News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by heisenbit on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:32PM (#14368642)
BBC may want to rethink that. Either it is illegal and then the police and courts are the place or it is legal and then it is none of their business. What they are threatening is when they perceive their TOS are violated that they use personal information and interfere in other relationships. This exposes the BBC to liability e.g. if the person is fired they may ask the BBC to pay up. See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tortious_interference
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by Veen on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:09PM (#14368981)
Anything you choose to publish on the BBC's website is their business. It's not as though they're going around looking for naughty posts on third-party websites and tattling about it.

There is no automatic right to anonymity when posting on someone else's website. If you post something publicly, surely the expectation is that you're fine with anyone seeing it. If the BBC chooses to share that with your boss, why is it different to anyone else choosing to share it with a member of the public.

If you don't want everyone to know that you're a dick, don't be a dick in public.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by nsnick on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:24PM (#14369143)
It doesn't matter whose business it is, the BBC still can't use communication between you and the BBC to interfere in a relationship you have with your employer that is illegal.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tortious_interference

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by oliwarner on Friday May 19, 2017 @03:41PM (#14378785)
This does depend on the scenario. If the abuse it's coming from a corporate network, from an employee, the employer is getting contacted. They are legally responsible for both.

If it's somebody posting from home in their own time, dobbing them in seems a bit weird. How do they know who I work for?

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by Veen on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:32PM (#14369229)
An analogy I have in mind might help. Say I write book arguing that a marginalized group are in fact responsible for all the evils in society. A publisher chooses to publish that book. Someone decides to send my boss a copy of the book and I get fired. Do I have cause to sue the sender for tortious interference?

I don't know what the status of private communications with the BBC would be in this regard, but if you're using their platform to publish, then I think that my argument holds.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by npiazza83 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:47PM (#14369381)
The court treats the actions of individuals on a case by case basis. Your analogy breaks down when codified into a business contract. By stipulating a course of action that may cause real financial harm. Even if they were to stipulate fines or other remedies in response to perceived financial harm on their part the enforcement of such penalties is not their responsibility. They have taken enforcement powers away from the government.

Think of it like this: If I'm a web developer and I haven't received payment for my services I can withhold those services or even retain control of the product I am providing or use the courts to enforce the contract, but if I used the client's credit card info to enforce fines and pay myself I have broken the law regardless of whether I put it in the contract.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by AcerbicZero on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:43PM (#14369344)
IANAL, but as I understand it, in that situation you would not have grounds to sue the sender.

However, if the publisher you sent the book to publishs it, then goes to your boss with the intent of getting you in trouble and/or fired, you might have something to sue over.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by wcummings on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:28PM (#14369190)
It's not really between you and the BBC, it's not private correspondence, it's a public post.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by npiazza83 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:29PM (#14369771)
Its A) codified into a business contract, not the actions of a private individual B) the use of private metadata and C) the stipulation that BBC is the enforcement mechanism that is problematic here.

Otherwise the BBC would quickly find that when they are late paying the contractors who work on their website their credit cards mysteriously get charged for the services rendered.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by chc on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:34PM (#14369253)
FYI, many people will perceive this comment of yours as dickish. Do you want everyone to know you're a dick, or do you feel like you're just expressing an opinion and having somebody attempt to personally harm you based on it would be an unreasonable overreaction?
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by Veen on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:58PM (#14369479)
I'm not a relativist. I think that in a civilized society there are standards of behavior that all reasonable people can agree on. Everything I say is premised on that assumption, so you're free to reject the argument if you don't feel such standards exist.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by chc on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:05PM (#14369560)
I certainly agree such standards exist. But one of those standards of behavior that reasonable people agree to seems to be "Don't try to ruin people's lives just because they hold unpopular opinions." The people I know who do believe in that kind of vigilante justice against ideological opponents are not at all what I'd describe as reasonable. Like, do you look at Joseph McCarthy and his supporters and say, "There was a bunch of reasonable folks"?
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by astrodust on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:32PM (#14369231)
Just forward them to the police and get an ASBO slapped on them: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-social_behaviour_order
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by foepys on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:25PM (#14369155)
> If the BBC chooses to share that with your boss, why is it different to anyone else choosing to share it with a member of the public.

I assume you never did something embarrassing in a bar? Or were more than a little drunk?

