News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by Fricken on Sunday May 14, 2017 @01:57PM (#14336660)
I had a phase of clinical depression, a long time ago now, but I started sleeping in the 14 inch gap between the bed and the wall, to feel squeezed. I did that for months. Who cares what somebody else's science says about it? I liked it and I did it. Does an extra heavy blanket sound nice to you? Then get one. Or don't.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by URSpider94 on Sunday May 14, 2017 @02:08PM (#14336731)
Yes, exactly. Get one, or don't. But the seller shouldn't tell people that their blanket cures these disorders, unless they have some proof.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by naravara on Sunday May 14, 2017 @02:29PM (#14336868)
They never said it cured it. They said it can help.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by justinpombrio on Sunday May 14, 2017 @02:51PM (#14336962)
Look, there's no need to have vague arguments about how we would describe their claims. Here is the wording they removed:

"The science behind Gravity reveals that it can be used to treat a variety of ailments, including insomnia, post-traumatic stress disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder, as well as circumstantial stress and prolonged anxiety."

Assuming that "can be used to treat" means what I think it does, this is simply false: the science doesn't show that. And regardless, claims of this form are specifically forbidden by Kickstarter, which prohibits "any item claiming to cure, treat, or prevent an illness or condition". So they removed this claim, like they should have.

None of this contradicts the fact that you might want to buy one of these blankets if you have insomnia, etc.

Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by naravara on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:58AM (#14342575)
This is a lot of sturm-und-drang over nothing. These arguments aren't "vague," the meanings of the words involved are pretty clear. People routinely offer suggestions about how to deal with emotional and physical issues based on anecdotes or claims that a few studies here and there offer evidence that maybe there is something to it. Lots of things people do to handle their issues, especially emotionally, wouldn't pass a clinical trial because those standards are extremely rigorous (and they should be) and it can be impractical or unethical to perform a sufficiently well controlled test.

But just because it's not adequately supported to pass a clinical trial doesn't mean there isn't something to it or even that claims are "unsupported." You can support a claim lots of ways, including with anecdotes or even just inductive reasoning. It's one thing to say that it doesn't clear the bar for proof we expect of the FDA or to establish a scientific consensus, but that's different from intimating that they're liars.

They made a mistake in their ad copy, that's clear enough. But mistakes like these are common when amateurs try to start up a business or pursue an interest. Claims that they're snake-oil salesmen or frauds because they spoke colloquially, rather than couching terms in the vague messaging of people steeped in the business culture and lingo of health supplements, pharmaceuticals, or medical device manufacturers is really excessive.

Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by fapjacks on Monday May 15, 2017 @02:57AM (#14339700)
Just to add to what you said, the reason that language is prohibited by Kickstarter is because it's prohibited by the FDA. Specifically those words.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by kortex on Sunday May 14, 2017 @05:04PM (#14337565)
I, for one, am sick of the constant stream of products that "may possibly support the promotion of boosting of enhancement of the body's natural immune functioning in conjunction with diet and exercise". It's obnoxiously dilute and I think nearly everything in the supplement aisle claims to help with immune, anxiety and/or digestion in some way.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by naravara on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:03PM (#14342630)
People have been eating roots and plants to help with digestion, anxiety, etc. since before the invention of writing and probably before the invention of fire. Of course there's going to be a bajillion remedies asserting something to that effect. We've been at it for a while.

Products are vague about their wording because they're legally required to be.

Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by wcummings on Sunday May 14, 2017 @02:41PM (#14336919)
They shouldn't tell people it treats them.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by URSpider94 on Sunday May 14, 2017 @02:44PM (#14336930)
... for which they have no evidence.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by WillPostForFood on Sunday May 14, 2017 @06:24PM (#14337887)
There are two studies cited in the article, they both appear very weak, but they are citing evidence.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by obstinate on Sunday May 14, 2017 @08:40PM (#14338337)
Normally when people talk about citing evidence, they're referring to strong evidence. Citing weak evidence can be about as bad as citing none at all, depending on how weak it is.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by rosser on Sunday May 14, 2017 @02:45PM (#14336938)
Claiming to have a "cure" isn't the only thing that's against these rules.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by lucasmullens on Sunday May 14, 2017 @04:12PM (#14337338)
I'm not sure why this is downvoted so heavily. It's an important clarification that they didn't claim they could cure disorders, only help with them. Yes, that's also not legal, but this comment wasn't disagreeing with that.

Claiming a cure would be a far bigger news story.

Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by DanBC on Sunday May 14, 2017 @04:19PM (#14337368)
It's being downvoted because it's a meaningless distinction.

The makers made a medical claim. They had no evidence to support that claim. They've withdrawn the claim.

It doesn't matter if they claimed "helps with" or "cures".

Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by tedmiston on Sunday May 14, 2017 @02:00PM (#14336679)
The concern I might have with it is if they raised the money with the claim then removed the claim after people had pledged. It wasn't clear to me from the article what the timeline was with changing the language and the end of the campaign.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by stefanwlb on Sunday May 14, 2017 @02:21PM (#14336819)
Shouldn't there be some protection from editing original claims, and if changed, that its clear when and what changed in the wording? I find the whole thing ridiculous.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by egypturnash on Sunday May 14, 2017 @04:19PM (#14337366)
FWIW, Kickstarter won't let you change the text of a reward tier as long as someone's pledged for it. You can change the text of the main pitch all you like, though.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by tdburn on Sunday May 14, 2017 @03:23PM (#14337112)
You can cancel and get a refund before the campaign fundraising period ends
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by gnicholas on Sunday May 14, 2017 @04:47PM (#14337500)
Good point. For major edits like this — especially where claims violated Kickstarter's TOS — it would seem appropriate to require the creator to send a message to all backers that communicates the change and the reason for it. Otherwise many backers might not find out about the changed language.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by mst on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:16PM (#14338706)
Per dstaley's comment up-thread, apparently they did send out a message explaining it.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by gnicholas on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:18AM (#14339129)
Thanks, this comment came a couple hours later so I hadn't seen it. I wonder if Kickstarter required them to send it or if it was voluntary.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by WillPostForFood on Sunday May 14, 2017 @06:26PM (#14337891)
You don't even need to get a refund. Kickstarter doesn't collect money until the end of the campaign, so you can change, withdraw, increase your pledge as much as you want with a couple clicks.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by dstaley on Sunday May 14, 2017 @07:06PM (#14338000)
Gravity backer here. They sent out an email to all the backers about the change.

> That said, we wanted to clarify that our blanket is not an FDA approved medical device, and as such, we've tweaked the language on our Kickstarter accordingly. We hope you understand, and we’re very excited for you to try this out for yourselves.

Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by coldtea on Sunday May 14, 2017 @08:04PM (#14338222)
>Who cares what somebody else's science says about it?

People that dislike snake oil salesmen and don't think there is "my science" and "somebody else's science", but just one science?

Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by obstinate on Sunday May 14, 2017 @08:38PM (#14338330)
Precisely. I have no problem hearing about what worked for you. The moment you start telling someone else it'll work for them, especially if you're looking to get paid based on that claim, you better back it up with evidence.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by mst on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:15PM (#14338703)
I read that to mean "somebody else's scientific (counter)claims", similar to how en_US might contain "according to person X's math". Took me a while to stop being annoyed by the latter, admittedly.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by ebbv on Sunday May 14, 2017 @02:48PM (#14336952)
If they had just advertised it as "a heavy blanket" do you think it would have gotten funding?

It got funding because they made unsubstantiated medical claims, which is illegal for good reason. Otherwise I could sell you "anti-cancer rocks" from my driveway.

Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by DonHopkins on Sunday May 14, 2017 @05:22PM (#14337649)
Maybe so, but then you'd be misrepresenting anti-tiger rocks as anti-cancer rocks.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xSVqLHghLpw

Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by vilhelm_s on Sunday May 14, 2017 @07:36PM (#14338118)
Tons of people (particularly on the autism spectrum) like weighted blankets, I don't think it's unreasonable that such a project could get kickstarted.
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by mst on Sunday May 14, 2017 @10:17PM (#14338712)
My anecdata matches yours here (notably I know multiple people with both autism and anxiety issues who swear by weighted blankets for helping them sleep).
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by Broken_Hippo on Sunday May 14, 2017 @02:05PM (#14336713)
The problem is more about not having customers expect the blanket to cure their psychiatric problems. Such language makes it easy to take advantage of someone who isn't in a mentally strong place at the moment - and puts their hopes of being "normal" into such products when the evidence isn't there.

I don't think the product itself is so bad: I like the weight of blankets when I sleep and like them to touch the bed on both sides of me. I'd completely understand a lightweight but weighted blanket during the summer, and I'm guessing it would make some folks feel comforted and so on. I'd much rather them have this sort of honesty in their advertising than the language they had.

Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by DonHopkins on Sunday May 14, 2017 @05:16PM (#14337625)
Will it cancel out the therapeutic effects of my Space Blanket?
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by robg on Sunday May 14, 2017 @06:26PM (#14337895)
You would agree though that a blanket that claims to cure, without evidence, is misleading and should be regulated?
Re:Makers of Crowdfunded “Gravity Blanket” Withdraw Unsuppor... by draw_down on Sunday May 14, 2017 @04:57PM (#14337534)
Oh wow, I did that for a long time too. I don't even remember when I stoped.