the threat itself, not carried out?

If there are no legal ramifications from merely threatening to perpetrate tortious interference, then it seems like a useful troll deterrent tool that the BBC has a right to use on their own site.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by jsmthrowaway on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:01PM (#14369502)
Tortious interference doesn't occur, in the slightest, whether the BBC carries out their threat or not. The hint is in the word "tortious." Explain the tort. Think about it: complaining to a manager at a fast food restaurant would result in liability for the customer in this world where tortious interference bizarrely applies.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by kazinator on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:21PM (#14369693)
This is like complaining to a manager at a fast food restaurant because of some personal problem with the fast food employee, outside of the context of being served by that employee. The perpetrator is "getting even" with that person by trying to stir up problems for them at work. Maybe they met at a party last weekend, and the one insulted the other's girlfriend or whatever; nothing to do with hamburgers.

If you have a problem with service and complain to a manager, then you're clearly not a "third party"; the contract between the employee and fast food restaurant has everything to do with serving you.

Note that the BBC are not saying that they will contact your employer only if it can be determined that you used the employer's time and equipment to post the comments. Even if you post those comments using your own residential internet connection on your own time, they threaten to contact your employer.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by JdeBP on Thursday May 18, 2017 @03:57PM (#14370573)
It's not like fast food restaurants at all. This is a privacy policy. And it is like (say) the privacy policy that covers people with accounts at Japan Today, which says:

> We reserve the right to use or share information in order to investigate, prevent, or take action regarding illegal activities, suspected fraud, situations involving potential threats to the physical safety of any person, violations of Japan Today Terms of Use, or as otherwise required by law.

The difference is that unlike Japan Today, and other privacy policies mentioned elsewhere on this page, the BBC is trying to tell you whom the information will be disclosed to, pursuant to the guidelines from the U.K. Information Commissioner on privacy policies, but somewhat ineptly. Japan Today tells you that it may "share information", but nothing whatsoever about whom that is likely to be with. The BBC is trying to tell you whom it is likely to be sharing information with.

And it should come as no surprise that if you are posting from a work computer, one of the people it is going to be sharing the information with is the company that your IP address backtracks to.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by jellicle on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:48PM (#14368780)
Why is it "none of the BBC's business" when you send hate mail to the BBC? Haven't you made it their business?
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by interfixus on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:02PM (#14368926)
That magic spell again: Hate mail.

All parties are invited to remember, one guy's considered opinion is another guy's hate speech.

And then, ever so often, the wind changes, the tables are turned, those in the wrong are now in the right, and those in the right are now everybody's laughing stock.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by Veen on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:09PM (#14368993)
The boundaries are fuzzy and subject to change. That doesn't mean there can be no standards of acceptability.

Who defines the standards? In this case, the BBC.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by Karunamon on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:46PM (#14369371)
That doesn't mean there can be no standards of acceptability.

Why do there need to be "standards of acceptability" at all? Seems to me the better world is one in which people don't interfere in other people's employment.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by interfixus on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:13PM (#14369029)
And those standards to be defined by ... ???
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by PascLeRasc on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:56PM (#14369999)
The BBC. Someone's website isn't a public place. This isn't free speech.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by npiazza83 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:11PM (#14369015)
The courts and laws are established to determine appropriate action in such a case.

Proving real damage to the BBC due to what they perceive to be "hate speech" is difficult.

The BBC has put in their terms that they reserve the right to cause real financial harm to those they perceive to be writing "hate speech".

I can put in my contract that I reserve the right to murder you, and if you sign it I'm still going to jail. Such is the case here. The BBC just made themselves look like idiots for no enforceable reason.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by jellicle on Friday May 19, 2017 @02:00PM (#14377989)
If telling your ISP about something you sent causes you "real financial harm", perhaps you shouldn't have sent it. Perhaps you are responsible for the "real financial harm" to yourself.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by npiazza83 on Monday May 22, 2017 @11:25AM (#14394325)
The law is designed to cover cases you might not immediately think of. Protecting men/women from "legal" harassing communication in the work place, protecting homosexual couples from discrimination, etc. eliminating such protections to stick it to nazis is, to put it mildly, naive