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by npiazza83 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:30PM (#14369214)
Funny, I've never heard of an Officer of the BBC. I've heard of an Officer of the law and an Officer of the court. They're generally responsible for enforcing penalties, fines, jail sentences, probation, sex offender lists, etc.

If you'd like to add, "tattling to your employer" to that list I suggest you talk to parliament. They get awfully upset when you try to "do things for them" via cellophane business contracts.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by rendall on Friday May 19, 2017 @08:20AM (#14374875)
Certainly BBC has officers. Some of them even have "Officer" in their job titles.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC#Executive_Committee

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by npiazza83 on Friday May 19, 2017 @08:57AM (#14375112)
In making this argument to personal friends I have heard several times, "Well what about tow trucks? They have the right to enforce contracts on private property and they aren't officers of the law!?"

The answer is that there are existing federal statutes in place to allow this. They are controversial and often challenged. Tow truck drivers operate in a grey area of the law and are frequently found to be in violation of the law. I would hope that the BBC values their operating license more than my local tow company.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by lostlogin on Thursday May 18, 2017 @03:04PM (#14370089)
You really don't see a difference between an individual sharing something about you and the same info coming from one of the biggest media corporations on earth straight to your boss?
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by logicallee on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:02PM (#14369519)
>There is no automatic right to anonymity when posting on someone else's website.

Put another way, anyone who posts anything on your site, you have a right to discover the name of. Do you agree with this satement? Do you agree that YCombinator, owner of the site you are posting this on, has a right to investigate and discover your name? (Which you are not posting under.)

For me, I would think that would be the case if you cross a certain line. They do not have the right to discover that you're actually (celebrity investor) and then, since of course you have "no right to anonymity", publish the fact that (celebrity investor) comments here.

I think this example logically proves that in fact you do have a right to post anonymously. (Since if you didn't, sites would have a right to go to any length to discover your identity.) Or what am I missing? I might have a flaw in the deduction made in this comment and am open to someone pointing it out.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by abandonliberty on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:21PM (#14369114)
This would be much more reasonable if work networks or devices were used during the behavior.

"Where the BBC reasonably believes that you are or may be in breach of any applicable laws"

They are actually reaching out to claim you have violated laws. Is this not potentially libelous?

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by kazinator on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:44PM (#14369346)
Tortious interference occurs only if the BBC carries out their threat.

But what is the legal status of the threat itself, not carried out?

If there are no legal ramifications from merely threatening to perpetrate tortious interference, then it seems like a useful troll deterrent tool that the BBC has a right to use on their own site.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by jsmthrowaway on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:01PM (#14369502)
Tortious interference doesn't occur, in the slightest, whether the BBC carries out their threat or not. The hint is in the word "tortious." Explain the tort. Think about it: complaining to a manager at a fast food restaurant would result in liability for the customer in this world where tortious interference bizarrely applies.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by kazinator on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:21PM (#14369693)
This is like complaining to a manager at a fast food restaurant because of some personal problem with the fast food employee, outside of the context of being served by that employee. The perpetrator is "getting even" with that person by trying to stir up problems for them at work. Maybe they met at a party last weekend, and the one insulted the other's girlfriend or whatever; nothing to do with hamburgers.

If you have a problem with service and complain to a manager, then you're clearly not a "third party"; the contract between the employee and fast food restaurant has everything to do with serving you.

Note that the BBC are not saying that they will contact your employer only if it can be determined that you used the employer's time and equipment to post the comments. Even if you post those comments using your own residential internet connection on your own time, they threaten to contact your employer.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by JdeBP on Thursday May 18, 2017 @03:57PM (#14370573)
It's not like fast food restaurants at all. This is a privacy policy. And it is like (say) the privacy policy that covers people with accounts at Japan Today, which says:

> We reserve the right to use or share information in order to investigate, prevent, or take action regarding illegal activities, suspected fraud, situations involving potential threats to the physical safety of any person, violations of Japan Today Terms of Use, or as otherwise required by law.

The difference is that unlike Japan Today, and other privacy policies mentioned elsewhere on this page, the BBC is trying to tell you whom the information will be disclosed to, pursuant to the guidelines from the U.K. Information Commissioner on privacy policies, but somewhat ineptly. Japan Today tells you that it may "share information", but nothing whatsoever about whom that is likely to be with. The BBC is trying to tell you whom it is likely to be sharing information with.

And it should come as no surprise that if you are posting from a work computer, one of the people it is going to be sharing the information with is the company that your IP address backtracks to.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by jellicle on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:48PM (#14368780)
Why is it "none of the BBC's business" when you send hate mail to the BBC? Haven't you made it their business?
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by interfixus on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:02PM (#14368926)
That magic spell again: Hate mail.

All parties are invited to remember, one guy's considered opinion is another guy's hate speech.

And then, ever so often, the wind changes, the tables are turned, those in the wrong are now in the right, and those in the right are now everybody's laughing stock.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by Veen on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:09PM (#14368993)
The boundaries are fuzzy and subject to change. That doesn't mean there can be no standards of acceptability.

Who defines the standards? In this case, the BBC.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by Karunamon on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:46PM (#14369371)
That doesn't mean there can be no standards of acceptability.

Why do there need to be "standards of acceptability" at all? Seems to me the better world is one in which people don't interfere in other people's employment.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by interfixus on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:13PM (#14369029)
And those standards to be defined by ... ???
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by PascLeRasc on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:56PM (#14369999)
The BBC. Someone's website isn't a public place. This isn't free speech.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by npiazza83 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:11PM (#14369015)
The courts and laws are established to determine appropriate action in such a case.

Proving real damage to the BBC due to what they perceive to be "hate speech" is difficult.

The BBC has put in their terms that they reserve the right to cause real financial harm to those they perceive to be writing "hate speech".

I can put in my contract that I reserve the right to murder you, and if you sign it I'm still going to jail. Such is the case here. The BBC just made themselves look like idiots for no enforceable reason.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by jellicle on Friday May 19, 2017 @02:00PM (#14377989)
If telling your ISP about something you sent causes you "real financial harm", perhaps you shouldn't have sent it. Perhaps you are responsible for the "real financial harm" to yourself.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by npiazza83 on Monday May 22, 2017 @11:25AM (#14394325)
The law is designed to cover cases you might not immediately think of. Protecting men/women from "legal" harassing communication in the work place, protecting homosexual couples from discrimination, etc. eliminating such protections to stick it to nazis is, to put it mildly, naive
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by matt4077 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:49PM (#14368797)
I'm no fan of the 'employer' part, because it places companies in a position as arbitrators of behaviour that they don't deserve.

BUT: Considering the stuff I see people posting online, I do think it's such a cesspool of hatred, ill-will and really bad arguments that I am concerned how societies will continue to function, if these interactions become a routine part of civic society.

In the past, your opinions, and statements were moderated by your peers, i. e. friends, family, or even strangers (but face-to-face). Sure, that meant a certain degree of self-censorship in some cases. But apart from some anarchists notion of "free speech", I have yet to see anything good emerging from the cauldron of freedom (see /r/the_donald for reference).

Anonymously posting hate-filled comments or fake conspiracies is probably legal, but that doesn't mean it's good. It has real costs, both in how it may hurt those it wants to hurt, as well as the toll it has taken on the political narrative. There needs to be a mechanism to include the author in the fallout from his comments.

The best I can think of would be connecting posts to the author's Facebook profile. If your friends all see the stuff you write at bbc.co.uk, you'll be a bit more circumspect in what you say.

Generally, posts that the author would be ashamed of if their mother read them are probably something we can do without.

Ideally, we should come up with a mechanism that respects the idea that we all have multiple public personas, i. e. it's completely legitimate to ask a question on a sexual health forum but you still don't want your family to see it. But these 'personas' shouldn't be license to act without taking responsibility for the consequences.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by chrshawkes on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:05PM (#14368948)
Idiots on a forum are not representative of society at large. In my opinion, only the extremes post day and night and I don't bother reading it anymore.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by lamontcg on Thursday May 18, 2017 @05:48PM (#14371401)
Back in the day Usenet was regulated by people complaining to admins or upstream admins. Students would get tempbans for being trolls, people's bosses could be involved. The web of trust between admins who just wanted to keep it all running meant that they policed their users a bit. And it was a lot more civil until we hit Endless September and AOL.

I'm not sure I think this idea of the BBC's is a bad idea.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by interfixus on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:05PM (#14368949)
And who gets to decide what's comme il faut and what is not?
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by matt4077 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @03:17PM (#14370207)
That's kinda the point, thank you very much.

There is a grey area of behaviour that cannot be pinned down with a blunt instrument like criminal law. These behaviours have traditionally been handled by the people witnessing them, and with an equally large spectrum of instruments from just a frown to social exclusion, etc.

So, to directly answer your question: nobody and everybody. By letting the people you actually interact with on a day-to-day basis know what you're writing online, the mechanisms of social control continue to function as they always have.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by kijeda on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:27PM (#14368595)
Seems like this is just a clumsy way of simply saying they are going to contact the administrator of the domain your account is associated with (which may be your employer, school, etc.)
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by blowski on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:29PM (#14368614)
Exactly. We may block your account, and send an email to something like [email protected]. If that happens to be your boss's email address, that's your problem.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by bostonpete on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:39PM (#14368709)
The article says:

"the BBC may use your personal information to inform relevant third parties such as your employer, school email/internet provider"

If your comment was what they intended, they would have just referred to "e-mail provider".

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by dismantlethesun on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:45PM (#14369363)
They are clarifying that they'll talk to everyone in the chain, so you don't think that only Google will hear about it just because your office email is hosted with Gmail.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by ccrush on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:20PM (#14369104)
That happens to be my email.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by JdeBP on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:35PM (#14369809)
Indeed. It seems that some people aren't twigging that the text quoted is part of a privacy policy. It's trying to explain one set of circumstances where the BBC will use and share "personal information" with others and what that may involve if one is (say) using the computers where one works or attends school and that's where tracking back one's IP address leads.

Compare Google's Privacy policy:

> We will share personal information with companies, organisations or individuals outside Google if we have a belief in good faith that access, use, preservation or disclosure of the information is reasonably necessary to:

> + meet any applicable law, regulation, legal process or enforceable governmental request.

> + enforce applicable Terms of Service, including investigation of potential violations.

Or Facebook's:

> We may also access, preserve and share information when we have a good faith belief it is necessary to: detect, prevent and address fraud and other illegal activity; to protect ourselves, you and others, including as part of investigations; or to prevent death or imminent bodily harm.

Or Apple's:

> We may also disclose information about you if we determine that disclosure is reasonably necessary to enforce our terms and conditions or protect our operations or users.

Or Reddit's:

> We may share information if we believe your actions are inconsistent with our user agreements, rules, or other Reddit policies, or to protect the rights, property, and safety of ourselves and others;

Ironically, the BBC is somewhat clearer about whom the information might end up being disclosed to.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by npiazza83 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:43PM (#14369871)
That's why I put in all my contracts that I may personally enforce fines and payment using the client's credit card info that I have incidentally acquired through managing their online services.

I sure hope that's legal!

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by donalhunt on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:49PM (#14369393)
THIS!

Having run a publicly facing messageboard for many years (no auth, just plain old "write what you want (within reason"), we were able to effectively keep the level of spam and abuse off the site with cultural norms within the user base.

In one case, we had someone specifically trolling people on the site. We were able to track the poster back to a particular university in Ireland who we notified via their abuse channel ([email protected] I think) with a very generic query:

"we're seeing someone from your network posting crap like this <link to content>. can you investigate?"

The behaviour stopped pretty quickly afterwards...

Turns out most network operators want to run a network that benefits all it's users. If you abuse that privilege, they have no qualms with disconnecting you!!

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by CaliforniaKarl on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:30PM (#14368623)
Wow, that's confusing.

I know that I know very little about U.K. law, so I would appreciate if someone there could answer:

- Do employers typically have law-enforcement duties?

- Is there a legal presumption of innocence---until proven otherwise---as there is in the U.S.?

- Besides TV Licenses, is the BBC a judicial entity?

I'm just trying to understand why the BBC may notify a non-law-enforcement agency about a possible violation of law.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by matt4077 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:53PM (#14368830)
> why the BBC may notify a non-law-enforcement agency about a possible violation of law

Well, they are journalists, after all :)

More seriously: these is a ton of stuff that happens that is both completely legal and somewhat bad. In the past, this grey area was policed by the community, using standards such as "politeness" or "etiquette" and sanctions such as "no longer inviting that idiot".

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by JdeBP on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:58PM (#14369480)
A lot of people are reading "will" for "may" and getting quite worked up.

A more charitable reading is that this document is a rather ham-fisted way of saying:

We've stated afore that your IP address is one of the pieces of "personal information" that we collect about you. If you ... do this ... then we will use that information to locate and notify the owner of the computers that you are using, or some point in the chain between those computers and us. Be aware that if the owner of the computers that you are using is your school, your employer, your organization, or your Internet service provider, they are likely who is going to be notified and your use of these computers for this purpose will be disclosed to them.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by dboreham on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:38PM (#14369292)
Some aspects of UK and US culture are quite different and I suspect this is one. It has been a while since I lived there but I think the general idea is that it is silly to waste law enforcement resources on absolutely everything. Some things can be dealt with outside of the police and courts. Even the US has this with the RIAA/MPAA able to "tattle" on people who are file sharing directly to their ISP without a police report being filed.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by DanBC on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:46PM (#14369375)
Also, a bit of what the BBC is talking about is either defamation (not something the police get involved with) or "misuse of company resources" - and BBC only wants to use this stick to prevent some of the vile trolling some of their employees have to put up with.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by ghughes on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:58PM (#14368882)
It's got nothing to do with the law. They're notifying third parties about people who they suspect of posting "offensive" content.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by cafard on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:12PM (#14369019)
"Where the BBC reasonably believes that you are or may be in breach of any applicable laws (e.g. because content you have posted may be defamatory), the BBC may use your personal information to inform relevant third parties such as your employer, school email/internet provider or law enforcement, [etc....]"

"in breach of any applicable laws" is not quite the same as "problematic", even under the modern sense of "a problem" or "something we don't like".

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by MichaelGG on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:26PM (#14369160)
They should be turning comments over to the police if they think it's a legal issue. Which makes me think they don't _really_ think it's about illegal comments.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by adamnemecek on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:25PM (#14368560)
Is this another TV detector van? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TV_detector_van
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by JdeBP on Thursday May 18, 2017 @03:39PM (#14370384)
No, it is a WWW site privacy policy. YCombinator's is at http://www.ycombinator.com/legal/ . Others have been mentioned on this page.

You can compare to other privacy policies, and note the somewhat ironic fact that other privacy policies are quite woolly and vague about whom personal information will be disclosed to for the purposes of protecting the site, protecting its users, and enforcing terms and conditions of service. For all users know, these companies and organizations could be disclosing it to some randomly selected stranger in a faraway country. The U.K. Information Commissioner has some guidelines for privacy policies, and making it clear what sort of people personal information will be disclosed to is actually a good thing, even though the BBC has been somewhat inept about it.

* https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protectio...

Rather than the vague "we may disclose information" of Apple, Reddit, and their ilk, the BBC is trying to point out that the people that it may disclose information to are going to be the people discoverable from things like looking up one's IP addresses, which is going to include employers if one posts to the BBC site from company computers, schools if one does so from school computers, and so forth.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by orbitingpluto on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:27PM (#14369182)
Given BBC's coverage as of late, I assume BBC will contact your boss if you make a pro-Corbyn statement.

This story reminded me of Rep. Rodney Frelinghuysen trying to get an anti-Trumper fired from her position at a bank by outing her to her boss. (https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2017/5/15/15640534/r...)

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by threatofrain on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:21PM (#14369116)
Is it problematic if you espouse beliefs about Brexit on BBC's website? Uh oh. Careful, your boss might know you have unsavory political beliefs.

If a person speaks illegally on a forum, then the right move would be to contact law enforcement. But if the action falls below law enforcement, then apparently the BBC has its own enforcement wing when it encounters unsavory speech. The oversight? BBC's cold cultural calculations and political acumen. The consequences? Getting someone fired or harassed at work.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by theandrewbailey on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:49PM (#14368789)
If so, I have a feeling that all those disclaimers stating "my opinions do not represent my employer's views" are going to have a very different meaning.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by stubadub on Thursday May 18, 2017 @07:35PM (#14371930)
This sounds like it would be a breach of the UK Data Protection Act

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/29/contents

Information shared with third party without consent Providing personal details to a family member without consent

Any organisation that stores and uses personal data relating to identifiable living individuals, either on a computer or in a paper filing system, is a "data controller" for the purposes of the DPA. Data controllers are obliged to handle personal data in accordance with the eight data-protection principles set out in schedule 1 to the DPA unless a specific exemption applies. The first principle is that data must be processed fairly and lawfully, which requires any processing (including disclosure) to be done either with the consent of the individual or in order to fulfil legal obligations such as contractual obligations. This disclosure would be a serious breach of privacy.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by JdeBP on Friday May 19, 2017 @02:15AM (#14373371)
Now see the Information Commissioner guidance for privacy policies that I hyperlinked at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14370384 .

Whilst most privacy policies do not say whom the data are shared with when it comes to enforcing terms and conditions and protecting the site/its users, the BBC's privacy policy here is. The UKICO guidelines point out that part of fairness is telling people whom data are going to be disclosed to; which the BBC is doing.

If one has a gripe against that, then one has a gripe against everyone, from Reddit to Amazon. Because all of their privacy policies have clauses that say, in one form or another, that personal information is disclosed in order to enforce terms and conditions, and to protect the site/its users. Reddit's and several others' are elsewhere on this page. Here is Amazon's:

> We release account and other personal information when we believe release is appropriate to comply with the law; enforce or apply our Conditions of Use and other agreements; or protect the rights, property or safety of Amazon.co.uk, our users or others.

Ironically, the BBC is actually attempting to be the best of the bunch. Other people actually do not comply with the UKICO guidelines and make no mention of whom the data are disclosed to in such cases. They just make vague "we disclose data" statements.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by LinuxBender on Thursday May 18, 2017 @04:01PM (#14370622)
Unless my post is related to my workplace, I am certain my employer would just tell them to play hide and go f themselves and to stop wasting their time.

This seems to me an attempt to get folks spun up talking about the BBC. Are they hurting for money?

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by merpnderp on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:24PM (#14369146)
Then I'm glad I'm in the US and work for an organization far more interested in preserving our fragile and shrinking individual rights than policing naughty thoughts on the interwebs.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by mnm1 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:58PM (#14369469)
Simply don't comment on any site/app that has your real information. Imagine that. Problems solved. Lots of them.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by ghostDancer on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:38PM (#14369287)
If you don't behave , BBC will tell your parents. No dessert this week.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by killjoywashere on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:36PM (#14369273)
"BBC Rule 9" is going to be a meme with a history similar to using "cuil" as a unit of measure, and "Wadsworth constant". Interesting, possibly even valid, but no one cares.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by leephillips on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:10PM (#14368997)
Wow, I haven't heard of anyone doing this since Dave Winer.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by MichaelGG on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:20PM (#14369099)
So if someone's BBC account gets hacked, or an attacker otherwise forges a comment, how's that going to play out when someone gets incorrectly dismissed?
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by knorker on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:26PM (#14369164)
I'll just contact them with a complaint.

Oh, error 504 gateway timeout. Maybe this article crashed their complaints department.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by arjie on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:35PM (#14368663)
Dude. It just means that if you abuse from [email protected], then example.com is going to be informed that you're spamming from them or whatever.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by Fifer82 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:56PM (#14368863)
Ahh UK State Media. I swiftly cancelled my Licence after the Scottish Indy Ref. I say let the licence fee collapse.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by CommanderData on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:05PM (#14368942)
So it becomes funded by the UK tax system? They are already contemplating scrapping the fee and increasing taxes to pay for BBC.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by Fifer82 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:19PM (#14369086)
Hopefully we will bail from UK this time and it won't be a problem.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by CommanderData on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:36PM (#14369274)
I doubt Scotland will be leaving the UK, its pretty clear Tories can't risk loosing Scotland.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by s73ver on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:25PM (#14368571)
If you post harassing comments, this probably should happen. People are going to be concerned about free speech, but harassment isn't free speech, and I honestly don't believe it's a "slippery slope".
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by drspacemonkey on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:33PM (#14368652)
The problem comes down to the definition of "harassment". I've encountered my fair share of people, some in positions of authority and/or should know better, who honestly believe that disagreement or impolite comments constitute "harassment".

Frankly, I'm not at all comfortable with a global media outlet reserving the right to try to get people fired in private for internet comments.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by mavdi on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:46PM (#14368764)
How about we start with racism? Some things are a grey area but some are downright harassment.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by zo1 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:19PM (#14369668)
You make that sound so simple with "racism". Yet here we are, 2017, and we still have swathes of people that think it's A-OK to be racist towards white people (or sexist towards men). And it magically doesn't count as racism because something something "institutionalized" magic definitions.

http://www.timeslive.co.za/local/2017/04/17/Huffington-Post-...

We can't even hold media, individual reporters or even public officials to account for posting false stories or false claims.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by MichaelGG on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:31PM (#14369227)
Seeing how the label "racism" is thrown around like crazy, I hardly find that to be a non-grey area.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by drspacemonkey on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:42PM (#14369333)
A racist comment can be rude, disrespectful, mean, or ignorant without being harassment. Then there's the more complicated issue of the term "racism", which I think you'll concur does not have a universally-agreed-upon definition.

By all means, delete such comments and ban the offending commenters (or even report them to the police if applicable), but reserving the right to try to get people fired is going too far. Internet vigilante justice is ugly and brutal, and I am not at all comfortable with the BBC getting involved in that game.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by SomeStupidPoint on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:35PM (#14369259)
Are critical comments about Islam, as a religion, racism? How about pointed comments about Israel's settlements?

Because I've heard people try to construe both as such.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by s73ver on Thursday May 18, 2017 @04:32PM (#14370840)
Most people who claim they're making critical comments just aren't.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by MrZongle2 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:01PM (#14368917)
What about pornography? Some things are in a grey area but some are downright naughty.

Same thing: the extremes are easy to label. The question is where do you draw the line between showing an ankle or face, and full-out copulation in 4K?

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by utternerd on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:33PM (#14368653)
> If you post or send offensive, inappropriate or objectionable content

Unfortunately it's not confined to simply "harassment" but anything "offensive, inappropriate or objectionable" by their own wording, which is highly subjective. If there's a legal issue, BBC should contact law enforcement, but beyond that informing others feels entirely punitive.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by Zenst on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:46PM (#14368766)
BBC staff caught watching TV without a TV liscense are subject to instant dismissal. Been the case for eons that company rule and that seems perfectly fair. But that is clear cut and defined upfront in the employment contract. This as you highlight is subjective and no clearly defined lines and that as you say is the job of the police. Indeed this action by them does open them up to the police being involved against them.

If anything, this opens up many opportunities of abuse from nefarious and mischief inclined people.

Lesson to take from this is, don't do personal stuff upon work computers period. That should be the take away message about this type of issue. Remember many an employment contract prohibit that and it is often overlooked if not abused, this may just become that abuse nail example you encounter with HR. Let alone the security aspects for you and your employer, your cloud drive getting a malware payload not impossible and vice versa.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by DanBC on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:34PM (#14369252)
> This as you highlight is subjective and no clearly defined lines and that as you say is the job of the police

Defamation is unlawful and is never investigated nor prosecuted by police.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by logfromblammo on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:36PM (#14369278)
That doesn't seem "perfectly fair"; it seems needlessly stupid.

If it is really that important, the company should just purchase the licenses for their employees, as a perquisite. Then it no longer has the need to police the private lives of its workers, in order to see if they need to be fired for illicit, unlicensed television-watching.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by maxpblum on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:31PM (#14368637)
What do you mean when you say you don't believe it's a "slippery slope"? That the proper boundaries are obvious to everyone?

I think the reason this is okay is that notifying a school or employer of your behavior is not the same as persecution.

Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by makomk on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:21PM (#14369113)
There's this idea I've seen a lot lately amongst social justice activists that the correct boundaries are obvious and a simple matter of common decency, and that anyone who dares to question this by asking where they should be placed is simply obfuscating to justify bigotry and harassment. Of course, no two people's idea of where the obvious, clear boundaries are is actually the same, it's just they don't generally realise this because it's never discussed. Occasionally something happens that different members of the community do see differently and all hell breaks loose.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by s73ver on Thursday May 18, 2017 @04:36PM (#14370879)
Many times, the "asking questions" thing is done not in good faith, and that's why it's dismissed out of hand.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by subway on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:38PM (#14368703)
I see no problem with giving someone a heads up that they've employed an asshole.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by pyre on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:58PM (#14368881)
The problem with this is that things change from time to time. Replace "asshole" with "Japanese sympathizer" during/after World War 2, or "Communist sympathizer" during the reign of McCarthyism. Would you be so quick to say that this is a good thing then?
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by chrshawkes on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:09PM (#14368986)
Who's your employer?
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by subway on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:22PM (#14369699)
It's readily available if you google my name and usernames; available in my profile.
Re:BBC Says It May Contact Your Boss If You Post Comments It... by chrshawkes on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:07PM (#14368970)
I'm glad you don't call the shots.